1
14th Earl of Derby* to 3rd Earl of Malmesbury,* MP 9M73/451/1/1
29 February 1852
St James's Square
Together with Lord Cowley's* despatches, I send you a note I have just received from the Queen.* I have told Her Majesty that I agree in her opinions, but fear we cannot effectively interfere as Austria is acting in concert with France, Russia will not recognise Switzerland, & Prussia will make no objection.Footnote 1 We are to have another Council on Friday at 3 – in case you have any business to be done there. [. . .]
[Enclosure: Queen Victoria to Derby, 29 February 1852, MP 9M73/451/1/2]
The Queen returns the enclosed despatches to Lord Derby & hopes that he will give his fullest consideration to the pretensions which France now puts forward with regard to Switzerland. The Queen cannot consider them in any other light than as establishing an entirely new principle of international law, which if admitted, will put an end to the independence of all smaller states, to which it may in turn be applied, as in fact it will make their internal government dependent upon the momentary interests & arbitrary demands of their more powerful neighbours. There is nothing M. Turgot* says of the inconvenience to France of the internal state of Switzerland which Europe at large might not have applied with greater justice to France herself ever since 1848.
2
Malmesbury to Derby, DP 920 DER (14) 144/1
29 February 1852
Since the Queen saw Ld Cowley[’]s despatch to wh she alludes one has arrived from McGinnis [sic]Footnote 2 at Berne stating the Federal Govt. to be more tractable.
The dispatches today from Russia declare Nesselrode* to be most anxious for our reconciliation with Austria — Tomorrow I see the for[eign] ministers & I wd not do so till I had got hold of the points.
I can't help thinking that if we are in long enough we shall get our old friends right. —
Just arrived
Vienna dispatches
nothingFootnote 3
[Note added at end of letter:]
Berlin
The D[uke]. of Augustenberg* [sic] has refused the pecuniary compensation from Denmark (wh opens that question again)Footnote 4 but the Court of PrussiaFootnote 5 will do her best to persuade him to do so —
3
Malmesbury to Derby, DP 920 DER (14) 144/1
‘Monday’ [1 March 1852]Footnote 6
Foreign Office
I have had my levée — I am to see Walewski* tomorrow as the Swiss question is the most pressingFootnote 7 — I wish to know under the present circumstances whether it wd not be well to suggest that we might consent to the President[’]s demand as regards certain French refugées [sic] at this moment obnoxious to him if he will on his part consent to waive that portion of his demand as to all future refugeesFootnote 8 — I think all Europe except perhaps Austria wd oppose this latter assertion of power —
[P.S.] I shall see Buol* & Van de Weyer* tomorrow.—
What ‘reparation’ do you think ought to satisfy Mr. Mather?Footnote 9 It was a blunder of Granville* not to hold the Tuscan Govt. entirely responsible from the beginning —
4
Malmesbury to Derby, DP 920 DER (14) 144/1
‘Wednesday’ [3 March 1852]Footnote 10
I have taken a copy of yr paperFootnote 11 wh is admirable —
I think it will be as well to see Buol tomorrow — We shd not look too much in a hurry, but if you think otherwise I will send for him sooner.
5
Derby to Malmesbury, DP 920 DER (14) 180/1, fos 21–22Footnote 12
4 March 1852
The Queen has not sent back the draftFootnote 13 and till she has, I think you had better avoid, if possible, reading the draft to Buol, or if you do, read it as a ‘mere sketch’ subject to alteration, but merely prepared as a basis, on which you may be prepared privately to negotiate with him for the removal of a vexatious obstacle to a good understanding. But you must not show your hand without making him show his also: and he must give you satisfactory explanations and conclude in civiller terms than the language of P. Schwarzenberg's* despatch,Footnote 14 or he can have nothing from us. [. . .]
6
Derby to Queen Victoria, DP 920 DER (14) 179/2, fos 60–63
11 March 1852
Lord D[erby] &c – submits to Y[our].M[ajesty]. two despatches received yesterday by Count Buol & communicated by him to Ld. Malmesbury & himself after post-time yest[erda]y. under date of the 5th inst. from Vienna. Ld D trusts that the communication of these despatches will be as satisfactory to Y.M. as he cannot but admit they have been to him, appearing, as they do, to indicate on the part of the Court of Vienna an anxious desire to renew with Y.M.'s Govt. those friendly relations, which of late years have been unfortunately exchanged for a position of mutual distrust & alienation. The despatch No. 2 appears to Ld D peculiarly significant; & plainly to intimate that while circumstances have driven Austria into an unusually close alliance with France, she is quite aware of the danger of that alliance, & is even looking forward to certain ‘eventualités’ in which it would be necessary for her to have secured a good understanding with the other great powers against the pretensions of France herself. Ld D. thinks that the answer to these despatches, but especially the second, will not be very easy; for while it will of course be necessary to accept with cordiality, & warmly to reciprocate the friendly professions of Austria it will be hardly less important to avoid drawing too broad a line of demarcation between the policy of Y.M.'s late & present servants, or giving encouragement to the idea which Prince Schwarzenberg appears desirous of inculcating, that henceforth Austria & England are under the same banner, & engaged in a common cause for the general promotion of ‘order’ throughout the world.Footnote 15 It will be necessary, as it seems to Ld. D. to imply at least, & that so clearly as to leave no possibility of misapprehension, that we draw a broad distinction between abstaining from giving support, physical or moral, to those who are seeking to overthrow the institutions of their own country, & joining with Austria in the maintenance of arbitrary principles of government, & the subversion, through Europe, of constitutional rights. Against any inference of such an understanding between the two powers, which Ld. D. cannot help thinking that Prince Schwarzenberg would desire to insinuate, Y.M.'s Govt. cannot too cautiously guard themselves, & any such union, Ld. D. hopes he need hardly say, would not be more repugnant to the feelings of Ld. Palmerston* than they would be to his own. But, this reserve apart, Ld. D. cannot but feel that in the altered tone of these despatches there is a fresh security for the maintenance of the peace of Europe, & he understands that the instructions sent to the Austrian minister at Paris will have led to a very much altered tone of his communications with the French Govt, who will henceforth have no pretence for saying that Austria is driving them into violent measures. [. . .]
7
Derby to Malmesbury, MP 9M73/451/2
‘Sunday night’ [?14 March 1852]Footnote 16
St James's Square
I have read your private instructions with great interest — they are excellent – terse, clear, and admirably expressed – If all my young soldiers show as well, we shall exhibit a formidable line of battle. [. . .]
8
Malmesbury to Derby, DP 920 DER (14) 144/1
27 March [1852]
Do not think me lazy for sending you back this despatch, I am ready to answer it tho’ I shd do it less well – but you will see at the end that it is to be read to you & that the reply must be made accordingly.Footnote 17
If I am to answer I conclude that I am to accept the very safe & natural proposal made with reference to Belgium calling a conference of the guaranteeing powers in case of being threatenedFootnote 18 – but should we not ask Russia what she wd do if L. Nap acted without notice,Footnote 19 & should we say that we could not submit to see the Scheldt in the hands of France. This last eventuality I suppose wd be war with England —
9
Derby to Malmesbury, MP 9M73/451/4
28 March 1852
St James's Square
I have just had a long conversation with Brünnow.* I think he is possessed of the powers to which I refer in the last paragraph of the draft I left with you last night,Footnote 20 but he will not say so, unless we are prepared now to enter into negotiations as to the naval assistance which we would afford in the event of an invasion of Belgium. This of course I told him I was not prepared to do; and indeed it might depend materially on the amount of cooperation which we might expect from other powers. I told him the nature of the despatch which he was about to receive; but he wished (and said that it would be more in accordance with diplomatic usage) that it should be addressed, not to him, but to Sir Hamilton Seymour.* Will you therefore throw it into that form. It will not require much alteration – and the enquiry with which it concludes is more fitly addressed through him to Count Nesselrode, than to Brünnow himself. I believe you send a courier off tomorrow – Brunnow wishes to send his despatches by the same messenger.
