Southern African politics and land reform remain firmly intertwined in the 21st century. Independence may be two or three decades old in many of the countries of the Southern African Development Community (SADC), yet the question of adequate and appropriate land reform remains as pertinent as ever. Kirk Helliker and Tendai Murisa's edited collection seeks to analyse issues of agrarian reform from the bottom-up, looking at the role of associative groups and civil society more broadly in Southern Africa as its nations continue to grapple with the problem of adequate land reform in the form of redistribution, restitution and future sustainable development. The collection sets out to ‘examine the manner in which various formations within civil society frame and attempt to solve [new agrarian and land] challenges, in order to promote a more inclusive and constructive framework for the participation in land and agrarian reform policy formation’ (p. x). Written by ‘academics, practitioners and activists in land and agrarian reform‘(p. x), the overall emphasis is on micro-level analyses of agrarian reform in the region and showing the social forces that engage domestic, and international, approaches to land issues in Southern Africa.
The collection consists of nine chapters, eight of which are focused on country-specific case studies. Chapters 2 and 3 look at the Eastern Cape in South Africa, with Chapters 4 to 9 looking at agrarian issues in Zimbabwe, Namibia, Mozambique, Botswana, Zambia and the Democratic Republic of Congo. Whilst an initial worry may be a wide divergence in geographical/historical context and current national politics, it quickly becomes apparent that each of the chapters bears interesting comparisons and the collection as a whole flows nicely from one chapter to the next. Thus, Chapters 2 and 3, focusing on rural communities in the Eastern Cape, South Africa in the post-apartheid era and the mobilisation of farm workers and dwellers in these communities in recent years, respectively, lay the framework for the chapters that follow. An underlying theme of the collection is thus the activisation and mobilisation of local actors and groups on the ground and attempting to challenge macro-level studies of national policy and implementation which ignore the dynamics and activities of the communities affected, and engaged, in such land reform projects or initiatives.
Many of the chapters offer searing critiques of inadequate land reform implementation and commitment from national governments, and the oft-recurring problem of concrete cooperation between Government departments, for instance in the illusory inter-departmental engagement in Ute Dickemann's look at national projects for the Hai//om and San in Namibia, Chapter 5. Chapter 4, by Tendai Murisa, in particular provokes much food for thought regarding Zimbabwean land reform and local action: challenging notions of War Veterans' agrarian groups, it attempts (and succeeds) in critically debunking two-dimensional depictions of the land question in Zimbabwe from the early 1990s to the present day. As Murisa notes, ‘the widespread land occupations that led to the fast track land reform programme in Zimbabwe have a longer history than widely acknowledged’ (p. 113) and studies of Zimbabwe's land occupations and ‘fast track’ land redistribution programme too often fail to ‘include the motivations of land occupiers, especially their socioeconomic contexts and the significance of land to rural social reproduction’ (p. 123). Ultimately, Murisa's chapter title points to a key function of Helliker and Murisa's collection as a whole: critically engaging with the ‘lacunae’ of rural agrarian engagement and resistance in Southern Africa beyond simplistic depictions of homogeneous, seemingly reactive, actors and groups.
The one chapter that fails somewhat to hold to the standard of the collection as a whole, however, is Diamanino Nhampossa's chapter on the ‘Genesis and role of the peasant movement in Mozambique’. Whilst the collection aims to give voice to intellectuals ‘actively engaged with rural communities' and to let them ‘speak to the experiences of these activists in working with marginalized communities' (p. 31), the problem of analytical distance can inevitably emerge. Nhampossa (Executive Coordinator of the National Farmers Union of Mozambique, UNAC) offers a chapter that is laudatory and praiseworthy to the extreme: it reads as a five-star review of the very organisation he is intimately involved with and a highly polished version of Mozambican (revolutionary and post-independence) history. It also falls into the problem present in many of the chapters, namely blanket critiques of ‘neo-liberalism’ and seemingly nefarious international bodies such as the World Bank and IMF. Whilst it is axiomatic that many of the chapters will critique international and national policies which are seemingly devoid of local context and input, blanket criticisms of ‘neo-liberalism’ are devoid of meaning if such a term is not sufficiently probed and analysed. This lends itself to another problem within some of the chapters: an idealised notion of self-sufficient, locally fuelled agrarian (national) policies which mask the international pressures, globalised trends and almost insurmountable obstacles such policies face. Indeed, it is only in Lapologang Magole and Joseph Mbaiwa's chapter on Botswana that the idea of sustainable development, a term frequently used in the collection, is actually defined (pp. 220–223). Thus, whilst many of the chapters expound locally informed, pro-poor policies that look to domestic markets and ‘peasant’ or agrarian constituencies as the first point of contact in policy formulation, such positions are theoretically sound but contextually deficient. Indeed, in Ute Dieckemann's look at the Hai//om in Namibia, the veneration of tourism initiatives and conservancy projects as alternative sources of income for communities forgets the problems concomitant in such projects which groups such as the Ju'hoansi in Nyae Nyae, for instance, have faced. As Magole and Mbaiwa state about colonial policies which have pervaded to the present; ‘the idea of protective areas was transferred to the African continent with little regard to the geographical, cultural or economic needs of the local people’ (p. 237). Finally, all too often the idea of ‘civil society’ is presented as a homogeneous body with a single, unifying aim: it is only in Cath Long's chapter on the DRC that the multifarious nature of NGOs, and the difficulties they face when international funding is key or local activism is minimal, is brought to the fore (pp. 307–310). Further exploration of divisions and alternative strategies within civil society itself is needed in a number of chapters.
These criticisms aside, this collection is a highly useful analysis of present-day agrarian and land issues in the Southern Africa region. The mix of case studies is very effective and lends itself to easy comparisons and contrasts between national and international policies and participation by groups across the region in the face of attempted (and often ill-thought out) agrarian and land reform. In looking beyond simply South Africa or Zimbabwe, the two countries that receive the most international media coverage of land reform issues, the collection shows the recurring problems and challenges that face agrarian communities, and ultimately national governments, for decades to come. It is clear that the land question has not been solved for much of the Southern Africa region and often, such as in Zambia, ‘a new round of land dispossession for rural people’ is occurring ‘with a much wider reach than original colonial land dispossessions’ (p. 264). Local communities, often ignored beneath national policies and international frameworks, will need to continue mobilising in effective ways to ensure their voices, and alternative strategies, are not ignored.
