Irfan Ahmad's book is a valuable addition to the growing body of literature on Islamism. Providing an in-depth look at Jamaʿat-e-Islami (JI) in India, Ahmad argues for viewing Islamism as a movement. Although others (Asef Bayat, Making Islam Democratic: Social Movements and the Post-Islamist Turn [Stanford, Calif.: Stanford University Press, 2007]; Kathleen Collins, “Ideas, Networks and Islamist Movements: Evidence from Central Asia and the Caucus,” World Politics 60 [2007], 64–96; Joel Beinin, “Islam, Marxism, and the Shubra al-Khayma Textile Workers: Muslim Brothers and Communists in the Egyptian Trade Union Movement,” in Edmund Burke and Ira Lapidus, eds., Islam, Politics and Social Movements [London: I. B. Tauris, 1988]; and Joel Beinin and Joe Stork, Political Islam: Essays from Middle East Report [Berkeley, Calif.: University of California Press, 1997]) have previously made this argument, Ahmad adds substance and depth to the discussion by providing rich ethnographic material. Ahmad's research is structured around the question of change within JI in India: whether and how JI's ideology changed since the partition of India and the departure of Abu ʿAla Maududi, the movement's founder, to Pakistan. Ahmad finds that JI has moved not only toward accepting democracy and secular political arrangements it had previously denounced but also toward valorizing them. The reasons for this shift are external as well as internal to the movement. Externally, the larger Muslim polity in India rejected JI's insistence on boycotting elections, and the Nehruvian Indian state provided enough space through “inclusionary” politics to allow some Muslims, if not all of them, to believe in the promise of democracy and secularism. Internally, change was aided by “the ability of the Jamaʿat's leadership to transform its ideology in the midst of complex socio-political and religious forces” (pp. 226–27). It is one of the key strengths of this book that Ahmad is able to provide us a glimpse of the kinds of debates that have been central to life within JI.
Even as the larger JI movement was moving toward a more genial relationship with democracy and secularism in the 1990s, a student offshoot, the Student Islamic Movement of India (SIMI), was moving toward radicalization. As Ahmad skilfully demonstrates, SIMI's radicalization was a response to the rising tide of Hindutva: the political movement that seeks to move beyond the everyday normalization of Hindu experience to a more aggressive assertion of Hinduism in the public sphere. Although a more detailed explanation of SIMI's radicalization is not carried out in this book, Ahmad suggests that the students’ age, their relatively higher economic status and consequent sense of entitlement, and their independence from JI may explain why the group adopted the language of jihad and militancy when JI disavowed such moves.
The bulk of the book and of Ahmad's ethnographic interaction revolves around student activists of SIMI and of a more moderate JI affiliate, the Student Islamic Organization of India (SIO). The emphasis on students in Ahmad's book is fitting because JI's ideology emphasized education's central role in preparing the vanguard party that Maududi imagined JI would become. Maududi had structured JI as a Leninist cadre-based party composed of educated and professional Muslims. Ahmad follows the trail of JI's student organizations in Aligarh Muslim University (AMU, a key center of modern Indian Muslim education), JI's school Jamiʿatul-Falah in Azamgarh, and another school in Rampur designed to serve as a model educational institution. He contends that although Maududi had, prior to Indian independence, condemned AMU in particular as being a “slaughterhouse” for inculcating secular values among Indian Muslims, the larger Muslim population around JI forced the Islamist party to seek and support AMU's minority status. Such support for the university's minority status, Ahmad implies, was tantamount to a recognition and valorization of AMU rather than the rejection that Maududi propagated. In chapters 3, 4, 5, and 6 Ahmad builds upon the details of his ethnographic interaction across the three sites by offering a sense of the contending trends within JI, whether in terms of: internal debates over greater teacher professionalization versus stricter religious observance (of the Islamist kind) for a Jamaʿat-affiliated school in Aligarh's poorer neighborhood, different points of view in regard to the role of the SIO at Aligarh University, or the open conflict between the SIO and the SIMI in Jamiʿatul-Falah. In all of these cases we see a pattern of increasing dilution of earlier stances.
The shift from JI declaring modern Muslim educational institutions to be slaughterhouses to actually endorsing and supporting them is central to Ahmad's argument and is repeatedly mentioned throughout the book. It is a useful point of departure from which to assess the ideological distance covered by JI. However, in his discussion of this shift Ahmad seems to ignore a central contradiction between Maududi's declarations at a particular point in history and his actual organizational strategies. Syed Vali Reza Nasr's authoritative body of work on JI's early years in Pakistan shows quite clearly how quickly JI, under Maududi, moved to organize within the country's professional colleges and modern universities. JI did not have its own madrasas in Pakistan until a decade ago, and Maududi's vision of a vanguard party was predicated on the membership of professional and pious Muslims who would be able to take over the state relatively quickly. Why and how JI in India has continued to resist these and other changes, which JI in Pakistan adopted much earlier, remains an important but unanswered question in Ahmad's analysis. For instance, why did JI in India resist electoral engagement when JI in Pakistan began engaging in electoral politics from the 1950s onward and actually supported the candidacy of a woman for president in the 1960s? These questions need to be adequately addressed for Ahmad's central thesis to be completely convincing.
Literature on social-movement theory has alerted us to the fact that the disjuncture between what leaders claim at one point and what they practice at another is compounded by the dissonance between the utopias leaders imagine and those their constituencies move toward. The answer to the question of why there were differences between Maududi's initial stances and JI's later development lies with the dynamics of Muslim citizenship in postcolonial India as well as the leadership of JI in India. Ahmad is right to contrast secular, democratic India with the largely undemocratic Middle Eastern countries in order to claim that secular democracy acted as the catalyst for democratization and secularization within the Islamist movement. However, it would have been useful to build directly into this argument the important distinguishing feature of Muslim life in India when compared to that in the Middle East: despite their large numbers, Muslims in India are ultimately a minority, and establishing “Allah's Kingdom” is a more uphill task in such a state than elsewhere. The interesting question in this context is not just how and why JI changed but why it remained wedded to the ideas that Maududi himself modified during the postindependence decades in Pakistan—the very decades in which JI India's leadership fought a losing battle against change.
In this context, a clearer picture of the differences and variations within the “Muslim masses” and of the socioeconomic profile of the “Islamist class” would have helped the reader to understand the reasons for the “ideological dissonance” that Ahmad claims ultimately led to the transformation of JI India. Some of these issues are taken up in Chapter 7, but they feel somewhat misplaced at the end of the book. Readers may have benefitted from Ahmad's situating this chapter earlier in the book, perhaps right after Chapter 2, in which the rise of Islamism is contextualized through a look at intellectual influences on Maududi.
The criticisms raised here, however, do not detract from the main strength of the book—the detailed ethnography that allows the reader to gain a palpable sense of the debates and contention within an important Islamist movement in a crucial center of innovation in contemporary Muslim thought and practice: India.