10
Derby to Malmesbury, MP 9M73/451/6
‘Wednesday’ [undated]
Brünnow[’]s confidential despatch to Nesselrode, which he will show you is very skilful, and very friendly.Footnote 21 He has not at all exaggerated my views, and has availed himself of the situation to withdraw the Emperor quietly from a too pertinacious adherence to the letter of former treaties which might be embarrassing. He inserted, at my suggestion words limiting the ‘intime union’ near the end of the despatch, to a ‘système défensif’ – I think you will be quite satisfied with his language —
11
Derby to Malmesbury, MP 9M73/451/8/1–2
13 April 1852
St James's Square
Bunsen* has been with me again this morning, and I think it is right you should know the language he holds.Footnote 22 He began by saying that the French Government, as indeed we know from Cowley, would not make any objection to recognizing the claims of Prussia upon Neufchâtel; and he says that Walewski declares that the French Article of ‘unanimity’ was only inserted from jealousy of another Power (of course Austria) and he seems even to think that it would not be insisted on – but he adds that the French Government declare that the real obstacle is the English Cabinet – and that we are determined to do nothing in the matter. He then went on with much apparent fussiness, to speak of the ulterior views with which he desires a joint note to be addressed to the Swiss Government in support of the Prussian claims. He adverted to the difficulty which I had suggested of the uselessness of a joint note, which the parties presenting it had bound themselves by a previous convention not to support, or allow to be supported by coercive measures. He admitted that in his opinion the Swiss Government would refuse; and although he attempted to account for the recent electionFootnote 23 in various ways, he evidently is convinced that the feelings of the population in the aggregate are not with Prussia — Indeed he went so far as to say that a representation of this kind made & rejected would be the best way of ‘shelving’ the question. On my saying something about the question being ‘settled’, he again, in a marked way, used the word ‘shelved’; and added, that after having recognized the rights of Prussia, and having failed in obtaining from Switzerland a consent to their reestablishment, we might then address our advice to Prussia to recede from pressing her rights, and that in such advice the K[ing]. of Prussia*Footnote 24 would find the easiest solution of the difficulty, and the best answer to his adherents in Neufchâtel. He offered to pledge me his honor [sic], that if the rights were recognized, and a representation made by the Great Powers to Switzerland unsuccessful, the K[ing] of Prussia would take no steps in support of his claims. This certainly places the case in a different light; but I cannot help thinking there would be considerable awkwardness in engaging the Great Powers to make a representation to Switzerland, inviting a refusal. It may be that Prussia thinks that the signature of a Convention would lead to a proposal for a mediation, and to a surrender of her claim, on the part of Prussia, for a consideration which the Swiss Government would in that case agree to give. One thing is clear to me, that Prussia feels the question a very embarrassing one, and would be glad to retreat, if she saw how to do so with dignity, or even so as to save appearances. Bunsen will see you on your return to Town; but I thought it as well that you should receive the report of his language while it was fresh in my recollection, that you might be prepared for the line he will take with you. I should add that he told me he had conversed with Aberdeen,* wh[i]c[h] led me to infer that he approved the proposed course, though he evidently had given no encouragement to any resumption of authority by Prussia.
I said a few words to him on the Danish question,Footnote 25 but he has no instructions, and chooses to be censéFootnote 26 to have nothing to do with it.
He believes in the President's peaceable intentions for the present – but that sooner or later he means to be Emperor, and that what may happen after that he hardly knows himself.
I sent your letter on to the Queen this morning.
We were well received at the Lord Mayor's yesterday, when all went off well —
12
Malmesbury to Derby, DP 920 DER (14) 144/1
16 April 1852
Foreign Office
[. . .] I cannot see what advantage we are to gain by Bunsen's plan.Footnote 27 The claim on Neufchatel is perfectly acknowledged by us & I don't see the use of christening Prussia over again as an empty honour — In fact we are to eat dirt to keep up Prussia's dignity. — We stand well with the Swiss now – & I am quite against throwing away our credit by inviting a preconcerted refusal, wh they (the Swiss) not being behind the scenes would boast of giving —
I sent Ch[arles] Murray'sFootnote 28 last despatchFootnote 29 to the D[uke]. of North[umberland],* as it was urgent his orders to strengthen the Mediterranean fleet should go tomorrow. He sends two ships from Lisbon & HothamFootnote 30 will go by the Vixen & we keep the Dauntless. —
The Duke who knows the Med[iterranean] Sea well says the account respecting settlements there is nonsense —
The orders to the two ships sent to Alexandria are to remonstrate against any hostilities between the two Turks until reference is made to the great powers, as also with the French if they attempt to land troops – but not to fire – in fact to put in a protest. [. . .]
13
Derby to Malmesbury, MP 9M73/451/9
[Undated] ‘¼ past 1’
I have this moment received the enclosed from Brünnow.Footnote 31 I have told him he shall have an answer in an hour or two. When you have made what use you think fit of his despatch, send it me back in a large cover (I have none here large enough) unsealed that I may return it to him. I think his report of what passed in conversation is substantially correct.
[PS] It would be useful that you should look up our old treaty obligations, that we may see whether we should rest on them, or whether it would be expedient to establish any new basis.
14
Derby to Malmesbury, MP 9M73/451/10
‘Monday’ [?26 April or 3 May 1852]Footnote 32
St James's Square
Read the enclosed and bring it with you to the Council.Footnote 33 The Queen's, or rather the Prince's*,Footnote 34 meddling in this matter will give us much trouble if we do not mind.
15
Malmesbury to Derby, DP 920 DER (14) 144/1
29 April [1852]
You will see that there is a hitch about Neufchatel at Paris & that Bunsen lied as usual when he said they put the refusal on our shoulders.Footnote 35 Walewski assured me it was false. I think we had better stave it off. It can do us no good to go & bark at Switzerland & at this moment when she is of her own accord returning to a Conservative form of govt. — I wait yr orders & only give my opinion wh you know was always against this move. —
I do not want to praise myself but I must say for Walewski that the solution of the Swiss question & the line France has taken on the TanzimatFootnote 36 is entirely attributable to him & to our discussions. Turgot was dead against me on both at first —
16
Derby to Malmesbury, MP 9M73/451/11
[8 May 1852] ‘4.35’Footnote 37
Downing Street
I am just come away from the Palace – an hour & a half, and not a word about Denmark — Sign away —Footnote 38
17
Derby to Malmesbury, MP 9M73/451/14
[Undated]
You have only sent back half my paperFootnote 39 – bring the other with you to the Levée. I should not be in a hurry – Radetzky'sFootnote 40 report is most unsatisfactory, and will require to be answered in detail & firmly. How did it come to you?
18
Malmesbury to Derby, DP 920 DER (14) 144/1
22 May [1852]
I believe the writer of the letter you send me to take a perfectly correct view of the case & I agree in all he says.Footnote 41
I was going to propose to you that we should make this case of MurrayFootnote 42 the opportunity for establishing diplomatic relations with Rome by placing Bulwer* in the position formerly intended for himFootnote 43 — The Pope*Footnote 44 wd accept him pro temporeFootnote 45 & that is sine die.Footnote 46 But I would not advise this till after the elections.
19
Derby to Malmesbury, MP 9M73/451/16
‘Wednesday’ [?26 May 1852]Footnote 47
St James's Square
I have forwarded your Box to the Queen – but I cannot say I like the course of conduct pursued by the French Gov[ernmen]t. It appears to me shuffling and evasive.Footnote 48 [. . .]
I send you a letter from Scarlett* – I will speak to you about the answer at the Cabinet. The Mather case is dead and buried, and producing papers about it now would be absurd.Footnote 49
20
Malmesbury to Derby, DP 920 DER (14) 144/1
28 May [1852]
We have a very up-hill game to fight in a certain quarter,Footnote 50 where they have also some crude ideas about France.
It would not cost Louis Nap[oleon] any thing to promise what is desiredFootnote 51 — I am trying to bring him to the more practical act of proving his pacific intentions by a reduction of his army & navy whenever he assumes the imperial crown — [. . .]
