Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-fvjsw Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T12:00:41.027Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Reminiscence, Reflections, and Resonance: The Just Intonation Resophonic Guitar and Lou Harrison's Scenes from Nek Chand

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  09 May 2012

GIACOMO FIORE*
Affiliation:
gf@giacomofiore.com
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Upon accepting a commission for a solo guitar piece from the 2002 Open Minds Music Festival in San Francisco, Lou Harrison decided to write Scenes from Nek Chand for a unique instrument: a resonator guitar refretted in just intonation. Harrison's last completed work draws inspiration from the sound of Hawaiian music that the composer remembered hearing in his youth, as well as from the artwork populating Nek Chand's Rock Garden of Chandigarh, India.

Based on archival research, oral histories, and the author's insights as a performer of contemporary music, this article examines the piece's inception, outlining the organological evolution of resophonic guitars and their relationship to Hawaiian music. It addresses the practical and aesthetic implications of the composer's choice of tuning, and examines the work of additional artists, such as Terry Riley and Larry Polansky, who have contributed to the growing repertoire for the just intonation resophonic guitar.

Information

Type
Research Article
Copyright
Copyright © The Society for American Music 2012
Figure 0

Figure 1.Illustrations from one of John Dopyera's patents for the tricone resophonic guitar.

Figure 1

Example 1.Overtone series on G, with the pitches of Nek Chand represented by filled notes. The two rows of ratios indicate intervals between adjacent pitches of the mode (above the staff), and the intonation of each individual pitch in relation to the fundamental G (below the staff), with deviation from equal temperament in cents.

Figure 2

Table 1.Intervals for Scenes from Nek Chand

Figure 3

Example 2.open strings of a guitar tuned to DADGAD, with their respective harmonics at the twelfth, seventh, and fifth fret. (notated at sounding pitch)

Figure 4

Example 3.sample tuning sequence using harmonics and open strings only (notated at sounding pitch).

Figure 5

Example 4.Dual descending motive in “The Leaning Lady” (2001), Reproduced by permission of the Lou Harrison Archive, Special Collections, University of California, Santa Cruz.

Figure 6

Example 5.Interrupted drone (jhala) pattern in “The Leaning Lady” (2001), Notice the alternation of dissonant (C-sharp, F) and consonant intervals. Reproduced by permission of the Lou Harrison Archive, Special Collections, University of California, Santa Cruz.

Figure 7

Example 6.“The Leaning Lady,” coda, with fading dissonances (marked with *) (2001). Reproduced by permission of the Lou Harrison Archive, Special Collections, University of California, Santa Cruz.

Figure 8

Example 7.“The Rock Garden,” main theme (2001–02). Reproduced by permission of the Lou Harrison Archive, Special Collections, University of California, Santa Cruz.

Figure 9

Example 8.“The Rock Garden,” syncopated retransition (2001–02). Reproduced by permission of the Lou Harrison Archive, Special Collections, University of California, Santa Cruz.

Figure 10

Example 9.“The Sinuous Arcade. . .,” refrain x (above) and y (below) (2001–02). Reproduced by permission of the Lou Harrison Archive, Special Collections, University of California, Santa Cruz.

Figure 11

Example 10.Variations in the close of refrain y to accommodate for beginning of following verselet (2001–02). Reproduced by permission of the Lou Harrison Archive, Special Collections, University of California, Santa Cruz.

Figure 12

Example 11.“The Sinuous Arcade. . .,” fading farewell gesture (2001–02). Reproduced by permission of the Lou Harrison Archive, Special Collections, University of California, Santa Cruz.

Figure 13

Figure 2.Lattice diagrams for the original tuning (above), and Bill Alves's proposal for a twelve-pitch completion (below). A left-to-right step on the horizontal axis represents a pure fifth (3:2); bottom-to-top describes pure major thirds (5:4); a harmonic seventh relationship (7:4) is drawn on the Z-axis (front to back); intervals with a ratio of 11:8 fall on an auxiliary fourth dimension, drawn in forward and left.

Figure 14

Figure 3.Bill Slye's final tuning scheme for the just intonation tricone resonator.

Figure 15

Table 2.Side-by-side comparison of the two tuning proposals and final tuning; note the availability of otonal hexads (1:1–3:2–5:4–7:4–9:8–11:8) over G and D.

Figure 16

Table 3.Current repertoire list for the just intonation resonator guitar.

Figure 17

Figure 4.Bill Slye with the first National prototype. Photograph courtesy of John Schneider.