It is especially painful to me, and it puts me in a very unfair position, that I should have to give judgment in these matters on application for Confirmatory Faculties. From a very long experience myself during the War in France, the very last thing I would desire to do would be to deliver any judgment which might look [like], or be supposed in any way to be[,] a reflection on a Memorial that is put up to those who have fallen. I would desire (as I hope everybody else would) to do the greatest honour to those who gave their lives for their Country during the War. However, it is a deep mistake, I am certain, to put up as a Memorial to those who have fallen (Memorials which are and which should be intended to be Memorials for all time) some object which is to say the least of it ecclesiastically disputable.Footnote 1
So spoke Chancellor Ernest Charles, expressing his frustration during a hearing of the Diocese of Wakefield Consistory Court on 27 November 1920, at which he was considering a retrospective application for a faculty from the parish church of St John the Evangelist, Clifton, near Brighouse in the West Riding of Yorkshire.
This article explores issues raised by faculty applications for the creation of memorials commemorating the First World War, particularly those which were open to legal rather than aesthetic objections, focusing on material from the diocese of Wakefield during Charles's period in office. The creation of First World War memorials has been examined from a range of perspectives, from the aesthetic concerns of art and architectural historians to the socio-political motivations of the decision makers. Most attention has been concentrated on the main civic memorials rather than on the multiplicity of other memorials erected by individual communities within villages, towns and cities. Every English parish church had at least one such memorial, but the fact that each one, whether located in the church or the churchyard, required approval at diocesan level has not figured significantly in either national or local studies. Nor has there been any published research on the operation of diocesan chancellors’ faculty jurisdiction in the early twentieth century. Parish church memorials are of more than merely denominational interest, as many communities chose to locate their commemorations of all local citizens in the parish church or churchyard rather than in civic space.Footnote 2
A faculty is a legal document issued by a church authority permitting an action. Faculty jurisdiction in the Church of England is of pre-Reformation origin and has as its basis the care and protection of ecclesiastical property. In the mid-nineteenth century, campaigners concerned with the fate of the country's heritage became increasingly critical of the church's record in that respect. Between 1840 and 1875, around 80 per cent of ancient churches had been restored, rebuilt or enlarged. In 1877, disquiet over the restoration of Tewkesbury Abbey prompted the formation of the Society for the Protection of Ancient Buildings. In 1912, a select committee of both houses of parliament recommended an erosion of the jurisdiction of consistory courts, the bodies through which chancellors, the legal officers of dioceses, granted faculties as part of their wider responsibilities. The Church of England resisted these moves successfully and obtained a statutory exemption from state control over its buildings in the Ancient Monuments Consolidation and Amendment Act of 1913, but only after promises that existing faculty procedures would be reviewed. In 1914, Sir Lewis Dibdin, then dean of the Court of Arches (the highest judicial post in the Church of England), presented a report which recommended a general tightening of procedures, as well as the setting up of specialist bodies to advise diocesan chancellors on architectural, archaeological, historical and artistic matters. However, diocesan advisory committees, as they came to be called, did not become a requirement until 1938, and had no decision-making powers of their own.Footnote 3
The timing of the Dibdin report meant that implementation of its recommendations was not the first priority for dioceses struggling to cope with the more urgent problems of wartime. It was early 1921 before the diocese of Wakefield established what was initially called the Ancient Churches Advisory Committee.Footnote 4 The diocese included a relatively small number of pre-Reformation churches, and the new framework was regarded as focusing on those, as the committee's name indicated.
