The last ten years has witnessed a veritable surge in the writing of Korean history textbooks. Clearly, publishers have learned that there is a buck to be made from this young and growing field. For teachers, this boon has the decided advantage of more than doubling the number of textbooks available in English. To the most recent works of Michael Robinson, Keith Pratt, and Kyung Moon Hwang, Michael Seth has added the most ambitious volume in the past ten years, coming in at just over 500 pages of text, A History of Korea: From Antiquity to the Present.
It will be only the most eager of students who is willing to read the entirety of a book that lands with a loud thump on one's desk, but for those who persevere, the rewards will be plenty. Seth has written a highly readable account starting with the earliest inhabitants of the peninsula down to the first decade of our own century. For teachers keen to teach through primary sources, Seth has followed each chapter with a key text. Though not the original translations of the author, these texts enrich the narrative. In keeping with recent academic trends, Seth also helpfully adds to each chapter a section entitled “Korea in Global Perspective,” which seeks to avoid the isolation of much national history to position the peninsula in a broader context.
Readers will quibble with some of the author's inevitably debatable decisions about a history rife with historiographical controversies: should the Tan'gun myth be reproduced as part of the earliest chapter on Korean history or should it be included in the Koryŏ section, when the myth was first written? How can the foreign relations of the late Chosŏn dynasty be reconfigured in line with theories that the Qing must be seen as a multi-ethnic Empire? Can a history of the colonial period acknowledge economic growth without writing specifically of capitalism? What are the consequences when we virtually reduce the history of North Korea to that of Kim Ilsung? Seth felicitously chooses to highlight specific historiographical dilemma within his prose. At times he explicitly notes the debates and alternative understandings of historians; at other points, he simply asks the type of rhetorical questions that belie easy answers, such as “Was Korea toward the end of the Yi Dynasty a society in decline?” (p. 218). Such an approach will play well in the classroom, as it offers a somewhat unsettled history, one that foregrounds the still ongoing efforts of historians to grapple with the past as a series of enduring problems and unanswered questions.
If there is one overarching theme, it is a conviction that underlies much of the Korean history field: that a major purpose for the study of the peninsula's history lies in revealing Korea's uniqueness. From the first sentence to the concluding chapter, Seth's narrative is sprinkled with adjectives—”distinctive,” “remarkable,” “different,” and “incomparable”—that revel in this form of national difference. The opening of Seth's separately published A Concise History of Modern History, which brings together the modern chapters of the first volume, launches its introduction with the assertion, “Korea has a history unlike any other modern nation” (p. 1). Such attention to particularity is perhaps an occupational hazard for a young field trying to assert itself. Whether for the purpose of offering an intellectual raison d'etre or for the purpose of hustling for resources within the university, the turn to uniqueness offers something of an answer to the “Why study Korea?” question that all members of the field face, whether from the public or university administrators. So, too, does the turn to uniqueness neatly fit the ambitions of many institutions in the ROK eager to ‘brand’ Korea on the international stage and, in the very public aspirations of some, to turn this brand into that ever amorphous and elusive foreign policy goal, soft power.
Yet such an approach to history forgets that at the beginning of the twenty-first century, when every nation-state proclaims its difference and when every national tourist agency markets particularity, there really is nothing unique about being unique. Rather, the very act of articulating difference is part of the logic of our international system (and, regrettably, a field defined by the bounds of the nation-state) that itself needs to be both subject to scrutiny and woven into our historical narratives.
Indeed, the richness of A History of Korea and A Concise History of Modern History gives ample evidence of the myriad issues, subjects, and historical problems that will interest both academic and non-academic audiences without necessitating a turn to uniqueness. That Seth's two valuable volumes offer the scope to allow us to imagine these alternatives will ensure that readers will be entertained, intrigued, and pleased.
