While scholarly discourse on identity in ancient Greece has centred around the relative importance of ethnicity versus culture (e.g. J. Hall, Hellenicity: Between Ethnicity and Culture (2002)), the equivalent debate for the Roman world has focused on identity as a cultural and political concept. The diminution or lack of an ethnic dimension, real or fictive, to Roman identity meant that citizenship could be acquired far more easily by those for whom it was not a birthright than was generally possible in the Greek poleis.
Archaeologists have very reasonably linked the acquisition of Roman identity with imperialism. Thus, it is recognized that as the empire spread, conquered peoples gained access to Roman artefacts and, for whatever reasons, assumed Roman cultural practices. Successful individuals in the provinces might acquire not only citizenship but also access to networks of power on an empire-wide scale. The process by which conquered peoples acquired Roman lifestyles and civic rights has traditionally been discussed in terms of Romanization, a term that is now so heavily problematized that it almost cannot be understood without inverted commas (v. for example, the papers in S. J. Keay and N. Terrenato (eds), Italy and the West: Comparative Issues in Romanization (2001)).
Revell's book takes a consciously different stance. It is not a book about ‘becoming Roman’, to use Greg Woolf's term (from the title of his 1998 book), but rather about being Roman. Thus, the principal issue under consideration is not how or why conquered peoples adopted a Roman identity, but rather how such an identity was experienced in the provinces. Consequently, instead of focusing on the conquest period and its immediate aftermath, R. concentrates on a period when Roman rule was established, unthreatened, and normative. That said, the experience of being Roman is not conceived as homogeneous. There is variability between and within provinces, between town and country, and between different individuals and social groups. Crucial vectors of variance at the individual level include civic and social status, age, and gender. R. argues that difference has been downplayed in much of the established scholarship because, on the one hand, of an over-emphasis on a perceived Roman versus native dichotomy and, on the other, a tendency to regard the experience of the dominant class of male citizens as definitive.
R. confines herself to the second century a.d., when Roman power was well-established in each of her study regions: the provinces in Britain and Iberia. Her methodology is to examine a small sample of broadly contemporary sites and to use structuration theory to explain how identity was experienced and shaped by living with and surrounded by a built environment and material culture of Roman type. As not every aspect of life in the provinces could possibly be examined in a single volume, R. concentrates on four key aspects: how identity was shaped by provincial architectural forms and epigraphic traditions; how the personality and role of the emperor was understood in different provinces; how approaches to religious practice and belief differed between provinces and sites; and how the individual's understanding of being Roman varied not only by province but also according to social status.
It is possible to criticize R.'s methodology because of either the very restricted sample size or the limited number of vectors that are chosen as a means to explore the divergent experiences of those living in the provinces in the second century a.d. However, to do so is rather to miss the point. R.'s intention is not to document the lives of Romans in the provinces in a fully comprehensive manner but rather to draw attention to the diversity of experience that is obscured by the notion of a common Roman identity. This is perhaps most effectively achieved in her fifth chapter in which she sketches how individuals, both real and hypothetical, encountered and responded to the architecture and inscriptions of Italica, a city in the province of Baetica. Her chosen individuals and archetypes include: an élite adult man; an adult woman from an élite family; a wealthy, freed, male slave; an ordinary male citizen; an ordinary woman; children of both sexes; and slaves of various types.
This book is a revised version of R.'s PhD thesis. At times its origins are only too apparent. It displays the obsession with definitions and the careful presentation of every stage of an argument that is demanded of a doctoral dissertation. While occasionally this approach can grate on the reader, such methodical rigour has its benefits, especially when dealing with a concept as slippery as identity.
This volume makes an important contribution to the study of Roman provincial identity. It does not negate or supplant the value of studies of, for want of a better term, Romanization, but complements them by demonstrating the ongoing complexity, diversity, and flexibility that the term Roman masks.
