Debating the Roman bishop's rise to primacy in the Christian Church remains an attractive venture for historians of the late Roman world. In this magisterial study, Philippe Blaudeau tackles the question anew by carefully balancing the power and influence of the Roman bishops against those of their Eastern colleagues between the fifth and the sixth centuries, taking into account the ever-shifting relationships between the five great episcopal sees around the late antique Mediterranean (Rome, Constantinople, Alexandria, Antioch and Jerusalem).
B. adopts a ‘geo-ecclesiastical’ perspective, which has also informed his previous monograph Alexandrie et Constantinople (451–491) (2006). Behind this perspective lies the supposition that the Christological controversies of the first half of the fifth century, which involved a by now largely Christianized population organized in administratively ‘mature’ churches, had turned Christianity into a ‘global’ enterprise, one that was seeking to set agendas and influence behaviour over long distances. The drivers of this change, however, had been Alexandria and Constantinople, while Rome was a relative new-comer to the game in the wake of the second council of Ephesus (a.d. 449). While Alexandrie et Constantinople took us to a.d. 491 (the death of Zeno), this book's real focus, despite its chronological parameters, is on the first half of the sixth century, until the death of Agapitus (a.d. 536), as it was the Acacian schism and its aftermath that provided the Roman bishop with an opportunity to hone Leo's ideology of petrinity. Nonetheless, and this is the overall argument of the book, the bishop of Rome struggled to come out a winner, due to a number of factors: the inability to influence behaviour in the East directly, rather than through the cumbersome method of irregular embassies and written correspondence, the difficulties in establishing an identity for the Roman see against the background of Ostrogothic rulers, energetic Roman aristocrats and home-grown schisms, and finally, once these issues were resolved, the appearance of an emperor with a vision of a ‘flat’ church hierarchy in the form of Justinian. All of this means, B. warns us, that we should not see this period as the one laying the foundation for the power structure of the medieval papacy. Rather, the institution of the papacy was part of a historical development, ‘lequel n'est même pas linéaire’ (9–10).
After a finely worded introduction laying down these parameters, which gives a breathtaking overview of previous scholarship all the way back to the Reformation and decidedly refutes Roman bishops’ ‘Prussian-style’ pursuit of power, we are treated to a substantial discussion of the sources. These are divided into texts that give a Roman perspective, and texts sent to Rome and preserved in the bishop's archives, which provides B. with an opportunity to investigate papal techniques of memory construction. Again, these were fairly haphazard, reflected in the fact that the late Roman see, contrary to others, did not develop a coherent narrative of its past, other than a text originating from a context of schism, the Liber pontificalis. B. then proceeds to a historical overview of the period under investigation, which would have been perhaps better placed at the beginning of the study (ch. 3), and to an investigation of the relationship between the Roman bishop and the secular forces that surrounded him (emperor, Ostrogothic kings and senators), which focuses much on Gelasius, the Roman bishop most at liberty to express a radical petrine viewpoint (ch. 4). The last two chapters (well-illustrated by maps) juxtapose the ideal ecclesiology of the Roman see initiated by Leo, centred on the triangular, but hierarchical relationship between the ‘apostolic’ sees Rome, Alexandria and Antioch, with the real ecclesialité, the pre-eminence of the bishop of Constantinople in the East, largely dismissed or even ignored by Roman bishops of the late fifth century so preoccupied with Alexandria. It is only under Hormisdas that a more wholesome solution to the vexed relationship between Rome and Constantinople was proposed, when Hormisdas’ deacon and ambassador to Constantinople, Dioscorus, the tragic hero of this book, proposed the concept of the ecclesia assidua (269): the position of Constantinople as not only a product of imperial will, but as justified by its ‘unremitting’ contribution to Christian unity throughout its history; an elegant way to confer honour without undermining Rome's petrine supremacy. This paved the way for Rome's hour of triumph when, in a.d. 536, on the brink of the Ostrogothic-Byzantine war, a Roman bishop visited Constantinople to ordain a patriarch, welcomed by the Eastern Chalcedonian forces. It also, however — and unforeseen by Hormisdas and Dioscorus — paved the way for Justinian's idea of a pentarchy of the major sees of the Roman Empire. The outcome of Justinian's war sealed Rome's fate as one of these for two further centuries.
The concept of géo-ecclésiologie shaping this argument is often implied, rather than fully developed theoretically and linked to current historiographical trends of global, centreless or entangled history, which might have been fruitful. Yet, the study entirely makes up for this through its flawless command of the sources. B.'s language is often dense and painfully detailed, engaging with every possible objection to his interpretations, due to the nature of the exercise, as this book is also the author's thèse d'habilitation. Yet, the reader is fully rewarded, for this is a study that will tell you everything you ever wanted to know but were always too afraid to ask about the puzzling abundance of sources produced during the Acacian schism. B. is certainly not the first to reject a linear history of the papacy, but he does it so powerfully that it will be hard to argue otherwise. Above all, he offers an exciting read: we, like the Roman bishops, are constantly given a glimpse of papal success, only to be frustrated again.
