In this mixed methods study, Anna Berti Suman takes a novel approach to the study of citizen sensing, exploring the question of why governments adopt citizen sensing methods and data and the reason behind their policy uptake. Suman's The Policy Uptake of Citizen Sensing views citizen sensing through the constructs of risk, technology, grassroots, and distrust while focusing primarily on the European Union. The book thoroughly explains and deconstructs her study's creation, development, methodology, data, analysis, and results.
The book unfolds across four chapters, an introduction and conclusion. Chapter 2 explores the study's independent variables, Chapter 3 the dependent variables, and Chapter 4 the empirical and case studies and results. Each chapter begins with a simple pictorial of the chapter's theme. The author weaves useful charts, graphics, and tables throughout the book. Also included are helpful visualizations of her methodologies, research questions, analyses, and results. She also includes detailed subheadings throughout each long chapter that guide the reader through her research.
Following a short introduction that focuses primarily on her research methodology, Chapter 2 defines citizen sensing and the parameters Suman uses in selecting the citizen sensing projects, with the focus on the independent variables in her study. The four variables are: the technologies used in citizen sensing (viewing it both as a social phenomenon and innovative research method); the grassroots nature of citizen sensing (who form the groups and whether they are representative of a whole population); risk (what is the challenge faced by the citizen sensors and what level of risk does it have to their wellbeing); and distrust (what level of distrust citizen sensors have towards their institutions). By dedicating an entire chapter to defining her independent variables, Suman emphasizes their importance to her study.
Chapter 3 deconstructs the concept and study of policy uptake, noting that policy uptake itself is a complex issue. This chapter focuses on the dependent variables in her study, social and policy uptakes. Suman argues for recognizing policy uptake as a field of study: since citizen sensing is a viable monitoring method, then both social (whether others/society adopts it) and policy uptake are worth studying. Social uptake is deconstructed first, as Suman explains that social uptake is useful since it can influence or push forward policy uptake. This requires carefully defining social uptake, identifying criteria by which to measure it, and its influence on policy uptake. Next, Suman focuses on policy uptake, starting with a literature review and a discussion of policy uptake's nuances and how those nuances influence her study. As an example, a policy uptake may be manifest (in which citizen sensing is openly acknowledged by the institution as a reason for the uptake); or silent (in which no such acknowledgment is made). She finishes the chapter by discussing the quality of the data available (which results is an interesting data pyramid, p. 93); and what she will study in her empirical analysis.
Chapter 4 provides the meat of the book. It empirically answers the question of when policy uptake occurs in a way that mitigates or eliminates the risk being addressed. Suman walks the reader through her methodology and the process behind the development of her research. It is a meandering road that explains both the findings and the limits of her approach and includes the various testing and fieldwork she developed in order to both justify and conduct her research (see the chart on page 124 for a visual of this process). Her first step is two case studies: she dives deeply into them, using both literature and interviews to build the story. Next, using the case studies, she develops her hypotheses for how and why policy uptake occurs. This next step relies initially on observation, feedback, and an extensive data set compiled by the Joint Research Centre of the European Commission, which was already exploring how citizen science could be used in developing environmental policy. Initially frustrated when her parameters cut down the possible dataset to just ten use cases, Suman then decided to use a mixed methods approach. This analysis demonstrated that both social and policy uptake require high risk combined with good technology and strong data dissemination. Building on this result, Suman returns to her case studies to pinpoint additional data, ultimately concluding that policy uptake can be largely contextual and that gathering all data around a citizen sensing project can be a daunting task.
Ultimately, while policy makers seemed interested in receiving citizen data, citizens themselves typically lacked the desire to influence policy, which meant that policy uptake was frequently an unforeseen outcome that occurs when policy makers perceive an institutional gap and when citizen sensors have champions (especially institutional champions). Finally, Chapter 5 offers a conclusion in which Suman briefly summarizes her study, how she developed it, her results, and both the limitations she saw in her study and the potential future research the study could foster.
Overall, the book provides an intense, in-depth view of a very specific question, using a relatively narrow dataset. Those interested in the niche topic of environmental citizen sensing and its impact on institutional policies will find the book a delightful and thorough read; those interested in reviewing an example of a research project using a mixed-methods approach may also find it worth a read. While not a book for a general audience, it will likely prove useful for those within the environmental citizen sensing space.
