What became individually and collectively of the network of cities that articulated the Roman Empire continues to fascinate a scholarly community that is perhaps uneasily aware of the lessons this may hold for a planet where now more than half of all humanity lives in cities, cities that are seen as increasingly at the mercy of natural forces and environmental change; the precarious equilibrium with the resources to sustain these places; the threat of political instability and warfare; shifts in economic patterns of supply and demand. All these factors are evoked in the various contributions that compose this collection. As the title suggests, the examples chosen are those that tend to the discontinuity end of the continuity-discontinuity spectrum (though the polarization this spectrum imposes is rightly criticized), many of the examples being ones which are now well-known to the archaeologist precisely because there is no successor city to obscure the ancient site. The examples range from Britain to Syria, though Italy and the West comprise the majority of the papers. This allows for a wide range of individual narratives and causations, but the range covered and the variety of experiences of desertion (or not), as well as the geographical patchiness, make it difficult for the editors to draw any general conclusions or propose any overarching exegesis of the subject. If anything, the variety of experiences seems to suggest that the search for generalizing explanations may be doomed from the start. But that is no reason for not at least trying.
The individual contributions summarize the results of new work, principally survey and excavation, at a number of sites along with the posing of new questions of well-known sites and/or material from earlier excavations, some of which were not particularly interested in the ‘post-Classical’ deposits, a particularly acute problem with Knossos and Sparta (Sweetman). The majority of the sites discussed are ones which had a ‘Classical’ phase, with the street-grids and public buildings and monuments of the high empire. This does risk playing into a long-established framework which sees the ‘Classical’ city as the ‘type’ of Roman-period urbanism with what happens after as an aberration: the book's subtitle with its evocation of the ‘post-Classical’ city also implies that the second century a.d. is some sort of benchmark. Instead, of course, cities should be seen as expressions of societies’ needs in their own period, and this is what the bulk of the authors do in examining their sites, even when examining change at sites as ‘Classical’ as Cyrene (Sears et al.), Pollentia (Cau), Potentia (Vermeulen), Hierapolis (Arthur) or Silchester (Fulford). And this is where the two definitely ‘post-Classical’ sites, Classe (Augenti) and Recópolis (Velázquez and Ripoll), are so valuable, since they show us what people in the fifth and seventh centuries wanted as a city — and it was not a pale imitation of the second century. Each, of course had a very particular function. Classe was a port and its layout and building-stock reflect this; the importance of major churches is noteworthy. Recópolis was a purpose-built Visigothic royal seat with its defences, church, main square and major building interpreted as a palace or a storehouse (or one on top of the other). Is this very particular vision of urbanism inspired by one of the post-Classical cities about which we desperately need to know more, Visigothic Toledo? At Butrint (Bowden and Hodges) churches again were crucial in mediating between Antiquity and the Middle Ages, oscillating between two poles either side of the inlet. Cosa (Cirelli and Fentress) could be included here since it is sufficiently different from what went before to qualify essentially as yet another new use of the site (though whether ‘urban’ is moot).
The book's title juxtaposes ‘extinction’ and ‘abandonment’: is this justified? What is the process of abandonment? Is abandonment of a particular urban place also abandonment of urbanism, or just of a particular and contingent expression of it? Are cities that became abandoned an unrepresentative sub-category by virtue(?) of having been abandoned? Even a site long-considered to be an example of ‘Pompeian’ single-event abandonment, Dura-Europos (Baird), turns out to have been changing significantly before the Persian siege and to have had an afterlife. Hierapolis saw a long sequence of occupation on the site before the centre of gravity moved more recently to Pamukkale leaving the ancient site abandoned (to tourists). But this raises the notion that we should perhaps be looking at ‘urbanism’ rather than at a specific ‘urban place’; the latter may come and go or wander round the landscape, as a differing expression of social, political, economic, religious needs for a ‘central place’ over time. In their beginning is their end: did the reasons for the foundation of an urban place predestine it to becoming redundant when those reasons no longer held? In the presentation of Potentia and in the Introduction (Christie) it is clear that a number of Roman military coloniae in Italy did not make the cut; it would be interesting to look at the whole class to see if they carried the seeds of their own failure. In brief sum, even if the range of sites and their situations presented here is hugely disparate, so also are the processes and reasons for post-Classical ‘abandonment’, giving us many different models to work with.
