No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 September 2004
In an engaging account of the professionalization of the traveling salesman, Walter Friedman traces the history of “salesmanship” and outlines the institutional developments that framed the marketing of increasingly complex goods to the American consumer. Regarding salespeople and their techniques as both underappreciated and appropriately reviled by the consuming public at various points in history, Friedman successfully demonstrates the integral nature of the sales profession to modern capitalism. Economic growth based on the advent of mass production would not have been as rapid if it were not for the large professional sales forces that emerged early in the twentieth century. Nevertheless, many of the guiding principles of this new generation of salesmen were already being used by their nineteenth-century counterparts.
In the first half of the book, each chapter focuses on a category of face-to-face transactions emblematic of the era being discussed. Stories of mid-nineteenth-century peddlers illustrate the difficulty of being an outsider trying to sell goods door-to-door. As selling techniques continued to develop, instructional materials advised salesmen to use emotional ploys to increase sales. For example, canvassers selling Ulysses S. Grant's memoir in the 1880s were likely to be military veterans, armed with manuals urging them to use flattery and maintain eye contact with prospective buyers (pp. 45–9). (These strategies were highly successful as the country mourned the President's passing.) Around the turn of the century, H. J. Heinz built a brand empire through advertising and by paying his salesmen commission on sales to grocers. Taken together, these chapters effectively outline the evolution of selling practices throughout the nineteenth century. With the rise of big business in the United States, both advertising and marketing became more important, transforming the vocation of the traveling salesman from then on.
In the early part of the twentieth century, Friedman argues, the rise of mass production in the United States was supported by “mass salesmanship,” the persuasive skills of an emerging professional class of traveling salesmen. These skills were not merely the product of door-to-door experience, but were taught by employers who needed rapid growth of sales to justify high volumes of output from large-scale operation. As Alfred Chandler (Scale and Scope: The Dynamics of Industrial Capitalism. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1990: 31) has pointed out, the “sales force became the most dependable instrument for obtaining and holding a market share large enough to assure the cost advantages of scale.” In addition to these scale advantages, national advertising and the professionalized sales force were complementary economic institutions, encouraging consumers and businesspeople to accept new technologies and branded merchandise. The traveling salesmen Friedman discusses sell a range of goods: sewing machines and cash registers to automobiles and Coca-Cola. Put differently, the twentieth century saw salesmanship evolve from a rhetorical sensitivity to consumer needs toward rhetorical strategies that cultivated the desire for goods.
Perhaps the most interesting and important chapter in the book details the organizational innovations carried out by John H. Patterson, head of National Cash Register (NCR). Following the ideas of scientific management expounded by Frederick W. Taylor, Patterson tried to standardize and control the marketing of his cash registers. He hired regional sales managers, and used strong commission incentives with very tight quotas for his salesmen (pp. 118, 128). Sales pitches were scripted and rehearsed. Patterson also enlisted the salesmen's wives, urging them to be cheerful and make sure their husbands ate right and exercised (p. 140). In the case of NCR, such control led to abuse of power—Friedman discusses various unethical business practices and apparent antitrust violations, although Patterson never served any jail time (pp. 144–47). Did the application of the principles of scientific management to sales necessarily contribute to unethical business practices or was this an isolated case? Friedman does not address this issue, but argues that Patterson's lasting impact was felt through the men who worked under him and later moved to other companies (pp. 149–50).
Friedman cleverly uses the Depression era to assess the resilience of the institution of mass salesmanship. While employers shifted their compensation schemes toward commission sales, national advertising continued to be critical to the survival of big business (p. 235). The pattern of advertising spending remained similar to that before the Depression, with technologically advanced goods having the highest advertising expense ratios (p. 237). Although pushed harder by their employers, salesmen at the end of the 1930s were organized much as they had been in the 1920s.
In the conclusion, Friedman makes a heroic effort to complete the story of advertising and salesmanship in the present day, linking it to the work of recent Nobel-prize winners in economics. Ultimately, the leap to the twenty-first century and recent economic theory does not quite work, but it still makes for very interesting reading.