Nicolas Trépanier's Foodways & Daily Life in Medieval Anatolia is an ambitious, nuanced, and well-written study that focuses on an understudied period of Anatolia, from a relatively rare lens even in the wider field of history: food. Using food as a lens through which one can understand an entire society, involving layers from economics to culture and daily life, while not new, remains a valuable and innovative approach, especially in the context of 14th-century Anatolia, where no such research has ever been conducted.
The book is organized into four chapters, covering the connections between food production, exchanges, consumption, and religion. The main focus is on “common people,” with some exceptions, and the “everyday” nature of these connections with food. It is a comprehensive study that touches on subjects as varied as agriculture, pastoralism, rituals of consumption, and the impact of large scale events such as wars upon the daily rhythms of people and their food. Despite the large variety of subjects covered in this broad survey, the unifying theme is always food, and its ability to create relational experiences for people, which, in turn, tells us more about 14th-century Anatolian society as a whole. Trépanier dwells on the aspect of social hierarchy as seen from the prism of food, revealing the inherent inequalities, and struggles, not concentrating on macrolevel events such as revolutions or wars, but from the everyday frictions between people of different social classes. These frictions were evident in the highly subjective—and, as he notes, useful precisely for this reason—nature of his sources. He also challenges perspectives based on religious differences between the Christian and Muslim communities of central Anatolia, and presents a more class-oriented picture of that society, with an emphasis on shared experiences outweighing religious divisions in daily life. It is difficult to simply summarize a book this ambitious, with such a variety of subjects and goals, short of writing a review as long as the book itself. However, the lasting impression of Trépanier's work is that of texture, of an attempt to portray a society not through well-established categorizations and historical paradigms, but portraying the less visible, less definable, relational aspects of society, albeit from a distance of more than seven centuries.
The ambitious nature of the book offers a number of innovative perspectives, but also significant limitations, especially in the conceptualization of space for Anatolia; Trépanier creates a convenient and well-defined border between central Anatolia and the coastal regions and their immediate hinterlands, but does not truly consider the interconnectedness and the intensely networked nature of the land in question, and this in turn creates avoidable problems throughout the book. Even with the caveat sentence where this narrow spatial definition is described as a “guideline to selection of sources” and not a “sharply defined geographical and chronological scope” (p. 8), it remains a key conceptual concern.
The second major conceptual assumption of the book suggests that central Anatolia had fewer Byzantine influences by this time, because of longer Muslim rule in the region, unlike the coastal provinces. It is inherently connected to the idea that because the “social and cultural landscape of Anatolia changed dramatically between the Byzantine and Ottoman periods” it would be “foolish to assume that food practices did not change as well” (p. 10). This idea of a radical change between the Byzantine and Ottoman periods does not have a lot of support in Byzantine or Ottoman historiography. To the contrary, many Byzantine and Ottoman historians emphasize the continuity of essential practices, institutions, and ways of life, in addition to the obvious changes that come from population movement, wars, and religious and political changes over centuries. If we are to use the radical change approach, we would need a much more thorough debate in the text itself on that subject before accepting it as a cornerstone upon which further theses can be constructed.
Admittedly, Trépanier has a significant challenge with the nature of his sources, and the study treats sources with nuance and care. However, why limit written sources to “Muslim” sources, for example, such as the waqfiyyas? Contemporary Byzantine records offer just as much, if not more in every aspect of daily life in the areas that were beyond Byzantine control in central Anatolia. There is no objective reason to omit the most extensive history-writing tradition of the land because the land itself is no longer under the political dominion of that state; the Byzantine cultural sphere certainly extended into central Anatolia in the 14th century, and Byzantine writers traveled extensively in that geography. The cookbooks of the time, or slightly earlier or later cookbooks, are also eliminated because they are Abbasid or Persian (Safavid in the specific example given in the book) in origin, but the hybridization of Anatolia certainly had these influences, among others: Byzantine, Abbasid, and Persian. There was a reason for the Rum Seljuks and their successor states to adopt a Byzantine–Persian state tradition, courtly etiquette, land management, and army practices. When such sources are eliminated, one creates an insular temporal slice, in addition to the insular spatial definition. Other than these issues, the methodology of the study is sophisticated, nuanced, and carefully formulated. Trépanier's emphasis on the daily and ordinary, or the quotidian, is not a new approach, but it is worthwhile in this geography and time period, and I do not recall any study that specifically approaches the subject with these priorities.
