In the late 1800s, many Americans perceived college as virtually worthless, because it did not teach anything relevant to business. Only after the turn of the century did a significant number of Americans start seeing higher education as a commodity valuable for practical reasons. In Creating the College Man, Daniel A. Clark shows how college became “so vital to [American] notions of advancement” (4). He places the responsibility for this turn-of-the-century transformation on Progressive Era periodicals, which created and disseminated a type of manhood—steeped in collegiate athletics and name-brand clothing—easily consumed by the middle class. Clark's book, which builds upon scholarship by David O. Levine and John Pettegrew,Footnote 1 makes a compelling case that periodicals contributed to the shaping of middle-class manhood as well as the rising importance of college education in the early 1900s. Although some of Clark's conclusions may outstrip his relatively narrow source base, Creating the College Man is a thorough discursive analysis and a welcome addition to the historiographical literature on higher education and middle-class culture in the Progressive Era.
In the nineteenth century, because it was not uncommon for a man to begin in business as a youngster and work his way up the corporate ladder, college seemed to be necessary only for clergy or those seeking general cultural attainment. Around 1900, though, corporations grew in complexity, and women took over jobs that had once served as entry-level positions for men. College then became the place where young men learned things—“an acquaintance with science, the breadth of liberal culture, and a brush with the so-called manly athletics” (27)—that became necessary as businessmen no longer made themselves. Women were part of the new collegiate order, but mainly in traditional roles—as mothers, nurturers, and homemakers in training. In short, college was becoming a place where white men, cordoned off from the most dramatic shocks of the industrial era, trained for the middle-management careers that awaited them after graduation. Middle-class periodicals embodied this shift. In the 1890s, magazines stressed pluck and self-reliance, but by the early 1900s they promoted the new scientific curriculum and touted college's benefits for developing the kind of character needed in business. Business colleges even ran advertisements that made their courses appear more traditionally collegiate in nature. College, in other words, had gained a perceived practical value among the reading public.
As Clark perceptively notes, it was not enough to reform the curriculum; rather, “the entire image of the college experience required transformation into a fitting manly preparation” (81). Periodicals, steeped in social Darwinist fears of over-civilization, portrayed middle-class college students as both athletes and fraternity boys. The modern college man had to be a rugged individualist as well as a gentlemanly team player who could contribute to corporations. Magazines romanticized college life and portrayed universities as “hallowed,” “prestigious,” or “idyllic” places (95–96). Nevertheless, to maintain the Victorian fiction that true men were self-made, early-1900s magazines delighted in stories that portrayed young men working their way through college. This new kind of Horatio Alger, of course, needed to be a consumer and dress the right way. In the book's only illustrated chapter, Clark astutely shows how around 1905 advertisers—especially manufacturers of ready-made menswear like “Harvard Clothes” (166)—used collegiate imagery (including athletics and campus hijinks) to sell their wares to readers who were becoming convinced that higher education was useful for modern business success.
Creating the College Man casts a fresh light on Progressive Era higher education and manliness, but it makes claims that are too expansive for its somewhat limited source base. Clark explains that he read, from “cover to cover,” decades’ worth of four periodicals: the monthlies Munsey's and Cosmopolitan (1893–1912) and weeklies Saturday Evening Post and Collier's (1899–1915). This close reading of four important periodicals provides a valuable look at changing middle-class mentalities. However, it cannot support Clark's implication that such periodicals were the primary force in creating the manly, collegiate ideal. The author asserts that “magazines did not reflect a changing reality in the image of college portrayed on their pages; they actively created this ideal out of a response to the sense of crisis perceived among their male readers” (18). Can analysis of a particular group of sources support the conclusion that they created the changes seen unfolding within their pages? Magazines were certainly contributing to this historical shift in middle-class manliness and education, but analysis of a wider range of sources is necessary to gauge the influence of middle-class periodicals.
This book is also somewhat narrow in its scope more generally. For example, readers would benefit from a brief survey of the diverse types of nineteenth-century higher education, especially antebellum manual labor colleges and post-Civil War land-grant universities. Were all pre-1890 colleges really training young men in the useless arts, or did late-1800s middle-class readers just think this was the case? Second, the book focuses on what we might call business manliness at the expense of a manliness of public service. Did municipal and state-level reformers welcome the same attributes as businessmen, or did they seek a different kind of college man? Perhaps the four periodicals examined did not address this issue, but critical readers will no doubt wonder if other sources would have yielded broader conclusions about important issues in Progressive Era history.
Ultimately, Creating the College Man provides a rich, nuanced cultural analysis of middle-class periodicals’ portrayal of college manliness from the 1890s to the 1910s. It even makes a persuasive case that these magazines at least helped convince Progressive Era Americans that higher education was a worthwhile investment. Although Clark occasionally gets bogged down in lists of rhetorical questions or detailed readings of his primary sources, this book is nevertheless written in a clear and accessible style that scholars, including graduate students, will find appealing. Progressive Era historians, though, will want to consult a wider range of sources in order to understand why college education became essential preparation for middle-class American men at the turn of the century.