The main concern of most dioceses during the war had been the prospect of a plethora of memorials to individual casualties being placed in churches by their families. They did not, however, wish to discourage wealthy parishioners from funding major embellishments to churches, such as new stained glass windows. Public advice was carefully worded. In January 1916, the Wakefield Diocesan Gazette urged the clergy to put notices in parish magazines and in the local press assuring readers that ‘general and comprehensive memorial[s]’ would be created, although memorials to individuals would not be ruled out. Such an initiative, the Gazette suggested, would pre-empt the distress which would occur if the desire for individual brasses and tablets overwhelmed church buildings, as it could well do in town churches. It would also be much valued by those who could not afford ‘costly offerings’ but could participate in a communal venture.Footnote 5 In May 1916, it was considered necessary to reiterate that advice, and to state that Wakefield's chancellor supported it:
A collective memorial gives a Parish the opportunity of recording its admiration for the services of a man or men, whose parents and friends are probably not in a position from a monetary point of view to erect an individual memorial. It also has a distinct value as associating together in the fellowship of sacrifice names of brave men from every rank and condition of life.Footnote 6
The same article also emphasized that plans for memorials should await the end of the war. That these exhortations were published even before the traumatic events on the Somme that July demonstrates that commemorative pressures were already building up. The Gazette is silent about what, if any, discussions took place in Wakefield during the remainder of the war, but by June 1919, the archbishop of York, Cosmo Gordon Lang, was describing the hope that communal memorials would prevail over individual ones as ‘very imperfectly fulfilled’. ‘Of course, it is very difficult to discipline individual feelings,’ he was quoted as saying, ‘but I deprecate in the interests of a truer ideal separating individuals from their comrades, when there is to be in the church some adequate and dignified memorial on which the names of all who have fallen are to be inscribed.’Footnote 7
The May 1916 edition of the Gazette had also recorded the case of an unnamed church whose application for a faculty had been refused as premature, unsuitable, likely to mislead historically and possibly leading to overcrowded or half-filled tablets. It seems that the church concerned was seeking to commemorate not only those who were losing their lives in the war but also all those who had volunteered to serve. It may be that the latter part of the application had sought to distinguish between those who had joined the armed forces as volunteers and those who, after the introduction of conscription, might be regarded as less worthy of honour. That would explain why the Gazette stated that ‘[a] permanent record of men offering their services for military work … was felt to be most unsuitable on every ground.’Footnote 8 The comment may, however, have reflected a more fundamental worry about commemorating living servicemen and ex-servicemen. In 1921, the chancellor of the diocese of Liverpool was reported as having rejected an application for a faculty for a memorial which included the names of those who had served and returned, as well as those of the dead, because a man named on a similar memorial had gone on to commit a serious offence but still appeared as one whose name should be remembered for ever.Footnote 9
By the spring and summer of 1919, most servicemen had returned home and the numbers of applications for faculties began to rise. The Wakefield diocesan faculty books show the numbers of faculties granted (see Table 1).Footnote 10 The peak in 1920 is certainly attributable to war memorial applications but other factors contributed to the overall rising numbers. Many fairly routine alterations to church buildings had been put off during the war because of more urgent pressures on time, money and materials; discussion of possible war memorial projects often triggered suggestions for other alterations which could conveniently be completed at the same time; and the higher profile of the faculty procedures following the Dibdin report probably meant that formal approval was now being sought for decisions which might in the past have been taken locally.
Numbers of Faculty Applications granted, Diocese of Wakefield, 1913–29

Source: WYAS(W), WD100/109, Diocese of Wakefield, Faculty Books, vols 2 (1908–22), 3 (1922–30).
