Since Mahmud Ahmadinejad became president of the Islamic Republic of Iran in 2005 and surprised the world by expressing strong messianic expectations, articles on the figure of the Mahdi and the nature of Shiʿi apocalyptic aspirations have increasingly found their way into the pages of the Western press. In academia, too, there has been a new wave of interest in Iran's recent postrevolutionary religious developments. This book by Abbas Amanat, a professor of history and international and area studies at Yale University, deals with the themes of Islamic apocalypticism, Twelver Shiʿi messianism, and aspects of clerical encounters with modernity. Aside from the introduction and Chapter 10, the chapters are slightly revised versions of articles that Amanat has written in the course of the last two decades and have already been published in various volumes of collected essays (see the sources on p. xvf). The chapters are grouped in four parts: “Apocalypticism in the Islamic Middle East,” “Millennial Cycles and Commemorating Martyrs,” “Clerical Encounters with Modernity,” and “Satan and Salvation in the Islamic Revolution.”
Following an introductory chapter outlining the historical development of Shiʿism in Iran, the two chapters in Part I provide an overview of the ideas of apocalypticism and millennialism in the Middle East's salvation religions. Invented by the Babylonians as a unit of time reckoning, the millennium likely first obtained an apocalyptic significance in Iranian Zoroastrianism; it was then adopted by Judaism, Christianity, and Islam. Amanat rightly highlights the fact that apocalyptic anxieties have hardly subsided and in fact are used in the present day as justification for political posturing, as with the messianic undertones in some of Khomeini's utterances or Ahmadinejad's call for “wiping Israel off the map.” This thesis is not an entirely new one. Mühlmann and Lanternari pointed to the millennarian elements in political and even secular ideologies already in the 1960s. They were followed by a number of other authors, who are cited by Amanat.
In Part II, Amanat shows that millennarian traits can also be detected in the doctrines of the cabalistic Nuqtavi movement, which came into being in northern Iran in the 15th century. For Nuqtavism, the doctrine of the cyclical renewal of prophetic revelations did not imply a messianic manifestation in the conventional Islamic sense. Rather, the advent of a new prophet in the Nuqtavi model was tantamount to terminating the Islamic cycle altogether, thus creating a de facto post-Islamic new religion. Given the paucity of primary sources, Amanat here—like other scholars—relies heavily on the pioneering work Nuqtaviyan ya Pasikhaniyan, published in 1941 by Sadiq Kiya. A new prophetic cycle was also initiated by the 19th-century Babi movement, the precursor of the Bahai religion. The most important text of its founder, Sayyid ʿAli Muhammad, is Bayan, which fulfills the function of the Babi scripture. Amanat analyzes both the content and the linguistic characteristics of Bayan, identifying features of “indigenous modernity” unique to modern Iranian religious history, namely, the use of Persian instead of Arabic as a signal of national awareness and a message of progressive renewal. The third chapter of Part II deals with Waʾiz Kashifi's Rawdat al-Shuhadaʾ (The Garden of the Martyrs), which was composed in Timurid Herat in 1502, on the eve of the Uzbek capture of the city. Compiled in the spoken Persian of its time, Rawdat al-Shuhadaʾ—Amanat argues—contributed to the Persianization of the early Islamic tragedy of Husayn in Karbala and became so successful that the narrators of Husayn's sufferings came to be known in Iran as rawza-khvan, reciters of the Rawda, who often used to recite the book verbatim.
In Part III, Amanat first addresses Shiʿi clerics’ refutations of Christian evangelicalism in the early 19th century. The polemics of the young English missionary preacher Henry Martyn, who was also the co-translator of the New Testament into Persian, generated a vast number of refutations that came to be known as radd-i padri (refuting the padre). Although there were similar polemical exchanges between Christians and Muslims in earlier centuries, Amanat underlines that Shiʿi scholars now introduced some new lines of argument. Especially remarkable was their emphasis on the evolutionary nature of prophethood and their deeper examination of the Bible, undertaken to reveal contradictions and discrepancies. Entitled “In-Between the Madrasa and the Marketplace: The Designation of Clerical Leadership in Modern Shiʿism” and first published in 1988 in Said Amir Arjomand's Authority and Political Culture in Shiʿism (Albany, N.Y.: State University of New York Press), Chapter 7 provides an excellent analysis of the emergence of the “source of emulation” (marjaʿ-i taqlīd) in the 19th century. Amanat here examines the interdependence of the quite unspecific aʿlamiya (superiority in learning), economic power, and interactions with the Qajar state. Heavily influenced by external factors, the nature of clerical leadership changed repeatedly according to conditions and exigencies. Scholarliness and the ability to exert political influence were each emphasized at different times. Amanat's most striking conclusion is that, contrary to previous appraisals, the transition from plural to singular leadership was not so much the result of the community's recognition of the most learned ʿālim but rather the madrasa–bazaar relationship that determined the position of a mujtahid as the sole head. Chapter 8 answers why the notion of the never-institutionalized marjaʿiyya (though quasi centralized under Ayatullah Burujirdi) was de facto, at least in the Iranian context, replaced by Khomeini's theory of vilāyat-i faqīh. Amanat elaborates that in the atmosphere of state-driven secular modernity and the ʿulamaʾ's legal redundancy, Khomeini's doctrine presented a solution to the old problem of unregulated leadership. Of course, it was a real novelty: never before did the clerics have the authority to govern. Furthermore, the use of the term faqīh (jurist), rather than marjaʿ or mujtahid, emphasized proficiency in fiqh instead of a clerical status based on a vaguely defined wisdom.
In Part IV, Chapter 9 explores the notion of the “Great Satan” (shayṭān-i buzurg), the term for the United States first used by Khomeini in November 1979 in a speech supporting the students who took the staff of the American Embassy in Tehran hostage. Unlike other shibboleths of the revolution, this one has endured. Amanat shows that the term is symbolically charged not only by a reference to the Qurʾanic Satan but also by Iranian legends with pre-Islamic roots and especially by the demonology of Cold War propaganda.
The tenth and last chapter addresses the issue of the new messianic trend in Iran, which enjoys the patronage of a number of conservative clerics and, notably, the current president, Mahmud Ahmadinejad. This growing enthusiasm for the Mahdi is especially associated with the mosque of Jamkaran (near Qom), which used to be a minor shrine but was transformed into a major pilgrimage site in recent years. Also remarkable is the huge number of publications and websites covering all the different aspects of Mahdism. State encouragement of Mahdism is a nearly unprecedented phenomenon in the history of Twelver Shiʿism. Amanat emphasises that apart from the personal religious convictions of Ahmadinejad and his supporters, this systematic endorsement of the Mahdi cult may be considered a conscious policy espoused by some clerics within the regime who hope to retain a following at a time when the former revolutionary rhetoric no longer seems to guarantee loyalty.
This volume offers valuable samples of Amanat's expertise in the field of Iranian Twelver Shiʿism and its apocalypticism in particular. That the author never neglects the context of the pre-Islamic Iranian traditions makes these articles even more interesting. As most of the chapters have already appeared in different publications, however, their theses and conclusions are probably not new to fellow specialists. Furthermore, parts II and III, in particular, cover quite different aspects of Iranian Shiʿism, which do not always closely correlate with each other. The newly published Chapter 10 is indeed the most interesting one: it is based on recent sources and carefully analyzes the probable causes for the contemporary messianic aspirations in Iran.
Although the book is largely a collection of previously published essays, Amanat's lucid analyses and readable style make it highly recommended to any student of modern Iran. Compiled in one volume, they will hopefully reach a larger audience, too.
