In “Not Altogether Human”: Pantheism and the Dark Nature of the American Renaissance, Richard Hardack explores the historical relationship between transcendentalism and pantheism by revealing a locus of cultural anxiety particularly with regard to race and gender. Offering close readings from canonical texts as well as from archival materials, Hardack argues that nineteenth-century constructions of pantheism coded all nonwhite nonmale bodies as “nature” or “other” (62). That is, the transcendentalists' notion that anyone could be educated, that anyone could be divinely inspired, and that all human beings had limitless potential became distinctly problematic when the white Christian male had to put his philosophy into practice and consider women and people of color as being an integral (rather than an incidental) part of the universality of all things. This is especially problematic for the white male for whom becoming one with nature has the effect that he must merge with entities also coded as cultural pollutants – for instance, the reified bodies of women, Native Americans, and slaves. As such, pantheism and the concept of “natural transformation” become “transcendental tropes” with “political and social consequences,” with the result that for many nineteenth-century proponents of transcendentalism “U.S. democracy is built on tropes that both universalize and tyrannize” (117). For the pantheist, then, merging with the “other” could be liberating, but it was also terrifying. Anxiety over this merging is inevitably reflected in Emerson's writings – and also in the works of those influenced by transcendentalism – as discourses of dismemberment and fragmentation. Upon addressing these anxieties, Hardack's wry humor is revealed as a parenthetical aside when, in discussing dismemberment in Melville's Pierre, he writes that “Pierre could be subtitled ‘A Farewell to Arms’ instead of ‘The Ambiguities’” (173).
By his own admission, Hardack's style of argumentation is unusual, requiring “a slightly different way of reading, as it develops, by necessity and design, several arguments that are accretive or cumulative rather than exclusively linear” (9). For instance, in chapter 2, Hardack links “parthenogenesis and primitivism, taxonomic universality, the animation of black nature, and the animation of inanimate matter,” all of which are “governed by a rhetoric which assumes that god is a universal, impersonal form of natural law” (62). While some may find Hardack's “accretive” approach distracting, he undoubtedly presents readers with “relatively unaddressed syntactical evidence that indicates that Melville was responding to transcendental theories generally and Emerson's work directly” (11). As such, a key component of the book's central argument is this: “Far from being hostile or indifferent to Emersonian idealism – as many critics … have contended – Melville was strongly influenced by a pantheism that he increasingly longed to refute, especially in his later years” (11). This assertion is followed by an intriguing counter to existing scholarship in the field:
Emerson should not be read as a prophet of self-reliance or Christian virtue, as he is commonly conceived … Emerson emerges here as an exemplar of self-negation, a man for whom all individuality and particularity are illusory and whose male individuality must be transcended and merged into the All of a non-Christian nature. (13)
Not only does Hardack illuminate the anxiety undergirding transcendentalism, the fear of a loss of individuality and the fear of a destabilized national identity, but he also raises questions as to how transcendentalism has been understood and interpreted as a philosophy, a spiritual practice, and a social movement. This interrogation of common interpretations is both compelling and persuasive.
Hardack is well published in this area and scholars of intellectual history as well as literary theorists will be especially well served by Not Altogether Human in that Hardack provides fresh perspectives on nineteenth-century transcendentalism and pantheism and provides meticulous readings of Emerson, Melville, and Hawthorne. Newcomers to Hardack's work will find that they are in good hands as he expertly navigates a complex literary landscape.