With that background, let us return to what was upsetting Chancellor Charles on that November day in 1920. Ernest Bruce Charles was a forty-nine-year-old barrister and recorder, who had been appointed as chancellor to the diocese of Wakefield in 1912. He was also chancellor of the diocese of Hereford, again from 1912, and would add the chancellorship of the diocese of Chelmsford in 1922. This pluralistic activity was (and is) not unusual. English ecclesiastical law was (and remains) a distinctly niche area of interest and expertise, and diocesan chancellorships were (and are) not lucrative posts. Charles's father had been dean of the Court of Arches, and his son ended his career as chancellor (commissary general) of the diocese of Canterbury. Ernest Charles lived in Kent, and the wide geographic spread of his chancellorships in the 1920s reflected the fact that, provided a diocese had a competent and industrious diocesan registrar, most business could be conducted without the need for particularly frequent visits.Footnote 11 He resigned his three chancellorships in 1928, on appointment as a High Court judge. His mention of wartime experience in France, in the quotation which began this article, referred to his service with the Red Cross, initially as an ambulance driver, later as part of the inquiry teams who tried to trace those missing in action, and culminating in appointment as director of the Wounded and Missing Inquiry Department, Le Havre.Footnote 12
The ‘ecclesiastically disputable’ war memorial installed in St John's, Clifton, was a faldstool surrounded by a triptych, with a crucifix in the central panel and, on the two wings, the names of those who had died in the war. The evidence available does not suggest that the church was trying to evade faculty jurisdiction but that it was rather late in making its application, assuming that approval would be granted before the work was completed.Footnote 13 However, that was not the case, and the memorial was in place by the time the chancellor came to make his decision. Normally, that would have led to nothing worse than a formal rebuke, before the grant of a confirmatory faculty. However, this case proved an exception. The chancellor had no hesitation in declaring that the element of the triptych depicting the crucifix was illegal. Here he was on familiar ground, having considered the legality of crucifixes ten months previously in the diocese of Hereford, in relation to a war memorial for the parish of Tenbury, Worcestershire. Citing the case of Ridsdale v. Clifton (1877), he had concluded in Hereford that a crucifix without associated figures turning it into a depiction of a historical event was illegal in itself, whether or not there was evidence that the image would be put to a superstitious use. His judgment on that occasion had been reported in The Times.Footnote 14 In Wakefield, he reiterated the main points of his previous judgment as the basis for his decision on Clifton's application. However, he went on to say that the memorial should remain and should be respected, although if anyone made a formal application for its removal he might have to grant such a request. He urged the parish to consider altering the central element of the triptych to make it a historical depiction, in which case he would gladly make a retrospective grant of approval. This they did. It is clear that in the months between the two judgments he had become much more conscious of the emotional context of his decisions, or at least more prepared to articulate that pressure. He may also have been aware that there was another application in the diocesan pipeline, which would bring the state of the law concerning depictions of the crucifixion into even sharper relief.
Towards the end of 1920, the parish of St Thomas in Huddersfield requested approval for a rood beam across the chancel arch with a crucifix and figures of the Virgin Mary and St John, commemorating an individual casualty, and a column in the churchyard bearing a lantern head containing a Calvary, as a general memorial. That application was approved a few weeks after the Clifton judgment, following a meeting in Wakefield with representatives of the parish.Footnote 15 Nevertheless, the church council of St Thomas was not at all happy. When presented with the bill for the faculty process, it agreed to send a formal resolution to the diocese stating that ‘the parochial council regard the whole thing as unnecessary, and a severe tax on the amount subscribed towards the object for which the faculty was obtained’. The council also discussed withholding the architect's fees, feeling that he should have ensured that the application was regarded as routine, not perhaps realizing that his knowledge of the state of the law concerning crucifixion scenes with attendant figures as opposed to a sole crucifix had almost certainly been the reason for the positive outcome.Footnote 16
