Between 1934 and 1940, and again between 1970 and 1976, the leaders of Mexico adopted a ‘populist’ presidential style, visiting the countryside, breaking tortillas with poor peasants, avoiding the most egregious forms of self-enrichment and declaiming the importance of revolutionary action. Whereas the first president, Lázaro Cárdenas, matched rhetoric with results, handing out over 18 million hectares of land to rural Mexicans, the second president, Luis Echeverría, did not. Stage-managed tours, long-winded Castro-esque speeches and a huipil-clad wife failed to disguise ineffective social reforms and the systematic repression of agrarian radicalism. As Alan Knight succinctly puts it in his essay, ‘Echeverría emulated Cárdenas's peripatetics, but not his policies’ (p. 21). Despite the clear differences between these two politicians, the adoption of this ‘populist style’ forms the basis of this collection of essays. By comparing Cárdenas and Echeverría, the contributors are asked to ponder the ramifications of both presidents' taste for ‘campesino chic’.
I shall come back to the fundamental framework for the collection later on, but, unsurprisingly, given the quality of historians brought together to scrutinise this question, there are some excellent articles. Knight's elegantly written piece contrasts the two presidencies, concluding that while there were some superficial (perhaps quite self-conscious) links, contrasting political systems, economic climates and personal ideologies led to very different outcomes. Whereas Cárdenas' land reforms permitted the Mexican peasantry to till their lands for another generation, Echeverría distributed poor-quality lands, upped rural corruption and encouraged the army to turf uncooperative peasants into unmarked graves. As one wit put it, ‘Cárdenas gave the peasants guns, Echeverría gave them a bullet’. Diane Davis' article, which outlines changes in policing policies from the 1930s to the 1970s, is also fascinating. Her work on the institutional roots of police corruption and popular resistance begs for more space. Michael Snodgrass' piece, which looks at labour policy, is an excellent, clear summary of changing relationships between the state and the unions during the years of the ‘Mexican miracle’. Alexander Aviña makes a valiant, if marginally less successful, stab at this same game, outlining state–peasant relations in Guerrero over the same period. Gabriela Soto Laveaga's article on the unintended consequences of Echeverría's attempts to create unions of barbasco producers in southern Mexico is also exciting. Eschewing the approaches of Davis, Snodgrass and Aviña, which basically employ the editors' framework to bookend historical narratives, Soto Laveaga pays particular attention to how Oaxaca's peasants reinterpreted Echeverría's populist grandstanding and used these promises to push for further reforms. The piece is clear, well researched and convincing.
Flanked by these ambitious contributions, other pieces take more micro-historical approaches, attempting to draw out broader conclusions from single events. María L. O. Muñoz looks at the ramifications of the 1975 National Indigenous Congress, ‘exploring the issue of agency through a Gramscian interpretation of hegemonic/counterhegemonic rapport’. Rather than viewing the congress as a vehicle to co-opt indigenous groups, she argues that Echeverría's rhetoric of indigenous autonomy ‘empowered’ indigenous groups by offering them a language to express their grievances. Amelia M. Kiddle and Joseph U. Lenti examine Cárdenas' state-sponsored funeral as a piece of political theatre. They argue that the event provided an opportunity both for Echeverría to adopt and distort Tata Lázaro's legacy and for ordinary people to express a ‘plea for help in improving their lives’.
My only problem with the book as whole, and this does not undermine the quality of the individual essays, is the conceptual framework of populism. Beyond a strangely inconclusive historiographical aside, the editors make little effort to define what they mean by populism. Instead they follow Knight's carefully formulated argument that populism is a political style rather than a specific set of policies. Yet, again and again, other contributors fail to follow the script, conflating style and substance, employing their own phrases or ignoring the term altogether. Emily Wakild argues that ‘resource populism’, defined as the ‘explicit creation of policies claiming state control over natural resources’, was a ‘critical element of Cárdenas's political style’. Aviña applies the term ‘neopopulism’ to describe Echeverría's blend of pan o palo realpolitik. Guillermo Palacios just ignores the framework and uses the pages to describe the institutionalisation of sociology and anthropology departments during the 1930s and 1940s, and Cuauhtémoc Cárdenas, in a weirdly out-of-place preface, counters the entire premise of the tome by asserting that ‘Lázaro Cárdenas, as a politician and as a public figure, cannot, from any point of view, be considered a populist’. At the same time, as well as some confusion over populism's meaning, there is little mention of the changing means by which this political style was delivered. Beyond a few notable exceptions, few authors acknowledge that by 1970 most Mexicans absorbed Echeverría's populist posturing not through one-off burro-powered visits but through radio and television. You do not have to be Marshall McLuhan to think that this may have affected popular responses to the manifestations of political power.
Despite these minor problems, together these articles start to shed some light on the complex relationships between the president, the party and popular groups, especially during the 1970s. Undeniably, studying Echeverría's regime outside the context of the preceding three decades is very difficult. But, if done well, as is the case in many of these essays, the blend of federal sources, printed documents, transnational viewpoints and oral histories can be enlightening. Although the idea of populism seems to have been grafted on as an afterthought, as stand-alone pieces many of the articles are very good and could be used in undergraduate and graduate classes with ease.
