Katherine Smith sets out the aim of her book as ‘to weave together normative (political) and rational (evidence-focused) approaches to thinking about the relationship between evidence and policy in public health by focusing on two contrasting case studies: health inequalities and tobacco control’ (p. 4). Through detailed analysis based on a large number of interviews and documents, she finds that, in the case of health inequalities policy in the United Kingdom (UK), there is relatively little sign of evidence making much impact on decision making. By contrast, in the case of tobacco control, she shows that evidence has had a considerable impact on policy with advocates able to employ evidence accurately and persuasively. Drawing on both of her case studies, she goes on to argue that it makes more sense empirically to focus on the influence of ideas rather than of evidence per se when trying to see how evidence is or is not used for policy (and, indeed, how its use might be increased or improved). In other words, it is not so much the findings of research that policy makers are seeking to use, and which have the potential to have influence, but the ideas derived from the research. Smith also shows how evidence may make certain ideas more persuasive in some settings, so evidence is not to be discounted in use, but that the persuasiveness of ideas is by no means automatically related to the quality and volume of the evidence that supports them. Instead, ideas have the advantage of a greater ability than research findings to move between actors in a policy community and thereby gathering influence.
In looking at how ideas have their impact within her two case studies, the author shows the significance of the wide range of participants and the links between them in each area of policy (e.g. advocacy organisations, think tanks, researchers, journalists, health professionals, civil servants, politicians and their advisers, knowledge brokers, etc.), and how these are involved in the transmission and transformation of ideas. The two case studies strongly hint at the possibility that evidence (largely in the form of the ideas it generates) is likely to have more impact on policy ‘where there are strong links between research, advocacy and policy communities and where researchers work with others to (i) develop charismatic ideas (within persuasive ‘policy frames’) and (ii) monitor and actively try to counter the effects of actors seeking to influence policies in alternative ways (e.g. corporations involved in marketing health-damaging products or think thanks promoting free-market policies and minimal state intervention)’ (p. 5).
Smith identifies four types of ideas each with a different capacity for influence. ‘Institutionalised’ ideas are those that have become taken-for-granted in a field and have thus become part of its policies, processes and practices to the extent of representing a barrier to change. ‘Critical’ ideas are those that challenge the status quo, but do not explain how change can be brought about. ‘Charismatic’ ideas, by contrast, are persuasive because they offer creative alternatives to (perceived inadequate) institutionalised ideas and related policies, though, as a result, they may elicit both strong support and strong opposition. She shows how tobacco policy researchers were able to develop ideas with charismatic properties which have enabled substantial policy change in the UK, whereas most of the ideas of health inequalities researchers remained simply ‘critical’, struggling to articulate a viable set of policies and a coherent vision of a society that would substantially reduce health inequalities.
To this trio, the author adds a fascinating fourth type of idea – the ‘chameleonic’ idea. ‘The key characteristics of chameleonic ideas, and what adds to their ability to travel between actors and across boundaries, are elasticity and transformability’ (p. 192). These are ideas that allow for multiple meanings. As a result, they are far less likely than critical ideas to be blocked by institutionalised ideas. However, their influence on policy is more unpredictable and the very features that enable them to survive criticism (e.g. ambiguity enabling divergent interest groups to support them) may also limit their eventual impact. In the case study of UK policy on health inequalities, chameleonic ideas tended to be advanced by policy ‘mediators’ or ‘entrepreneurs’ working in the field rather than the original researchers. Smith gives the example of individuals at the interface between research and policy emphasising the psychosocial over the material-structural determinants of health inequalities so that they could provide evidence-informed policy advice that would be perceived as less challenging to existing policy approaches.
Smith concludes that her focus on ‘ideas’ rather than ‘evidence’ (as facts and findings) may provide a way of resolving the tension in debates and practice concerning evidence and policy between, on the one hand, the rational, instrumental school, still very much alive in public health, and, on the other, the political, democratic, ideological, values-based perspective more readily grasped by those from a political science or sociological background. She sees the notion of ‘research-informed ideas’ (p. 213) as allowing fuller acknowledgement of the fact that public health policy debates and their results are shaped by normative, political and empirical considerations. In turn, she argues, optimistically, that this ‘may open up the opportunity for more radical and imaginative dialogue’ and ‘make more meaningful choices possible’ (p. 219).
This is a rich and sophisticated analysis of the overlapping worlds of evidence creation, evidence mediation and policy making. Seemingly effortlessly, the two fine-grained case studies in all their singularity are related to other cases and contexts, and to the previous empirical and conceptual literature. There is no doubt that this book contributes immensely to improving understanding of the nature of the contribution of evidence in public health policy in the UK in the early twenty-first century and, because of its theoretical contribution, more widely.
To be more critical, however, the notion that ideas are central to public policy (and to the contribution of evidence) is scarcely new to policy scientists. For example, a leading British textbook describes the policy process in terms of ‘the interplay between institutions, interests and ideas’ (John, Reference John1998). The partial novelty lies in demonstrating the important role of ideas in public health, a field that tends to cleave to a more empiricist view of the contribution of evidence.
It is also worth considering the impact on the analysis of the choice of two such different case studies ‒ health inequalities and tobacco control. The evidence on a reduction in health inequalities suggests that this would require fundamental change to the nature of society and the economy of a kind entirely absent from the current political agenda. By contrast, the tobacco industry has few friends and tobacco control, particularly related to children's smoking, is supported across a wide ideological spectrum. It is scarcely surprising that the journey of evidence from research to policy is very different in each of these two fields.
Finally, were the book's conclusions to become widely known and accepted beyond academia, it is fascinating (if a little unfair, perhaps) to speculate on the consequences for the status and funding of public health research. Smith argues that her analysis in no way implies that research is an unnecessary activity. However, it is open to doubt whether research funders and policy agencies would necessarily agree so readily confronted by her analysis. They may conclude that, if the contribution of research evidence to policy is ultimately through the derivative medium of ideas rather than ‘hard facts’, the expensive apparatus of primary empirical research could be safely much reduced or eliminated altogether in the rapid quest for new ideas, to be replaced by journalism, punditry, desk-based analysis and various forms of public and expert deliberation. While researchers would argue that research, scholarship and critical thinking are vital for the generation of robust ideas, it has to be recognised that one possible consequence of the insight that the influence of research is largely through the realm of ideas might be to regard research and researchers as having no greater claim to truth telling and thus no greater right to be heard than any other group in society.