To the average churchgoer, and indeed to many clergy, the result – that a relatively small image of the crucified Redeemer in front of a prayer desk was illegal, yet an enormous rood beam dominating the interior of the church in pre-Reformation style was legal, as was an outdoor Calvary similar to those found across Catholic Europe – was very difficult to comprehend. There was nothing amiss with Chancellor Charles's understanding of the law. Volume 11 of the first edition of Halsbury's Laws of England, which he had no doubt consulted, tracked the less than consistent state of the case law, and advised that crucifixes had normally been held to be illegal, regardless of context, whereas depictions of the crucifixion with associated figures had to pass the test of whether or not they were likely to be put to superstitious use.Footnote 17 Why an image of Christ on the cross by itself was not considered a depiction of a historical event, whilst adding figures of the Virgin and St John made it into one, was not, to say the least, self-evident. The case law on which all this rested came from the court cases during the height of the nineteenth-century ritualistic controversies. Those Victorian judges who had established the case law were also in a very difficult position. The basis from which they had to start was the Book of Common Prayer of 1662. Like its predecessors, that book was annexed to an act of uniformity, which gave it its statutory authority. A rubric at the beginning of the Orders for Morning and Evening Prayer decreed that the ornaments of the church and of the ministers should be those which were legal in the second year of the reign of Edward VI, repeating the substance of the corresponding Ornaments Rubric in the Prayer Book of 1559. Although usually taken to be a reference to the status quo implemented by the Prayer Book of 1549, the requirement to use that first statutory book did not come into force until a few months into the third year of Edward's reign.Footnote 18 The resulting ambiguity, perhaps deliberately retained in 1662 to avoid reopening one of the more contentious issues of the previous century, was never formally resolved.Footnote 19 A further complication was that the various documents published during the reigns of Henry VIII, Edward VI and Elizabeth I were written to be interpreted by clerics grounded in the theology of the Reformation era. By the nineteenth century, interpretation was being undertaken by lawyers whose intellectual training had been quite different, and who were required to base their judgments on the words in front of them with very limited regard to the intentions of those who wrote them, even if these intentions could be accurately known or understood.Footnote 20 Most of the Victorian cases were also primarily about the contentious actions of individual clergy during the church's official worship, with questions of church ornaments and decorations being subsidiary matters, some of which could be related to the Ornaments Rubric and others not. It is no wonder that by the time an uneasy truce settled over the Church of England later in the nineteenth century the state of the case law was less than coherent.Footnote 21
The cases of St John, Clifton and St Thomas, Huddersfield were not the end of Chancellor Charles's difficulties. In 1924, he was faced with a fait accompli in Huddersfield's main parish church, where the incumbent had radically reordered the sanctuary to introduce a new freestanding altar with a baldachino and a new east window, displacing in the process various existing memorials, including that of the family of the church's patron. Aspects of the design of the altar and its canopy as finally installed were potentially illegal, and so out of proportion to the chancel as a whole as to be aesthetically questionable too. The parochial church council had not resolved to apply for a faculty until the beginning of October 1923, and the actual application was only made on 15 November, just two days before the dedication ceremony. The formal application represented the whole scheme as a war memorial, although the vicar had made clear his dissatisfaction with the appearance of St Peter's within months of his induction, when discussion of any permanent war memorial was over a year away. The application was vague about the nature of the structure over the new altar, and did not mention the consequential relocation of existing memorials. As the incumbent was rural dean and a canon of Wakefield and former canon of York, and his architect, Ninian Comper, worked almost exclusively on ecclesiastical projects and was noted for his contempt for official process, it is difficult not to conclude that the delay in requesting a faculty was deliberate. Moreover, the incumbent, Albert Darell Tupper-Carey (1866–1943), was also a personal friend of the archbishop of York, and was shortly to resign the living on medical advice. A faculty was granted, without the Gazette making public the fact that the approval was retrospective, and follow-up action concentrated on the unauthorized relocation of the memorials of prominent families. Ironically, the faculty application contained one element which was correctly timed, as the formal decision to commission a stone tablet inscribed with the names of the dead was not taken until the month after the ceremony at which the window and the new altar were dedicated.Footnote 22