21
Malmesbury to Derby, DP 920 DER (14) 144/1
‘Sunday’ [30 May 1852]Footnote 52
Heron Court
I have received a letter from Disraeli in a tremendous stew about the Mather case of which he as yet knows nothing.Footnote 53
I have ordered the correspondence to be printed & (with the exception of three letters wh I have sent you up to be added) you will receive it tomorrow —
Scarlett has done far worse than I at first believed. By Mr Barron[’]s* letterFootnote 54 of the 9th inst. we were led to believe that £222 & the release of the StratfordsFootnote 55 had been offered & accepted as a legal & fair demand & compensation for Mr Mather's injury — Absurd as this wasFootnote 56 there was no serious harm in it, & I wrote to BulwerFootnote 57 on the 21st. to recognise Scarlett[’]s act – but on the 22nd there comes another batch of despatches stating that Scarlett had formerly waived the principle of Tuscan responsibility, & not only that, but accepted a note, wh you will see, from the D[uke]. of CasiglianoFootnote 58 in which the £222 is ostentatiously put forward as an act of generosity! not to be used as a precedent —
It is clear that Scarlett must have been non compos, for he quotes my despatch of the 9th of April as his excuse wh despatch is the strongest of all in its instructions to maintain Tuscan responsibility & independence.—
He has now got us into a complete mess, because if he had asserted the principle of forcing Tuscany to do justice as an independent power, we might have made light of the actual sum paid, but as the case stands, we have ended by taking charity & that in the most humiliating manner —
I cannot stand this & hope you will approve of a despatch I have written to Bulwer to close the mission if the principle of protection to our subjects is not recognised by the Tuscan Govt. & the insulting language of Casigliano's note altered — It is our only way out of the scrape wh that hothead has got us into. — [. . .]
22
Malmesbury to Derby, DP 920 DER (14) 144/1
30 May 1852
Heron Court
I wrote to you early this morning to save the messenger as I was anxious you should know how completely Scarlett had stultified all our policy respecting Tuscan disputes & Austrian influence at Florence — As we stand now we have not even got one expression of regret for Mather's injury but on the contrary an insolent note accompanying the payment & treating it as a generous allowance not a legal redress. — Swartzenberg [sic] & Buol have both publicly stated their friendly sentiments & sorrow for the accident but not one word has the Italian uttered wh approaches an apology. I see nothing left for us, even if it were not our duty, than to write in the sense I have done to Bulwer & as it is a despatch of some consequence, I should be much obliged to you, if you approve of the substance, to touch up the diction.
On Thursday Dudley StuartFootnote 59 will move for the papers, & I wish them to be laid before the House as soon as [is] convenient but I shd not like the discussion & perhaps the hostile motion they will induce to take place there long before I can tell my story in the Lords, which do not sit for any business this week.Footnote 60 I shd propose therefore that Edward*Footnote 61 shd present them tomorrow week.
23
Malmesbury to Derby, DP 920 DER (14) 144/1
31 May 1852
Heron Court
I send you a letter from Bulwer in which you will find a graphic confirmation of the extent of Scarlett's folly. — That Bulwer (who never thinks of anything but Bulwer) should recommend us not to make him ‘break his shins’ over this obstacle, is natural enough, but shd we not act as I proposed to you, it is my shins if not those of the entire Gov[ernmen]t. that will be kicked by the House of Commons, if indeed they do not kick some other part of our persons. —
In looking over the papers you will see that Barron's first despatchFootnote 62 simply announcing the settlement of the question & the amount to be paid in money & prisoners, reached the F.O. on the 17th. & that I wrote to Bulwer on the 21st to recognise Scarlett[’]s act the extent of which I had no idea of. On the 22. the second batchFootnote 63 arrived at the F.O. with the details of his absolute concessions of principle & dignity but as the 23rd was Sunday these despatches did not reach me till Monday the 24th, & were not read by me till Tuesday the 25th.Footnote 64after I had instructed Addington* to write to Mather to inform him (on the strength of the first despatch from Barron) that the affair was concluded. —
Referring to another part of Bulwer's letter wh treats of his negotiations with Rome I should be much obliged to you to put down the instructions he requires as to what we want the Pope to do or not to do.Footnote 65 If we could get him to help us in Ireland at the elections or even to make his people abstain from hostility it would be a great victory, but I am so absolutely ignorant of Irish politics & you are so completely experienced in them that I cannot do otherwise than require y[ou]r instructions for Bulwer in detail.
We must leave their execution to him & his judgement, wh I suppose is good as every body says so —
He is certainly sharp enough in his own interest.— Mr. Hudson* must settle it with him for keeping Mr. Barron against the rules of the service & of all civility. —
24
Derby to Malmesbury, MP 9M73/451/18
1 June 1852
St James's Square
I think your answer to Mr. Mather will do very well. The question about Bulwer is more difficult, but I think your notion of letting him retire to Rome, in no official character is a good one. He might there at all events see Cardinal Antonelli,* who is the real director of every thing, and endeavour to find out the real mind of Rome as to English & Irish affairs. It is difficult to say what he is to urge the Pope to do or not to do, because what we really want is to abridge his own power and that of the Priesthood his agents – in which he is not likely to assist us, especially as we have no quid pro quo to offer him, and no threat effectually to alarm him. Just at present the great object would be to restrain the R.C. clergy from making religious questions prominent at the elections – a course of proceeding which will infallibly kindle into tenfold fury the Protestant feeling which is already burning so fiercelyFootnote 66 – but even were His Holiness disposed to act towards us in a friendly spirit, which I doubt, his orders could hardly be received in time to influence the present elections. I should like however to talk to you about these matters. Could you come to me in D[ownin]g St a little before 5?
25
Derby to Malmesbury, MP 9M73/451/17
[?2 June 1852] ‘10 P.M.’Footnote 67
St James's Square
I wish you would come down here as soon as you can get away, without attracting observation, from your dinner. The Queen is in a great fuss about the proposal – and I must write to H.M. tonight — I wish to have the latest intelligence, and to be able to assure H.M. that you have thrown, not cold, but iced, water on the proposition.Footnote 68
26
Malmesbury to Derby, DP 920 DER (14) 144/1
20 June [1852]
The contradiction that Bulwer alludes to between my private letter & public despatch to him he ought to have understood, because in my public instructions I of course desired him if he closed the embassy to repair to Parma or Modena to wh courts he is also accredited – & I cd not allude to Rome – whilst in my private letter I tell him that he might make the rupture with Tuscany an opportunity for going to Rome —Footnote 69
Pray, if you can, send me the documents he required to shew Antonelli before the middle of the week —
27
Derby to Malmesbury, MP 9M73/451/20
24 June 1852
St James's Square
I send you back the papers furnished by Naas.* [. . .] An abstract however of the Tenant League BillFootnote 70 might be desirable. I have not time to prepare instructions to Bulwer, but I send him a long private letter, which, if it meets your concurrence, I will thank you to send over to TalbotFootnote 71 to have copied, and then despatch it by your messenger. I wish you would have a copy made, to go with it, of the R.C M.P's oath; and of the declarations made by the R.C. bishops & clergy before the passing of the Relief Bill.
28
Derby to Malmesbury, MP 9M73/451/21
25 June 1852
I think Sir H[enry] B[ulwer].'s course shd be entirely approved, and the immaterial concession made on which the Grand DukeFootnote 72 lays so much stress.Footnote 73 Regret for the past, and acknowledged responsibility for the future are all that we can require[.]
29
Derby to Malmesbury, MP 9M73/451/23
28 June 1852
I should think the conciliatory tone more likely to effect the object, but on that point Sir H[enry].B[ulwer] must have better means of judging than either you or I.Footnote 74
30
Derby to Malmesbury, MP 9M73/451/26
[Undated]
I think we may accept the reparation offered,Footnote 75 though it is not very satisfactory; but our forbearance here may strengthen our hands in Mather's case.
31
Derby to Malmesbury, MP 9M73/451/43/1
‘Friday night’ [16 July 1852]Footnote 76
[Osborne House]Footnote 77
I shall take this letter over with me tomorrow; but as I shall only pass through London, I write to say that the Queen in a long and most free conversation on the part of Her Majesty this morning, expressed some surprise at not having heard from you of the arrival of Lord HowdenFootnote 78 or of Lord Stratford* (or as she always calls him Lord Stuart) de Redcliffe.Footnote 79 She said, very good-humouredly, that she supposed you imagined that being at Osborne she would not wish to be troubled with Audiences – but that she wished on the contrary to know of the arrival of any foreign ministers, and she would always find means, if it was inconvenient to her to receive them, of putting them off – but in the present instance I think it clear that she wishes to see both one and the other.Footnote 80 Next week she is going on a short cruise in the Channel for three or four days beginning with Monday; and I should therefore suppose that the following week will suit her for receiving them.Footnote 81 I understand another cruise is meditated for about the 9th of August.Footnote 82 I have arranged with Her Majesty that you should accompany her to Scotland on the 30thFootnote 83 and that I should relieve guard about the 10th.Footnote 84 She was very civil about you, and her tone altogether most friendly & confidential. [. . .]
