This eclectic book synthesizes a large body of research on the phenomenon of self-sacrifice. It offers the reader a comprehensive treatment of a subject that, perhaps unfortunately, remains timely and relevant for scholarly and policy communities concerned about resurgent violence in the Muslim world. In a single volume, Meir Hatina explores martyrdom in religious and secular struggles; Islamic and non-Islamic societies; Sunni and Shiite traditions; classical Islamic jurisprudence and modern Islamist ideology; and national and transnational conflicts. For good measure, Hatina incorporates a plethora of Arabic primary and secondary sources in addition to Hebrew, German, and English ones. Some may criticize Martyrdom in Modern Islam for its wide breadth and insufficient depth, but this would be an unfair criticism. This is a very good book, well researched and written, with an important contribution to make. While not an encyclopedia on martyrdom, it can substitute as such given the range of topics it covers, as well as the quality and quantity of it citations. The argument of the book, while short of being compelling, is worth considering carefully.
Hatina’s purpose is to make a case for the “important role of convictions and belief in a cause to the point of dying for them” (p. 1). Critical of social scientific approaches that reduce martyrdom to personal motivations and utilitarian preferences, the author explores the totality of modern-day martyrdom, including its “ideological, symbolic, social, and political aspects” (p. 13). Indeed, argues Hatina, martyrdom is a multilayered act that cannot be intelligibly reduced to individual choices or organizational instrumentality; it is simultaneously violence toward an adversary, a pathway to personal redemption for the faithful, an invitation for others to sacrifice, a message to empower one’s community, an affirmation of a collective identity, and an effective instrument in contests over power.
The main thesis of the book is that martyrdom is not just an act by an inspired individual eager to die for a cause. It is a discursively constructed phenomenon anchored in historical, political, and cultural narratives that frame acts of self-sacrifice as heroic, while simultaneously delineating them from fanatical terrorism. As Hatina emphasizes, “the martyr has no existence without memorialization, commemoration, and narration” (p. 7). “Interpretive communities,” in the crucibles of sectarian, ethnic, and political struggles, “imbue martyrs with significance and influence” (pp. 7–8). This constructivist approach to the phenomenon of martyrdom does not emphasize ideational framing at the expense of rational, instrumental politics. Instead, it insists on the proper contextualization of martyrdom in both the political and ideational. Both have their places in the explanation of martyrdom—neither is comprehensible without the other.
While the book’s title betrays its emphasis on contemporary Muslim martyrdom, the author is keen to present a historical and comparative perspective. His first two chapters take the reader back to ancient Jewish, Christian, and Muslim martyrdom narratives. This discussion is intended to show both continuity and rupture between historical and contemporary martyrdom. As the author notes in relation to Muslim martyrs, “the twin ideas of jihad and martyrdom [in classical Islam] did not necessarily determine the course of Muslim history” (p. 50). He adds that “the motif of martyrdom evoked varied interpretations” (p. 231), and the core of the book wonderfully illustrates the many forms of martyrdom, ranging from “defensive” communal and ethno-nationalist martyrdom (e.g., Muslim Brotherhood in the 1930s and 1940s; Hezbollah since the 1980s; Hamas since the 1990s), to the more offensive martyrdom of revolutionary Islamist (e.g., Sayyid Qutb and his radical scions in Egypt from the 1960s to the 1990s) and transnational jihadists (e.g., Al Qaeda and the Islamic State). Each form of martyrdom was justified through reference to religious traditions and texts, but one form cannot be considered an equivalent of the other. Context and interpretive predilections, then as now, shape how martyrdom is defined, deployed, and venerated.
This line of argumentation is convincing, but it seems to undermine the author’s rejection of instrumentalism. If the religious text is only meaningful by understanding the sociopolitical context, then why not just adopt a strictly instrumental explanation of martyrdom? Religion is what we make of it. The author falls back on the assertion that religion’s purpose “is to provide meaning to a given reality” (p. 15). In other words, religion is a useful discursive field in which acts of self-sacrifice are made meaningful to the individual, his or her supportive community, and external observers that stand to condone or condemn these acts. Without a meaningful narrative to frame the act of martyrdom, it becomes difficult to inspire individuals to step forward as willing martyrs, recruit others to the cause, maintain societal support for extraordinary measures, and affirm the sanctity of the cause, be it national liberation, social revolution, or global war.
Hatina’s argument falls short of convincing the reader because of his observation that “of the three radical narratives, only the ethno-national one gained wide theological backing from the broad center of the Islamic spectrum” (p. 235). If so, then he is truly in trouble. As others and I have observed, the global jihadists have mobilized more suicide bombers than all other movements—Islamic and non-Islamic—combined (see Mohammed M. Hafez, Suicide Bombers in Iraq, 2007, and Assaf Moghadam, The Globalization of Martyrdom, 2008). Despite their failure to earn the approval of bona fide Islamic authorities such as Yusuf al-Qaradawi and Salman al-Ouda, global jihadists since the 1990s have been able to recruit and deploy suicide bombers seemingly without limits.
Just as importantly, the martyrs of global jihad, contrary to Hatina’s earlier assertion, exist without “memorialization, commemoration, and narration.” To be sure, there is a lot of martyrdom veneration by Al Qaeda, but their martyrdom biographies and commemorative montages are not easy to locate, as they tend to reside deep inside obscure forums that only the most determined viewer (usually other jihadists and intelligence analysts) can find. Moreover, governments such as Jordan and Saudi Arabia deliberately offer counternarratives that portray these martyrs as duped youth who are manipulated into killing fellow Muslims. Yet we continue to see high levels of support and volunteerism from those two countries, among many others.
These observations do not negate Hatina’s general argument about the significance of religious narratives in support of martyrdom because it is true, as Thomas Hegghammer points out in his book Jihad in Saudi Arabia (2010), that earlier support for self-sacrifice in nationalist struggles (Palestine, Afghanistan, Bosnia, and Chechnya) became the scaffolding upon which global jihadists constructed their own martyrdom narratives. But it is also true that sustained attacks on the legitimacy of jihadist narratives of martyrdom since 9/11 have not deterred thousands of Muslim youths from volunteering to fight and die as martyrs for Al Qaeda and its affiliates.
In addition to this critique, the book’s organization struck me as a bit odd. Chapter 8, “Approaching ‘Suicide’ Attacks,” which is a literature review of extant scholarship on the topic, should have been located in the introduction or the opening chapter. There is no logical reason to make it the penultimate chapter, and it seemed to add little to the argument, but it affirms the book’s value as a comprehensive text on the subject.
This is a mere quibble with an otherwise comprehensive, well-researched, and easily readable book that could inform undergraduates, postgraduates, and government analysts on a timely and important topic.