Charles was not the only diocesan chancellor to be facing problems. In August 1918, Chancellor the Ven. John Prescott at the Carlisle Consistory Court had considered an application for approval of a new east window at St Paul, Carlisle, in memory of all those who had died in the war from the church and the parish. The design was for a five-light window, with a central panel depicting Christ on the cross. Both the position of the window, in the general view of the congregation at all times, and the nature of the figure, which the chancellor described as ‘practically a crucifix’, concerned him so much that he reserved judgment. By the time of the next court, changes had been made to the design, which now contained the figures of the Virgin and St John and also extended the arms of Christ into the adjacent lights so as to link all aspects of the crucifixion scene together. However, the chancellor was not persuaded that those alterations met his original objections, nor did he accept arguments that the window was a painted depiction of the crucifixion scene and not a crucifix, that it would enhance the appearance of the church and that it was a very suitable memorial to the war. He refused the application.Footnote 23
In June 1920, in the diocese of Winchester, Chancellor the Rt Hon. George Talbot considered a case involving a crucifix erected in the consecrated grounds of St Nicholas, Guildford, in memory of an individual casualty. The crucifix had already been dedicated by the bishop of Guildford, on the understanding that a confirmatory faculty would be sought for it. Nevertheless the faculty had been refused, solely on the grounds of its retrospective character. A new application was then made to have the crucifix removed, and a counter-proposal submitted to move it to a disused burial ground adjacent to the church. Arguments were made concerning the illegality of a crucifix per se, and the likelihood of its being the focus of superstitious practices in either location. In his final judgment, permitting the re-erection of the crucifix in its new location, Talbot questioned the contention that a crucifix was always illegal in the Church of England, noting that the Inner Temple accounts showed that there had been one in the Temple Church in 1674. He also dealt robustly with the evidence presented in support of the crucifix's superstitious use: that men had been seen raising their hats as they passed; and men, women and children had been observed making the sign of the cross, bowing, genuflecting or even kneeling in front of it. If the crucifix reminded them of the redeeming passion of our Lord, he said, prompting them to express thankfulness or reverence by outward gestures or public prayer, it was both uncharitable and unreasonable to attribute superstition to them.Footnote 24
A year later in the Exeter diocese, dealing with a very similar case in which a war memorial crucifix had been erected and dedicated without a faculty in the churchyard of St Stephen, Devonport, and its removal requested on the grounds of superstitious actions having been observed by opponents watching responses to the memorial, Chancellor Sir Francis Newbolt came to a very different conclusion. He ruled that superstitious use was very likely and that the crucifix should be removed and replaced by what he called a ‘proper war memorial’.Footnote 25
By April 1921, Carlisle had a new chancellor, the Ven. Donald Campbell, whose views appeared rather different from those of his predecessor. It was proposed to erect a large crucifix in the churchyard of Christ Church, Carlisle. Crucifixes as war memorials in churchyards were causing a great deal of difficulty to chancellors, he said, and would continue to do so until there was a Court of Appeal ruling. In most dioceses they had been allowed and many erected, but elsewhere they had been judged illegal. He favoured the view of Lord Phillimore that ‘all images in stained glass, painting, or sculpture were lawful unless they were liable to be abused by superstitious devotion’, and did not think it possible that a crucifix in a churchyard could be liable to superstitious use.Footnote 26
No new ruling by a higher court on these issues ever materialized. The diversity of judgments by consistory courts arose because, as was the case for the secular courts, chancellors were only required to give respectful attention to the decisions of courts at the same level of seniority as their own. They were bound to follow the decisions of higher courts, unless it could be argued that the essence of the current case could be properly distinguished from the earlier one. The seventh edition of Cripps's Church and Clergy (1921) followed a summary of the nineteenth-century rulings on crucifixes with a discreet footnote indicating that unreported consistory court rulings on war memorials were affecting the state of the case law.Footnote 27 By 1933, the second edition of Halsbury's Laws of England was warning that ‘many, if not most, of the things pronounced unlawful by the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council have become of general usage’. One reason given for this was that, as stated in the Report of the Royal Commission on Ecclesiastical Discipline, ‘[a] Court dealing with matters of conscience and religion must, above all others, rest on moral authority if its judgments are to be effective. As thousands of clergy with strong lay support refuse to recognise the jurisdiction of the Judicial Committee, its judgments cannot be practically enforced.’Footnote 28 The second edition made no explicit mention of the impact of the commemoration of the war on the changed climate, perhaps feeling that referencing a royal commission placed the volume's stance on safer legal ground.