32
Malmesbury to Derby, DP 920 DER (14) 144/1
17 July [1852]
Foreign Office
I found your letter on my return here & also Colloredo* whose despatches I send you to read. We are not to copy. I don't much like the one about Mather & Tuscany. Should it be answered or treated as a brutum fulmenFootnote 85 – Colloredo said it was necessary for Austria to say this as she had a treaty with Tuscany but that he did not wish to open the question & as the paper is not to be copied no record of it will remain here[.]
33
Derby to Malmesbury, 9M73/451/29
19 July 1852
St Leonards
I agree with you in not much approving Buol's tone about Tuscany,Footnote 86 though I think it is chiefly to be taken as an indication of the stiff manner of the man, rather than of an unfriendly spirit. I think however that you cannot allow the despatch to remain altogether unanswered: nor to appear to concede the principle for which he contends of recognising Austrian responsibility for acts done in Tuscany: and I am the more inclined to this opinion, because Count Boul rests his case in great measure on a treaty between Austria & Tuscany, which has never been communicated, as I believe, and which I do not wish should be, to this country; and to which, as being a secret treaty, or at least containing a secret article, he has, as I should think, no diplomatic right to refer. On this point however I may be mistaken; but I think, while deprecating discussion, you should reaffirm the responsibility, as coincident with the independence, of Tuscany. [. . .]
34
Derby to Malmesbury, MP 9M73/451/31
‘Friday evg.’ [Undated]Footnote 87
St Leonards
I return your proposed answer to the Duke of Augustenburg,Footnote 88 which I think is quite right — I see no reason why you should show it to the Queen. I hope you observe his signature on the articleFootnote 89 Duke of Holstein.
35
Derby to Malmesbury, MP 9M73/451/33
‘Sunday’ [Undated]
St James's Square
I have sent, both through Walpole* and Naas[,] to get materials for our representation as to the state of the R.C. clergy in Ireland, and I will forward them the moment I get them, but I fear they will hardly be in time to do any good for the elections — You shall have your draft in the ‘Empire’ case tomorrow.
36
Malmesbury to Derby, DP 920 DER (14) 144/1
25 July [1852]
I had a long talk with Brunnow yesterday about the Greek successionFootnote 90 & found him quite of our mind & ready to revise the treaty of 1832 & substitute AdelbertFootnote 91 the Greek for LuitpoldFootnote 92 the Roman assuming always that the latter is ready to renounce his rights.
B. will open upon you on this subject at GoodwoodFootnote 93 but do not tell him that Cowley had pressed it upon me from Thouvenel* as I treated it as a subject which we originated to him Brunnow officiallyFootnote 94 — I shall now address Cowley officially to know the opinion of France, & then ascertain officially from Bavaria the disposition of the two princes —
37
Malmesbury to Derby, DP 920 DER (14) 144/1
30 July [1852]
Foreign Office
[. . .] I sent for Colloredo yesterday (Bunsen was out of the question) to ask him whether there was any truth in the convention signed by the Great Powers wh appeared in the Chronicle & TimesFootnote 95 — I said that if it was true it did not concern us beyond the fact that they had made overtures to us which meant nothingFootnote 96 — Colloredo said that it was only a confused invention founded upon the fact of those overtures wh somehow or other had leaked out & that no convention had been signed — I cannot say however I was satisfied for he looked what is vulgarly called ‘foolish’, but it may be that he suspected such a convention has been signed without his knowledge. — If it is so the overture to us was made merely to ascertain our intentions & is a low trick out of wh they get nothing – & if such a treaty be not a dead letter it will be the origin of a European war hereafter —
In the meantime L. N. won't be pleased & will [be]Footnote 97 more civil than ever to us —
38
Derby to Malmesbury, DP 920 DER (14) 180/2, fos 183–184Footnote 98
31 July 1852
With the draft of your despatch to Lord Cowley, I send you a letter which I received last night from the Queen, and a copy of my answer, which will I hope be in accordance with your views. I had a few words with Brunnow yesterday and he will no doubt see you. He evidently wishes that you should write to Petersburgh [sic] as well as to Paris and to have the appearance of making a simultaneous suggestion to both Courts.Footnote 99 Before I saw him, I had, as you will see, in some degree altered the terms of your draft, so that you should not seem to say to the French Government that you had arranged everything with Russia before consulting them. I know the reverse is the case; but the public despatch, on the face of it, would have that appearance. I shall be at the office till 5 or later if you want to see me.
39
Derby to Malmesbury, MP 9M73/451/35
11 August 1852
St Leonards
I enclose you an acceptance of Walewski's invitation which I will thank you to forward, if you are satisfied that we should dine there.Footnote 100 The only point which raises the least doubt in my mind is the note ‘en uniforme’ – which gives the whole affair a more formal & official character than would otherwise belong to it. I think however we ought to accept, subject to an assurance, which I have no doubt Walewski will give you, that nothing shall be said or done to give to the dinner any political significance, and especially nothing as regards the Imperial title.
[. . .] I am writing to Her Majesty today, and shall tell her the view we take of the French Dinner – it is just as well to name these little matters. [. . .]
40
Derby to Malmesbury, MP 9M73/451/36
17 August 1852
St Leonards
Buol's note,Footnote 101 which I had last night[,] is outrageous, and must be very seriously taken up – I think I had better see Colloredo. I wish you would bring it down with you in the train tomorrow, and with it the statement of Mr Newton. We can talk it over on our way.Footnote 102 [. . .]
41
Derby to Malmesbury, MP 9M73/451/37/1–2
20 August 1852
10 Downing Street
These papers which Walpole sends on to you through me, are any thing but agreeable. The refugees in Jersey want looking after closely; and I must say that the collection of a large number of them in such immediate proximity to the French coast, together with the language they are reported to hold, is calculated to give just cause of umbrage to France. We must keep a sharp look out over these fellows; and I do not think it would have a bad effect, and might supersede the employment by the French Government of unauthorised spies, if we were to follow up the precedent of the Exhibition, and on the very ground of the number of the refugees, and their supposed projects, invite the President to send over some of the French police to cooperate with ours. It is a step which would mark confidence, and would I think be justified by the circumstances. Hardinge,*Footnote 103 who I have just seen, is going over there in a few days, and I have asked him to keep his eyes & ears open.
Cowley has been with me, and, oddly enough, expressed his anxiety as to the state of these Channel Islands, and possible causes of difference with France, arising out of the conduct of the refugees. He wants to avoid taking his seat, and giving his proxy; but I think I have given him to understand that we shall expect it. He is to take a few days to consider what he will do. I have seen Colloredo, and have expressed to him strongly the painful impression produced upon your mind and my own by Buol's answer to Mr Howard* which I read to him.Footnote 104 I told him he must not be surprised if in answer to it we were compelled to use strong language, & that the tone of Buol's communication, independent of the substance, struck us as quite inconsistent with his professions of friendship, and fell short of ordinary courtesy. He protested of course that he was sure nothing was farther from Count Buol's wishes than to show any unfriendly feeling; but that he would write to him tonight, and let him know the impression produced upon us, and I told him that as Lord Westmorland* was returning to Vienna, and from a private letter which I had seen, there was some reason to hope that a further communication, in a different spirit, might yet be received from Vienna, we would postpone for a short time sending our official reply to his letter. I hope you will approve of this delay, which may do some good, and which we can afford, as Parliament is not sitting.
