The beautifully presented Dragons and lotus blossoms catalogue was published to accompany an exhibition of Vietnamese ceramics at Alabama's Birmingham Museum of Art. The strength of this impressive collection, which covers almost two thousand years of ceramic production, lies in the creativity and beauty of several extraordinary pieces dating from the Ly and Tran dynasties, eleventh–fourteenth centuries CE. The broad range of Tran era glaze types and decorative styles are also well represented. During the fourteenth–sixteenth centuries large quantities of ceramics were exported from Vietnam to Southeast Asia and West Asia and the exhibits on pp. 166–209 indicate the diverse decorative styles of such tradewares.
The catalogue's superb colour photographs enable the reader to fully appreciate the quality of the glazes and expressive designs of the exhibited pieces that are presented on pp. 42–237. Additional Vietnamese ceramics from the Museum's collection, which did not form part of the exhibition, are shown on pp. 238–57. On pp. 10–11 there is a chronology outlining major historical periods and a map showing the expansion of Vietnam's borders. Unfortunately, three dynasties established after Vietnam won its independence from China in the tenth century CE — Dinh, 968–80, Early Le, 980–1009 and Ly, 1010–1225 — are either missing or misrepresented in this chronology.
Three essays present an excellent historical background and aesthetic appreciation of Vietnamese ceramics. John A. Stevenson explores the evolution of ceramic production in Vietnam and explains that ceramics are one of the few examples of the country's culture to have survived its turbulent past. Whilst noting Chinese cultural influences, Stevenson points out several features that make the Vietnamese ceramic tradition distinctive. Donald A. Wood's essay further examines indigenous and borrowed cultural meanings and the symbolism behind Vietnamese ceramic decoration. He states that potters derived inspiration from the natural environment and they represented not only what was important to them, but also typical aspects of their daily lives.
Philippe Truong's essay explains how archaeological research and museum collections are managed in present-day Vietnam, and he warns about the forgery of admired ceramics of the past. Both Stevenson and Truong discuss the significance of recent shipwreck discoveries, in particular the Hoi An excavation that is represented by a few exhibited pieces (pp. 192–5 and 208–9). Surprisingly, the essays omit to mention Vietnamese kiln site excavations that provide valuable information about firing methods, forms, and clay body types. Tang Ba Hoanh, in Chu Dau Ceramics published in 1999, provides significant data about a kiln site in northern Vietnam, while the Go Sanh kiln sites in Central Vietnam are well documented in the 2002 excavation report edited by Aoyagi Yoji and Hasebe Gakuji.
The ceramics exhibited in the Dragons and lotus blossoms catalogue are presented in chronological groups with a brief introduction to each section. The influence of Chinese decorative styles is highlighted where applicable and the catalogue's authors rightly hold a high regard for Chinese ceramics. Nevertheless, the comment that kiln grit on a Vietnamese bowl was a deficiency that Chinese potters would have rejected (p. 70), implies that only fine ceramics were produced in China. The Chinese imperial kilns ensured that only the highest quality wares were supplied to the emperors by destroying pieces with even minor imperfections. Yet, privately owned kilns in China and Vietnam could not afford to follow such wasteful practices and market demand sometimes meant that less than perfect ceramics were saleable.
The integration of Chinese cultural ideas by Vietnamese potters can also make the identification of tradewares quite challenging and the provenance of a few exhibits is disputable. The glazing and brushwork of four blue and white ceramics (cat. 122, 138, 191 and 197) suggest that they are Chinese pieces. The bowl on p. 187 with foliated dragons and a double vajra motif has features seen on fifteenth to early-sixteenth-century Chinese wares. Peter Y.K. Lam, in the Journal of the Hong Kong Archaeological Society (1986–88), discusses ceramics with these motifs found at the Penny's Bay excavations in Hong Kong, and Liang Baiquan documents ceramic shards found near the Ming Palace site in Nanjing in A legacy of the Ming (1996). Similarly decorated Chinese bowls, some with grit on their bases, were also recovered from the 1997 Lena Shoal shipwreck excavation in the Philippines.
Coarse dishes like a heavily potted catalogue exhibit (cat. 177) were found at the Dai Lang burial mound excavations in the Vietnam's Central Highlands, which this reviewer documented during a 1992 research project. Nevertheless, Penelope Hughes-Stanton and Rose Kerr, in Kiln sites of ancient China, 1980, no. 182, present evidence that indicates that these dishes are thirteenth–fourteenth century products of the Putian kilns in Fujian Province. Moreover, evidence by the same authors (no. 213) shows that the large dish with a bold floral motif on p. 257 of the catalogue is a tenth–twelfth century product of the Xicun kilns in Guangdong. Several similarly decorated tradewares were also found at Butuan on the Philippine island of Mindanao.
The catalogue presents a group of ceramics originating from the separate polity of Champa in Central Vietnam (pp. 224–31). The jar (cat. 162) and bowl (cat. 213) are recognisable Cham wares, but the incised bottle (cat. 158) is unusual because its decoration imitates that of fifteenth-century underglaze blue bottles from northern Vietnamese kilns. A beaker with dotted designs (cat. 48), which is included with northern Vietnamese wares, may also be a Cham ware since the decoration and the way the unglazed foot area has fired a purplish colour are more characteristic of ceramics from Champa. A few problematic attributions, however, can also be noted. This is not surprising since Cham ceramics are not well known.
Two bowls on pp. 226–7 have glazing and forms that are quite unlike Cham wares, although similar bowls were excavated from the Dai Lang burials. For typical examples of Cham dishes, see Yoji Aoyagi and Gakuji Hasebe, Champa ceramics production and trade (2002). Furthermore, Zeng Guangyi — in Archaeological finds from the five dynasties to the Qing periods in Guangdong (1989, pp. 165–7) — identifies bowls like the catalogue example on p. 227 as products of Guangdong kilns made to imitate Longquan celadon dishes. Two glazed jars with applied dragons on pp. 230–1 are also Chinese products. Jars like cat. 164 were excavated from the San Diego shipwreck in the Philippines and also from the Brunei Darussalam shipwreck. The dragon jars from both shipwrecks have been attributed to southern Chinese kilns. Moreover, the brittle clay body type of these jars does not conform to that of the shards and wasters that were found during the Go Sanh kiln excavations.
Finally, a puzzling dish (cat. 199) with an unusual floral design and atypical glaze may possibly be a Chinese ware. In the Transactions of the Oriental Ceramic Society, 2002–2003, London, Cyril Beecher describes similar cobalt-decorated ceramics found in Yunnan Province that have designs imitating fifteenth-century Vietnamese decorative schemes. This instance indicates that sometimes influences flowed in the other direction, from Vietnam to China.