As the statistics in Table 1 indicate, these high-profile cases were occurring in the context of a much greater volume of work generally. Repeated reminders in the Gazette that clergy and churchwardens should not enter into contracts for work before receiving faculty approval of their plans indicated that compliance with the faculty procedures was a problem. Over and above the normal uneven implementation of any bureaucratic system, there were particular post-war pressures. Many parishes experienced a substantial change in personnel, as those who would have retired years before had it not been for the war left office and too many pre-war young leaders failed to return. There was also an understandable impatience with traditional decision-making, not only amongst returning servicemen but also amongst men and women who had taken on new responsibilities on the home front. Discussions about the best way to commemorate the war often took place outside formal structures, and were not always underpinned by the necessary official authorizations. To add to the potential for confusion, a major constitutional change took place in 1921, when the long-standing pattern of legal authority resting with the incumbent, the churchwardens and the vestry meetings was replaced by the creation of parochial church councils.Footnote 29 In places where voluntary church councils had been established for some years, that change could be almost seamless; in others, the new bodies struggled to understand and carry out their responsibilities; moreover, some clergy and churchwardens were more enthusiastic than others about the changes. The cost of obtaining a faculty was also an issue. Although the standard fee of two guineas (£2 2s) appears reasonable, when placed in the context of raising money for a simple wall tablet costing £25, resentment at what seemed like a diocesan tax on honouring the dead is understandable. A contested application could raise the diocesan costs charged to the parish to nearer £15, over and above the additional local expenses.Footnote 30
All these factors contributed to the likelihood that, from a parish perspective, faculty procedures would seem like routine red tape, to be complied with as and when someone remembered the need to do so. Consequently, applications for faculties were often made at a late stage of the creation of a memorial, after its completion or (indeed) not at all. Collation of newspaper reports, parish records and other sources relating to the creation of war memorials for just one borough in the diocese, Huddersfield, suggests that the numbers of faculties granted should have been significantly higher. One church in Huddersfield managed to erect, over a period of five years, a churchyard commemorative cross for the district as a whole, two tablets and a chancel screen for individual casualties, and a stained glass window with an associated tablet for the church's own group of casualties, as well as reordering part of the church to create a memorial chapel, all without even retrospective faculty approval.Footnote 31
Whether the Wakefield diocese found the time and resources to address aesthetic issues arising out of faculty applications for war memorials is not clear. The earliest extant minute book for the diocesan advisory committee dates from 1966, although earlier ones may exist amongst diocesan material not yet catalogued to individual item level. Editions of the Gazette to the end of the 1920s noted changes in the committee's membership and title but offered almost no information about its work. The one exception was in November 1924, when, as part of yet another reminder about the need to apply for a faculty before work was commissioned or begun, the Gazette stated that diocesan advisory committees ‘protect parishioners from unworthy alterations or additions to their churches. The question was nothing to do with the illegality or otherwise of the various proposals.’Footnote 32 Earlier that year, the Gazette had carried an article publicizing the advice of the Central Committee for the Protection of Churches that the temporary grave markers being returned to relatives from overseas should not be housed in churches. That conclusion was based on the danger of the ‘serious disfigurement of churches’ as the crosses were ‘usually very roughly made of thin, perishable wood for temporary use, and … quite unsuited for any position of permanency’. The committee had also concluded that ‘[i]n the majority of cases the names of those commemorated are already inscribed in the local War Memorial, very often in the church itself’.Footnote 33
Sir Lewis Dibdin could not have foreseen the environment in which his reforms to the system of faculty jurisdiction would unfold. He aimed for greater and more informed scrutiny of the impact of applications on the Church of England's heritage. Whether he achieved that is difficult to assess. At the level of particular dioceses, evidence for the operation of the faculty system is scattered amongst the records of individual parishes, unless diocesan registry files have survived and been catalogued. It would be particularly valuable to locate evidence concerning the extent to which aesthetic considerations influenced war memorial proposals for major pre-Reformation churches. It is also difficult to obtain a national overview of the decisions of consistory courts on applications for faculties involving war memorials which had potentially illegal constituents. Few of the latter cases found their way into the official law reports, so contemporary newspapers are the most accessible source of information.Footnote 34 It can, however, be concluded that this is an area where the strict application of case law was increasingly abandoned in the face of a very different climate of opinion from that in which it was first established. Whatever the personal churchmanship of individual chancellors, and the influence of that on their interpretation of the case law, they would also have been affected by the impact of the war on themselves, their families and friends, and the perspective that gave on the emotional context within the parishes applying for faculties. By the end of the First World War, the focus was no longer on errant clergy testing the bounds of the inclusivity of the Church of England but on individual grieving communities who, having come to corporate decisions about the form in which their dead should be remembered and their returned servicemen honoured, saw little reason why bureaucratic procedures and obscure Victorian court cases should conspire to thwart the implementation of those decisions.

