Mark Benbow's book is the latest in a number of recent volumes that reexamine the role of religion in the policies, politics, and lives of Americans in the Gilded Age and Progressive Era.Footnote 1 The strength of this book is the author's familiarity with the Presbyterian theology in which Woodrow Wilson was immersed from childhood until he entered politics. Benbow explains simply and clearly Wilson's Southern Presbyterian beliefs about “covenant” and “federal headship” (3–12). These ideas, along with the other ideological attitudes the president developed over his life, formed the mental tapestry that directed his approach to international relations.
Benbow's explanation of Wilson's complex approach to policy decisions is a strength of this book. The president made his foreign policy decisions from a place of isolation that, as Robert W. Tucker recently remarked, was “without parallel among American presidents.”Footnote 2 Wilson's religious upbringing and thought patterns influenced the approach he took to language and action. His internal sense of divine calling explains his feeling of isolation. The president's religious upbringing gave him a faith in the ability of language and words to create reality. To Wilson, words carried creative capacity and the ability to hold contradictions together in the mystery of Providence. He believed that he was ultimately accountable to a higher authority and could not fully rely on his advisors as they were not privy to his own inner truth. His sense of reality transcended the precise legal meanings that his advisers were reading into vital documents and communications.
According to Wilson's theology, the world was not neatly separated into sacred and secular but was a whole to be fit into a theological framework. Previous scholars have also emphasized the significance of Wilson's religious beliefs: John Mulder's 1978 Woodrow Wilson, The Years of Preparation details how Wilson's tradition of faith applied religious views to the world at large.Footnote 3 What has been missing until recently is an application of those ideas specifically to the way in which the president conducted foreign policy. For most historians accustomed to taking a materialist and reasoned approach to history, extra rational approaches, particularly those that might be rooted in faith, are problematic. It is easier to assume they were not important enough to the final outcome in the “real” world to warrant exploration. Benbow bridges the gulf through the use of the theory of analogical reasoning, making the extra-rational world of faith and theology accessible to the rational world of historians of foreign policy (1–3).
Leading Them to the Promised Land begins with the chaos of the Mexican Revolution up to 1913. Two of Wilson's initial foreign policy goals were to repudiate Taft's “Dollar Diplomacy” in favor of a more idealistic approach and to restore order to the United States's southern neighbor. Benbow sheds new light on old subjects. Rather than condoning imperialism as usual, Wilson believed that by imposing a providential, covenant-based scheme onto the messy politics of Mexico, he was following a divine pattern: “Covenants were a method of bringing order to chaos, of moving those emerging from the wilderness closer to God and heaven” (10).
The president's desire for order, particularly the fascination that began in his youth with covenants and constitutions, has been well documented, but Benbow's application of Wilson's theological idea of “federal headship” adds a new dimension to the story. The concept of federal headship was common among Southern Presbyterians. According to this theology, Adam's sin in the Garden of Eden made Adam the “representative” of all humanity, leaving all guilty. That a single representative can be responsible for a group had implications beyond theology for Wilson. A country's president could be seen as the “federal head” of his nation, representing and speaking on its behalf before the rest of the world. That Wilson believed this idea of “representative responsibility” gives a rationality to his personalization of politics. It is why he focused on the personality of the kaiser when considering war with Germany, and it explains his sense of personal responsibility in the treaty fight, having given his word at Versailles. This idea makes sense of what otherwise seems to be unwarranted involvement in Mexico's affairs. The American ambassador, Henry Lane Wilson, had been a participant in the coup that overthrew Francisco Madero. This made the United States guilty for the subsequent murder of President Madero and the rise to power of Victoriano Huerta (19–24). It was up to the president as the representative of the United States to right that wrong. This added theological motivation gives the history of Wilson's foreign policy a new dimension.
Once the major theoretical foundations have been laid, the book examines the major points in United States/Mexican relations through Wilson's Southern Presbyterian lens. The story follows the slide toward the invasion of Veracruz. Benbow traces as well Wilson's desire to “teach” Mexicans “to elect good men,” the failure of the president's “lesson plan,” the background of the ABC Conference, and finally the unintended consequences of the whole affair. The book underscores the mystification that many of Wilson's colleagues exhibited with regard to his motives. The theological template sets this book apart from others on U.S. foreign policy in Mexico during this period.
Leading Them to the Promised Land concludes with Wilson's ideological template for his conduct of foreign policy. Benbow lays it out in a very “Wilsonian” six points (125–26). This is a useful template for understanding the way the president believed that he was carrying out his world mission. A final irony, however, is that these points were not always how the president acted. Point two, for example, is related to the importance of discussion to help rulers determine the popular will. Once the president's mind was made up, he usually avoided discussion. Point six, a commitment to non intervention, seems particularly ironic in the Mexican situation. Wilson's theological views were both the good and the bad in his policy, and Benbow's Wilson compellingly demonstrates both.