42
Malmesbury to Derby, DP 920 DER (14) 144/1
‘Saturday evg.’ [21 August 1852]Footnote 105
Heron Court
I have received yr papers & letter on the Jersey refugees since I sent off mine of this morning to ask you what Colloredo had said — I quite agree with you on both subjects – of course on the first as it was I who desired Sir R MayneFootnote 106 to send over a detective. I had however intended to communicate the intentions of these persons to the President privately letting him know at the same time that I was aware of his own spies. It seemed to me that we should equally deserve the confidence of the French Govt without risking the outcry wh will be made if we openly propose to them to join in a surveillance. The French Govt would certainly shew us up, but if the President were informed by some one viva voce the whole object wd be obtained without any risk of a debate in the H[ouse] of Commons —
I talked to Cowley about it & he said he could find means of letting him know —
I will follow yr instructions on the Newton caseFootnote 107 about wh we have a fair excuse for delay inasmuch as the hero is not returned from abroad & that there is considerable discrepancy between his own story & his father[’]s wh obliges me to see him. — Considering the brutal nature of the Austrian soldiers & police, & the state of their country, & then the incurable snobbism of our young English travellers of the middle class, I see no end to these cases unless we openly say that if they choose to go for pleasure into a country so misgoverned we cannot go to war for the roughness they meet with.
43
Malmesbury to Derby, DP 920 DER (14) 144/1
21 August [1852]
Heron Court
As you are going to Osborne on MondayFootnote 108 I should be much obliged to you for a line to say what passed between you & Colloredo on the subject of Mr. Newton.Footnote 109 — It appears to me that we must settle upon some definite course of policy as regards these cases wh are sure to recur & to be taken up in the H[ouse]. of Commons & by the press with popular virulence. — I send you a translation of an article from the Govt. papers at Vienna wh shews the feeling entertained against us by Palmerston's bluster & Haynau's caseFootnote 110 — We shall get nothing from Austria & the more we write the more incapable of obliging her to repair injustice & the more ridiculous shall we appear —
Supposing Buol positively to refuse redress what can we do? The ultima ratioFootnote 111 wd be to blockade Trieste & Venice & stop a trade wh gives us a million sterling per ann[um]. — My opinion is if, as I expect he will, Buol maintains his present tone, that we should openly declare in Parl[iamen]t. our inability to answer for the safety of our subjects upon Austrian territory & warn them accordingly that if they visit that country it is at their peril, that if they do so merely for pleasure they must take the consequences as they would in a barbarous land, altho’ we are ready to protect our merchants vis et armis.Footnote 112 We may recall Westmorland or not at the same time. —
Edward will have told you what I heard from Cowley about Belgium & you will have seen Cowley yrself. — Whenever Austria is well with France she waxes insolent.
44
Malmesbury to Derby, DP 920 DER (14) 144/1
27 August [1852]
Foreign Office
[. . .] I am to see a Conseiler from Neufchatel tomorrow. It is the only question that I think may give us trouble —Footnote 113
The PresidentFootnote 114 is very angry at the difficulties thrown in the way of his marriage by Austria &c[.] The lady says she will have him & Walewski & Persigny* both agree that he never will forgive this interference.
45
Malmesbury to Derby, 920 DER (14) 144/1
2 September 1852
Balmoral
[. . .] My private secretary is about a mile off so it is not easy to carry on the business in an official manner & I must trust to Edward who is much more fit for the F[oreign].S[ecretaryshi]p. than I am. [. . .] Nothing can be more amiable than the Queen & Prince are, & as far as you & I are concerned I am sure there is no personal prejudice –
46
Malmesbury to Derby, DP 920 DER (14) 144/1
2 September 1852
Balmoral
[. . .] Bulwer seems to be doing very well but his Austrian news corroborated unintentionally by Dawkin'sFootnote 115 [sic] account of their studied rudeness to British travellers is very important as regards Italy, & I think we must finally play France against them. Russia wd not help Austria in any ambitious views on Italy but only defend her from internal revolution. I may say en passant I had a very satisfactory conversation with Brunnow on Neufchatel before I left town & shall frame a despatch to Bloomfield* upon it soon — [. . .]
The Prince's mind is actively engaged in foreign politics & he shews on this subject as upon all others great information — In respect to Austria he is I think quite what he should be, & I agree with him that we can do her much more harm than she can do us —
47
Malmesbury to Derby, DP 920 DER (14) 144/1
3 September [1852]
Balmoral
[. . .] I wish you would ascertain that the Duke [of Northumberland] has sent a steamer to be permanently stationed at Jersey — Walpole is getting nervous about it — I am not if we show that we attend to the point — The Alderney forts shd not be starved. —
The President knows by this time from me the plots against him & that I am aware of his spies at Jersey as against us —
Walpole won't believe that he can buy at Paris a correct map of our works there & every where else whenever he likes – & I do not mind that, but if it be true that French Govt. agents are trying to debauch the loyalty of the people it is dangerous —
48
Derby to Malmesbury, DP 920 DER (14) 179/2, fos 190–191Footnote 116
3 September 1852Footnote 117
I inclose you a part of a letter which I have received from Walpole with the inclosures, which I quite agree with him in thinking that you should see. [. . .] You will be the best judge what course to take; but I think you should let Cowley have this information, & that some representation should be made, through him, to the French Govt. of the double part which their agents are acting. I do not know whether the laws of Jersey would allow our removing the refugees from a position the proximity of which to France affords some justification for the espionage practised by the French Government. If we can do it, we certainly ought. Meanwhile I hope the steamer we have ordered there will be of some service as a check on those gentry. I asked Hardinge to keep his eyes & ears open, & to give me, on his return, his political, as well as his military, opinion.Footnote 118 [. . .]
49
Malmesbury to Derby, DP 920 DER (14) 144/1
4 September [1852]
Balmoral
I send you a draft I have written on the Neufchatel question[.] I hope you will revise the language but approve of the sense – I am perfectly sure that if we go into this thorny question we shall upset your government & raise a storm in Europe.
Brunnow thinks the same & I am sure I can get the President to oppose it —
I also send a despatch from Brunnow upon Greece & Edward's comments upon his views – he gave E. a duplicate of the conversation he bestowed upon me last Sunday. We had better wait to see what Bavaria means. Her family compact is not officially announced but only told me by letter namely to substitute Adelbert for Luitpold who wd not for himself or his children renounce their religion.
Whilst in the Highlands I shall not send you any rubbish of a routine nature —
[P.S.] Pray send the draft to Bloomfield on to the F.O. as the Queen has seen a duplicate wh I sent her to hasten the course of business —
50
Malmesbury to Derby, DP 920 DER (14) 144/1
‘Sunday morning’ [5 September 1852]Footnote 119
Balmoral
I had last night a conversation with the Prince on Neufchatel & I found that among the many other objections to any interference with that canton you may add the royal displeasure at any such policy.
The Prince says it is entirely a ‘marotte’Footnote 120 of the King'sFootnote 121 wh Austria & Russia work according to their wish to obtain any particular object from him — He said he wd write himself to the King to tell him not to press the subject further —Footnote 122
I have just got yr letters on Jersey — I wish you would get F. Somerset* to send for a battalion more to the island as the barracks wd hold that, & I see no reason why we shd not fill them — I found him very averse to sending troops there & I do not know why. The idea of offending the French wh he suggested is nonsense. I will send a copy of Sanders[’]Footnote 123 report to Cowley with instructions to make a verbal remonstrance. It will come very well after Harris’Footnote 124 conversation with the PresidentFootnote 125 — [. . .]
51
Malmesbury to Derby, DP 920 DER (14) 144/1
9 September [1852]
Balmoral
[. . .] With respect to Greece I think we should be satisfied if Adelbert adopts the Greek faith immediately & promises it for his unhatched chickens —
If there is any truth in Milbanke'sFootnote 126 suspicion that Russia wants the Emperor Nicholas’ nephew to succeed we should have France with him, as the boy is cousin to the President & a Beauharnais, but I have found the F[rench].G[overnment]. very jealous of Russia on this question, & I therefore do not believe it. — You will learn a great deal of the private springs wh influence German politics if you talk of them to the Prince. He has his crotchets, but he strikes me as a very clever man, & can be of use to us by giving us information wh our ministers ought to give but never do. — He will shew you a copy of his letter to the K[ing]. of Prussia. [. . .]
My cousin's letterFootnote 127 contained nothing more respecting the Jersey conference with the President than what I sent you – I shall see him at Achnacarry & will send you more particulars. Meantime Cowley is to remonstrate against the three agitators. [. . .]