Following the structure of the book, the chapter on food production and peasants’ lives provides concise, but careful coverage of material reality: fields, animals, and transportation. However, achieving all this, plus the connection to nomadism, pastoralism, geography, and social hierarchy in a mere twenty-three pages necessitates shortcuts and leaves the reader in breathless rush. One certainly does not have to go to the length of a Braudel or Bloch in covering these subjects, and there are obvious limitations with the sources at hand, but in a book that is primarily about food and what it tells us about society, the material reality deserves more attention.
Food as exchange, the theme for the second chapter, analyzes the impact of exchange (as a broadly defined term, rather than simply limited to markets) and macrolevel dynamics such as administration and war, on ordinary people. In many ways, the coverage of these subjects has the same strengths and weaknesses as the first chapter, where nineteen pages for such broad and diversified dynamics do not do justice to the subjects at hand. The discussions on the role of markets, transportation, water, taxes, and the army are well conceived, but very brief.
The chapter on food consumption, and social hierarchy as observed through food, outlines the strict divisions between layers of that hierarchy, and makes creative use of some of the sources, especially in the case of Rumi's anecdotes and observations, including his encounter with an Armenian butcher. The frame of reference limits the impact of the arguments to an extent, as the inclusion of Aegean, Black Sea, and Mediterranean coasts/hinterlands with higher population densities would not have undermined Trépanier's arguments, but provided essential comparative insights in a land that was much more interconnected than the study proposes. Nonetheless, Trépanier's observation about the impact of the low density of the population upon every field of life is nothing short of a revelation, and deserves attention. This chapter also showcases a strength of the book in Trépanier's treatment of his sources, which is thorough and critical, and he is clearly aware of their limitations.
The final chapter, focusing on food and religion, at times feels distanced from the rest of the book, as the quotidian element occasionally fades into the background. Admittedly, sorting through and analyzing the religious nuances within the central Anatolian population could be the task of a lengthy book by itself. Essential rituals of fasting and sacrifice as well as less widespread rituals such as rain prayers are briefly covered; it is difficult to follow how these rituals were expressed in daily life, and how the extremely heterogeneous communities of Anatolia not only practiced, but experienced, these rituals in their daily lives. The narrative occasionally treats “Muslims” as an absolute, monolithic category, when there were tremendous differences in the way Islam was practiced and experienced in these lands. Of course, some of these limitations come directly from the sources themselves.
Finally, one of the most promising subjects for any study on the connection between Islam and food—the issue of wine and mind-altering substances such as hashish or cannabis—deserves a more focused and thorough argument. For example, Trépanier, in connecting an earlier observation in the book to this subject, hypothesizes that wine may have been too expensive for the masses, resulting in relatively low accessibility for lower classes, and reducing the visibility of the potential differences in wine consumption between Christian and Muslim populations. The hypothesis is not developed further. Even in the narrow spatial definition of central Anatolia, wine production, an essential staple of the economy for millennia, continued unabated between the Byzantine and Ottoman periods, let alone in the rich vineyards of the Aegean and northwestern Anatolian farmlands and river valleys, as well as in Cilicia. Central Anatolia was not only producing wine itself in ancient viticulture areas such as Cappadocia, it was enveloped by three of the most prolific wine-producing regions in the world at the time, all at a week's travel distance by camel caravan. A consequence of this abundance of wine was the presence of multiple qualities of wine in the markets, and the accessibility of cheap wine, consumed precisely by the lower classes that attract Trépanier's interest throughout the book. This example also highlights the strengths and limitations of this ambitious, very well-written book; it leaves the reader with a hunger to read more of it.