You will see that Buol continues to be bearish. I suspect he dislikes HowardFootnote 128 for his Whig connexionsFootnote 129 —
52
Malmesbury to Derby, DP 920 DER (14) 144/1
19 September [1852]
Achnacarry
I send you attached to these Neapolitan despatches Edward's & Addington's remarks & counter remarks on Mr. Hamilton's case —Footnote 130
It is one wh will make a great noise in the H[ouse]. of C[ommons]. & his memorandum here inclosed makes it worse than I at first thought —
I should propose acting simply in the same course we we [sic] have adopted till now namely.
Insist on the entrance being a breach of the treaty.
Admit that Mr. H. has no right to educate Neapolitan children if the Govt. objects —
Insist that he has a right to receive, take care of, & educate British children.
Demand compensation for Mr. H equivalent to the actual loss he has suffered by the closing of his school for a time.
My conversation with Prince CariniFootnote 131 induces me to believe that we can carry all this out, & I am very averse to any pottering about the treaty now — Addington was away when we began the dispute —
If you approve of this course pray write me a word to that effect & whilst the despatches are with the Queen I will give instructions to the F.O.
53
Malmesbury to Derby, DP 920 DER (14) 144/1
3 October 1852
The very important letters I send you from Bulwer cannot be answered by me without detailed instructions from you. If you are not overwhelmed with work they had better be answered by you in person —
That dated Sep 21 sent under flying seal thro’ Cowley gives a resumé of Bulwer's work & of his questions. It appears that we are to give the Pope an opportunity of speaking for us in Ireland — Can you find any [word missing in original] in the course proposed? Is there such a bishop as he requires & who will play into our hands?
The subject is so important & the time so short before the 11th of November that I send you the letters straight from here. If you do not want to keep the principal ones or to send them to Naas or Eglinton* pray forward them to Edward —
54
Malmesbury to Derby, DP 920 DER (14) 144/1
8 October [1852]
You will see by this letter of Ld. Howard'sFootnote 132 that Leopold* is frightened & our court also, for it must be from them that Leopold knows the Austrian & Russian answers to my questions about the Belgian press — I shall write to him that we cannot put on any such pressure as the King requires, as to be useful to him it must be public & to be public it wd be fatal to any English govt. —
It is this gadfly of the Belgian press, wh being in French, is stinging & working L.N. into a fever. I do not wonder at it, for it requires the public school education of an Englishman & his natural phlegm to stand the misrepresentations of an English & Belgian newspaper with indifference, especially when one begins at four & forty years of age like L.N.
55
Derby to Malmesbury, MP 9M73/2/255
‘Friday Evg.’ [?8 or 15 October 1852]Footnote 133
I think it would be better not to volunteer printing any explanation of the private conversations which passed between Cardl. Antonelli & Bulwer, both on the general principle that they were private, and also because one explanation will lead to another, and we should have to disclose more of our case than would be convenient.
56
Malmesbury to Cowley, Cowley MSS, TNA, FO 519/196, fos 173–174
15 October 1852
Foreign Office
In great haste I write you a line to beg of you to send me the best account you can of the French navy & of what they have been about lately in that department — All our newspapers talk of increased activity & you in your last letter use a similar phrase — Now the navy is the pulse we feel the President by — Without a navy he can do us no harm & a navy adapted for invasion.
[. . .] I see a presentiment in both countries almost universal that L.N. means mischief – Lord Derby gets letters every day to say so — I alone do not believe it as he studiously shuns every cause of offence to England – but still we must be ready[.]
57
Malmesbury to Derby, DP 920 DER (14) 144/1
15 October [1852]
Do you wish to see me before the Cabinet? Walewski comes to see me at 5 o[’] clock. — These letters confirm what I think of the general opinion of L.N.'s views upon this country. If general opinion be right all we can do is de rester dans notre droitFootnote 134 & be prepared at the Admiralty.
58
Derby to Malmesbury, MP 9M73/451/47/1–3
17 October 1852
St Leonards
I return you a number of your private letters, of great interest, and which you ought to have had back earlier. I cannot however even now find time to give you the full explanation of my views which you wish for; still less to attempt to send instructions to Bulwer on the very important questions to which his letters refer. It would seem to be his opinion, and I agree with him, that at present it will not do to attempt to establish formal diplomatic relations with Rome. Whenever we do attempt it, we ought to accredit a Minister there, without receiving one here in return. I think Eglinton ought to have Bulwer's two letters of the 21st. September; and if he can find a R.C. Bishop whom he can trust, he should employ him to write such a letter as Antonelli suggests. If he cannot find such a Bishop, Dean MeylerFootnote 135 I believe is one of the most moderate and trustworthy ecclesiastics. I confess however that I have not much faith in the sincerity of any desire on the part of Rome to repress that spirit of turbulence on the part of the Irish priesthood, which they see causes considerable annoyance to a Protestant – and in their eyes a liberal government. I will not believe that if they were in earnest, they would feel any delicacy at all about waiting to have their opinions asked, but would let their opinions be known in a way that could not be misunderstood. Even if, in answer to the letters of our ecclesiastic, we get a general exhortation to peace and good order, to avoid politics &c &c, unless it be directed to particular cases, and to particular persons, it will be taken by the Irish clergy just at its real worth, and will be treated with indifference accordingly – while on the other hand Rome will be able to appeal to this declaration of her views, as a proof of her moderation, and of her desire to restrain the spirit of disaffection at which she secretly connives. A declaration against the Tenant Law League would be something; an avowal that R. Catholics enjoyed full religious liberty, would of itself be of use; but that which is most desirable, is of course most difficult for the See of Rome to pronounce upon, namely the crusade instituted by the R.C. priesthood against the temporalities of the Established Church. And yet it is really in the interest of Catholics, well considered, that this crusade should be discouraged. I do not want that they should not consider, or avow that they consider, the Protestant Endowment as an injustice; but I do not understand how any body of clergy can take in their hands the oath required by the Relief Act to be taken by R.C. M.Ps, and bear in mind the circumstances under which that oath was imposed, and the advantages which they obtained in consideration of it, and then make the single qualification for their tumultuous support of any candidate, his declaration that in the teeth of that oath he will use his utmost endeavours to subvert that Establishment. I think the Pope must see that the contradiction between the obligation accepted, and the pledge required, is such as to justify the bulk of Protestants in the charge which is repelled by R. Catholics as calumnious, that it is an article of their belief that no faith is to be kept with heretics, and that the good of their Church justifies the violation of a solemn oath. It is this belief mainly which keeps alive the prevailing animosity. We Protestants have no desire to interfere with the religious belief or religious worship of R. Catholics. If there are any that have, they are a small minority, with whom the Government would have no difficulty in dealing – and I will venture to answer for it, that if the Church of Rome puts forth no pretensions to temporal power, inconsistent with the laws of the land, and if the mass of R. Catholics, content with the full enjoyment of religious freedom which it is admitted they possess, respect the settlement of property, and are content to have the Church of England in undisturbed possession of that which is legally hers, religious animosity would die away for want of food, and no government would be disposed to draw the slightest political distinction between Protestant & Catholic. But as long as the present system continues, and is not peremptorily checked by Rome, it will be believed to be secretly encouraged by Her – and the indignation of the Protestant public may be excited to such a pitch, as that no government can refrain from taking measures in accordance with the public will, for enforcing, at all hazards, the supremacy of the Law, and the security of the Church to which the great majority of the people belong. How far the Pope & Cardinal Antonelli may be inclined to go in imposing a real check upon the aggressive spirit of Irish Catholicism I know not; but according not to their professions, but to the reality of their efforts in that direction, I for one, and the country with me, will judge of the sincerity of the friendly feelings they profess.
59
Malmesbury to Derby, DP 920 DER (14) 144/1
‘Monday evg.’ [?18 October 1852]Footnote 136
I send my proposition to France & Russia for settling the Greek question – It gets rid of Cetto'sFootnote 137 rigmarole wh I inclose. — It also put an end to Brunnow's views of forcing a conversion immediately upon Adelbert. — Walewski[,] Brunnow & I met today in conference – They were rather startled at the simplicity of the planFootnote 138 but adhered – Walewski wanted Cetto to be present but we opposed it on the score of the protecting powers being on a higher footing than the protected, the creator [rather]Footnote 139 than the creature — We shall therefore invite Greece & Bavaria to adhere to our works as was done in 1832 – & I hope this job is as good as settled —
60
Malmesbury to Derby, DP 920 DER (14) 144/1
19 October [1852]
I wish very much you wd see LavradioFootnote 140before the Cabinet & I have told him to call at 1 o'clock — His acc[oun]t of French projects & feeling coming from an intelligent man like him & a foreigner, & spontaneously offered to the Govt. are to be valued & respected under any circumstances, but still more at the moment when we are about to discuss our Budget. [. . .] It is a question in my opinion whether we should not increase our seamen & have 2000 more in hand.
Van de Weyer you must hear on the same theme but he is an interested party. Both however are to be listened to — The Empire, coronation, &c. will ensure us six months at least of peace & we shd not lose that time. I still adhere to my opinion that L.N. does not wish to fight us, but, I confess he may be [sic] have to choose between his own or our destruction.
61
Derby to Malmesbury, MP 9M73/451/50
‘Sat[urda]y.’ [23 October 1852]Footnote 141
St Leonards
I have just received your letter by messenger, enclosing Eglinton's, which I return. If you will look back to a letter which I wrote you on the 17thFootnote 142 – you will find that in all the main points I concur with Eglinton, and have indeed anticipated much of what he has now said to you; especially as to the inutility, for our purposes, of such a letter as it is proposed that the Pope should write, if it be directed only to general, and not to specific, objects. I also agree with him, and have so written, that such a letter would eminently serve the Pope's interests, by giving a plausible ground for talking about his moderation &c – and I have further expressed my utter disbelief, in which Eglinton also agrees, of the sincerity of the Pope's pretext as to not liking to volunteer interference. I have given myself a holiday from coming up to Town today, to help me to get through more work here. Why should not you come down to dine & sleep here tomorrow? and [sic] if you will come in good time, we can talk over this important matter. I shall be in Town in good time on Monday, but I have an appointment at 12, and our Cabinet is fixed for 1.
62
Malmesbury to Derby, DP 920 DER (14) 144/1
‘Saturday’ [23 October 1852]Footnote 143
Foreign Office
I sent yr letter of the 17th. to Eglinton with the other papers from Bulwer. I conclude that as you both object to the course Bulwer & Antonelli agreed upon (I understand you to have waived yours) we must try some plan for establishing diplomatic relations like that proposed by my Chelsea friendFootnote 144 whom you really ought to see some day. — I will come down to see you tomorrow & be at St Leonards by ½ past 3 but I am sorry to say I must return as I have 3 or 4 people to dinner with me[.]
63
Malmesbury to Derby, DP 920 DER (14) 144/1
31 October [1852]
I send you some papers wh Ld RaglanFootnote 145 brought me yesterday. The information of the writer as to the French force is said to be pretty correct — Their intentions are another thing & I utterly discredit a piratical expedition against us — It is however true that they have ordered their Meditteranean [sic] fleet to be composed entirely of steamers.
I trust you will ask for 2000 more seamen £24000 added to the £36000 voted for the reserve will pay them —
The Empire will be proclaimed the 20thprox.Footnote 146 & on this subject I think I ought to address the Cabinet as soon as possible — Recognise him we must, but as Napoleon the III I do not understand how we can, seeing that we acknowledged Charles X and Louis Philippe whilst Napoleon II was alive. [. . .]
64
Malmesbury to Cowley, Cowley MSS, TNA, FO 519/196, fos 183–184
2 November 1852
Foreign Office
I saw Walewski last night & in conversation he announced to me that L.N[.] would not take the titles of King of Algeria & Protecteur de leurs Saints but Nap[oleon] III he would have — I said I thought it would give rise to difficulties — With us? Yes even with us as I did not see how we were to stultify all our acts for the last 37 years — To recognise him as legitimate sovereign was illegitimatising retrospectively Louis 18th [and] Charles Xth whom we had recognised on the principles of hereditary right while the supposed Nap[oleon] II was alive as Duc de Reichstadt — that if we recognised L.N. it was upon the elective principle wh we had followed since 1830 — If the subject is mooted to you you will hold the same language but state you have no instructions.— I have written to Vienna[,] Berlin & Petersburgh [sic] to ask what they mean to do. — We are anxious to prevent all difficulties but the President ought on his side to smooth the way as much as possible — [. . .]
65
Malmesbury to Derby, DP 920 DER (14) 144/1
3 November [1852]
The inclosed letter from Mr. Hudson is the history, for the 1000th time repeated of an Italian prince – Independent in early life as they advance in years they invariably fall into the hands of their bigotted wives[,] mistresses & confessors — I consider this King of Sardinia*Footnote 147 to be now rapidly descending to the degraded position of the Grand Duke of Tuscany — It is a caution to England how careful she must be committing herself in the defence of a race which will not defend itself. —
66
Derby to Malmesbury, MP 9M73/451/53
4 November 1852
Downing Street
I send you a letter received this morning from Mahon,Footnote 148 which corroborates alarmingly the reports we hear from all quarters of L. N.'s intentions. Van de Weyer has been with me also, and has shown me a very strong letter from Leopold. I can hardly bring myself to believe in such recklessness as would be indicated by any early move; but it behoves all your agents to be on the alert, and Cowley should be especially warned to have his eyes open, and not to neglect the means of obtaining such information which I presume he possesses.
67
Malmesbury to Cowley, Cowley MSS, TNA, FO 519/196, fos 189–192
5 November 1852
Foreign Office
Your letter is a very important one at this moment[,] the principal object wh occupies me now being the subject of the numeral III wh L.N. means to attach to his name. It is impossible not to see that it means so much, & is of such consequence to him & to the memory of his uncle that he cannot yield the point without losing ground in France — Before I discuss the subject further I must inform you that having dined on Tuesday with Walewski he was so full of the matter that he took me apart for an hour to the great offence of his company. He renewed the conversation[,] which I entered into freely but always guarding myself as giving private & friendly advice to the President thro’ him & actuated by an earnest desire to smooth all difficulties in his path — When asked & replying that I believed the Great Powers would be most unwilling to recognise L.N's legitimate right to the throne wh the numeral III inferred Walewski declared it did not mean that but was merely a designation that he was the 3rd of that name who had appeared on the stage. [. . .] He concluded by stating that we might glisserFootnote 149 over the word. [. . .] It appears to me that we must first be quite sure that the 3 Great Powers will oppose the numeral – but that we must after this one act of coalition separate ourselves as to the form of disapprobation – that whenever the title shall be announced to the Queen we shall, (before she replies to the letter of the new Emperor) inquire the meaning of the numeral III assuming that it does not infer, what it might be supposed to declare, the hereditary right of succession inchoate in the family of his uncle, a principle wh we cd not recognise both for the sake of the past & the future, seeing that we had recognised the two last Bourbons on that principle & were now ready to recognise him on the opposite one[:] election.
There might be another course[:] namely to recognise the Emperor of the French with a protest against our recognition being misinterpreted for reasons as before stated.– The more he accompanies his announcement with assurances of respect for territorial rights & the more he puts forth the popular principles of his elective power the more easy it will be for us to slide easily over the numeral – but whether we accept it under protest or ask explanations as to its meaning, we must at all events comment upon its anomalous nature[.]
[P.S.] If you have any opportunity unofficially of using the contents of this letter as furnishing you with arguments or elements of advice you will employ them at yr own discretion —
68
Malmesbury to Cowley, Cowley MSS, TNA, FO 519/196, fos 193–194
6 November 1852
Foreign Office
I have just read yr letter & the President[’]s message to the Cabinet. Knowing as we do by your private information what the animus of the Empire is we cannot but be alarmed at the prospect of affairs —
Still we must act upon what is officially said & done & we read in the message a moral not a physical triumph as the actual sentiment expressed – ‘conquetes du 89’ evidently means popular liberties not territory as no territory was gained for France in that year — Such being the case we do not think this message as giving us an advantageous ground of protesting – but there is a better reason for yr remaining silent & that is that I have no positive assurances from the 3 Great Powers & if Prussia & Austria consult first with Russia I cannot receive any for a fortnight.— The feeling of the Govt is decidedly to oppose the recognition of the title of Nap[oleon] III because it infers a stultifying of our former acts & treaties.
You had better therefore at present continue on the best terms with the Govt. & to any questions reply that you have no instructions. If any thing urgent occurs send over immediately. — [. . .]
69
Derby to Malmesbury, MP 9M73/451/58/1
‘Tuesday’ [9 November 1852]Footnote 150
I have this moment received the enclosed. It is most inconvenient, as I have not yet taken my seat – but I mean to go down by the 10.40 train, and wish you would meet me at the Paddington Station at that time[.]
[Enclosure: Queen Victoria to Derby, 8 November 1852, 9M73/451/58/2]
The Queen has rec[eive]d this even[in]g. the draft wh: it is proposed to send to the different courts on the subject of the Imperial Title.Footnote 151 The matter it treats of is so important that the Queen does not wish to let it go without having had some verbal explanations about it from Ld Derby. She therefore wd wish him to come down here tomorrow either with or without Ld Malmesbury, any time between 11 – & 3 – .
70
Malmesbury to Derby, DP 920 DER (14) 144/1
12 November 1852
Here is a most important & agreeable letter from Cowley.Footnote 152
Louis Nap renounces all claim to the throne from hereditary right & on the score of legitimacy — We shall now in recognising him as the de facto & elected emperor have merely to refer to these spontaneous explanations & interpretations, & express our satisfaction at his having thus saved us the necessity of asking for them. —
It was the thorniest subject I have yet had to deal with, & it was with great hesitation I took the step of making our opinions known to him unofficially & as an old friend, so I am glad I was right in my decision.
We shall now save our honour without risk of a quarrel —
As to promises about treaties they do not affect that & in my opinion are moonshine – The great powers have not their own hands clean enough to handle the subject with advantage —
I want to see you for 5 min[utes] on an important matter before I meet the 4 ministers on the Greek treaty at 3.
71
Malmesbury to Cowley, Cowley MSS, TNA, FO 519/196, fos 197–198
12 November 1852
Foreign Office
I have only time to beg of you to assure the President personally from me & from Ld Derby that his explanation to youFootnote 153 of the numeral attached to Napoleon gave us the greatest pleasure by removing a difficulty which I explained to Walewski. We could not interpret the title as retrospectively claiming a legitimate right to the throne of France without entering into insuperable sophisms & altering history —
Assure him that I have always smoothed difficulties for him & that it is the earnest desire of both myself and the English Govt. to continue our relations with him on the most friendly footing of alliance. — [. . .]
72
Malmesbury to Derby, DP 920 DER (14) 144/1
17 November [1852]
I send you some papers from Brunnow upon Nap[oleon]. III. They were written before my first despatch was addressed to Petersburgh [sic] & therefore before yr memorandum wh followed it a week later. — Nesselrode therefore did not know our view of the matter & still less L. Napoleon's present intention to declare himself an elected & not hereditary sovereign.—
It is very satisfactory to a tyro like me to find that so old a statesman recommends the same manner of turning the difficulty by a protest wh I submitted to the Cabinet. — Brunnow at the time was not satisfied with this view of the subject & was inclined to go farther than Nesselrode.
If the President[’]s assurances to Cowley are officially given & voluntarily expressed we should allude to them as rendering questions unnecessary wh wd otherwise have been indispensible [sic] —
73
Derby to Malmesbury, MP 9M73/451/61
‘Wednesday’ [17 November 1852]Footnote 154
10 Downing Street
I return your Russian papers. It does not seem to me however that Nesselrode & you are quite on the same tack – for while you propose to recognise as Napoleon III under protest against the hereditary claim – he declares distinctly that the Emperor ‘reconnaitre l'Empereur du Francais – mais, pour Napoleon III, il l'ignore’[.]Footnote 155 We shall have plenty of time however to talk this over tomorrow. [. . .]
74
Malmesbury to Derby, DP 920 DER (14) 144/1
23 November 1852
Foreign Office
I shall be much obliged to you to return the papers which I send you to Prince Albert when you go to Windsor tomorrow —
They advert to improvements in our system of national defence & if you have not seen them they are well worth reading.
The D[uke]. of North[umberlan]d. has been to me most anxious that the 1500 marines wh he expected to have shd not be suppressed. He says he cannot carry out his plan without them. Whatever may be the supplementary vote you may finally determine to ask for there can be now no doubt that it will be supported by the Whig leaders & many of the Peelites – Ld John [Russell,]* Palmerston & S. HerbertFootnote 156 have declared this & wish you to know it. — It seems to me of vital importance to employ the next 4 months actively in our preparations. L.N. cannot attack England in winter even if he had not other domestic amusements in hand. These months are invaluable & are to us what the peace of Amiens was to Napoleon the 1st. when it gave him time to create his artillery. — My opinion still is that L.N. will avoid a war with us if he can, but I now know that he is preparing for it – Mr. HamondFootnote 157 the Cherburgh [sic] consul has been to me today – 300 large cannon have arrived at St. Malo & 30 at Granville – There are four times the number of men employed in Cherburgh dockyard that there were in April last. Within a month a new class of steamer has been built 130 feet long with a screw & flat bottomed evidently made to carry & land troops in shallow water. They would not draw 5 feet being iron laid over wood so that men could jump out & walk ashore — The French pretend they are for the African & S. American rivers but that cannot be as they could not outlive the voyage with flat bottoms. They wd be most formidable boats because as they need not be towed they wd accompany without retarding the large steamers to effect a most instantaneous landing for the first detachments to obtain a footing — After Mr. Hamond I saw Walewski & held the language you instructed me to repeat to him respecting the title of Nap[oleon] III. — He appeared much annoyed at the difficulties to be expected from the great powers, but said he wd hope to the last that there wd be no appearance of coalition between them & England – that if there was[,] sooner or later it must occasion a war in wh we shd be left to pay the piper, that the President did not care for them if we stood aloof for he knew they had neither the pluck nor power to hurt him – that he would make all the explanations necessary to save our credit & honour & that if we refused to recognise the numeral all his friendly conduct would have been ungratefully received.— Here he used the old arguments – I replied that we had determined nothing, that if explanations were given they must be official & such as I could repeat to Parl[iamen]t.
The moral of all this is that I am convinced we should immediately ask for 5000 seamen – 1000 marines & money for our seven steamers – 2000 artillerymen shd also be raised because they cannot be made soldiers as quickly as infantry —
75
Malmesbury to Derby, DP 920 DER (14) 144/1
28 November [1852]
I send you the Russian despatches.Footnote 158 I have had a long conference with Brunnow who says that my view is the best for England & that the declaration I shall get from L.N. will be of the greatest use to the other powers. He says also that nothing can have been more honorable [sic] & friendly than our conduct to all of them, & he even added that ours was the most practical & statesmanlike view of the subject —
I am glad our hands are free — I am writing a despatch for Cowley to clinch the nail I want to drive into the French govt. & I will call on you this afternoon to shew it you.
76
Malmesbury to Derby, DP 920 DER (14) 144/1
1 December [1852]
Will you have the goodness to send the inclosed letter to the Queen when you have read it —
My opinion is that we must now obtain the recognition by D[rouyn] de L[’Huys].* of the memorandum as proposed by Cowley as all we are likely to get, & that when we recognise the Empire I should announce it in my place in Parl[iamen]t. & state the objections we felt to the numeral & under what circumstances those objections were waived. This will bind the French historically as much as any thing they can give us on paper. I would advise holding out & writing a note which he must answer, but if he did so in the language Walewski used the other day & wh I shall notice at his court, it would lead to a wrangle —
This again I should not mind were I not persuaded that the H[ouse]. of Commons is too ignorant or too vulgar to see & appreciate the value of our objections to a cipher —
77
Malmesbury to Derby, DP 920 DER (14) 144/1
‘Wednesday’ [8 December 1852]Footnote 159
Many thanks for Guizot[’]sFootnote 160 letter — There is a great deal of truth in it but he never was more wrong than in calling L.N. indolent. He never was a minute of his life unoccupied either with violent exercises or study. [. . .]
