No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 September 2004
“All cities possess environmental stories, but there is no city that surpasses Pittsburgh in terms of the scope of its air, land, and water pollution history and the extent to which its landscape has been altered and shaped”(p. 3), claims Joel Tarr, editor of Devastation and Renewal: An Environmental History of Pittsburgh and Its Region. Inspired by the emerging field of urban environmental history, Tarr organized a conference around Pittsburgh. This volume represents the fruits of that gathering.
These essays orient the environmental history of Pittsburgh in the context of the city's physical and economic changes. The rise of Pittsburgh's industries, especially coal and steel, drove the city's explosive growth after the mid-nineteenth century. While clouds of black smoke indicated a strong economy, Pittsburgh's financial successes produced byproducts such as land polluting “gob piles” (mine wastes) and sulfuric acid that flowed into the region's waterways. The influx of workers taxed the city's infrastructure. Domestic wastes, such as raw sewage, damaged the city's waterways significantly. Untreated water meant that from 1873–1907, more Pittsburghers died from typhoid fever than did residents of any other major American city (p. 70).
Water pollution, air pollution, and industrial wastes represent the three major environmental problems addressed in the book. For example, three essays discuss the impacts that industrial growth and collapse had on the area's rivers. Located where the Allegheny and Monongahela flow into the Ohio, Pittsburgh's rivers functioned to connect the city to its hinterlands and markets. Rivers remained central to Pittsburgh's industrial expansion. The rivers acted as convenient dumping grounds for ecologically destructive effluents, and transportation needs led to the construction of locks, dams, and bridges that altered Pittsburgh's physical landscape. Progressive Era reformers rallied around issues of smoky air and clean drinking water, but questions of responsibility, as well Pittsburgh's industrial agenda, prohibited lawmakers and activists from making major changes. Edward Muller, in his contribution, explains that the city's redevelopment plans that began after World War II, known as the Pittsburgh Renaissance, represented the next wave of protest against issues of smoke, filth, water degradation, and downtown decay. The rivers, however, remained peripheral to city improvement plans. Not until the collapse of manufacturing in the 1980s, did the rivers' attributes seem to re-enter planners' consciousness. Since then, redevelopment plans included projects that focused on the rivers, such as rails-to-trails projects, riverfront access, housing, and new sports stadiums. Fish kills, typhoid epidemics, and sulfuric acid drainage might seem like problems of the past, but Tarr and Terry Yosie caution in their essay on wastewater that “Pittsburgh today has more combined sewer overflow outlets than any other city in the nation, leading to rising fecal coliform rates in the rivers at times of wet weather”(p. 87). Images of raw sewage interrupting weekend regattas impinge on Pittsburgh's reputation as an environmental success story.
Along those lines, Samuel Hays's piece criticizes those that wished to celebrate Pittsburgh's environmental improvements. He argues that due to an impoverished environmental culture, Pittsburgh's environmental achievements were largely a myth. Hays disagrees with arguments that local government played a significant role in the reduction of air pollution after World War II. Instead, Hays credits homeowners' switch to natural gas, and the railroads' transition to diesel-electric locomotives. Furthermore, he identifies other components of Pittsburgh's false notion of itself as a green city: apathetic environmental groups; poor coverage of environmental issues in the media; the oversight of environmental education in primary, secondary, and university curricula; and the subordination of environmental issues to revitalization projects that center on bringing high-tech jobs to the city and tourism.
Altogether, these essays confirm that looking at the place of nature in the city is a barometer of cultural attitudes. Although the authors touch on the connection between deindustrialization and Pittsburgh's healthier climate, they do not address it adequately. Overall, they do not look enough at the vicissitudes of the industrial economy or the impacts of economic collapse on changing environmental attitudes. One must question whether the city's politicians, corporate leaders, and residents would have altered their approaches if manufacturing had remained strong in the region.
Overall, Hays's critiques stand out in contrast to the historically centered analyses of the rest of the contributors. There seems little question that the quality of life in the “smoky city” has improved from the days of typhoid epidemics, suffocating clouds of smog, and dead rivers. Improvements to Pittsburgh's environment, however, seem inextricably bound to its industrial collapse. The authors leave us with the troubling possibility that Pittsburgh's environmental renewal has more to do with economic decline than designs that stem from concern about residents' health and recovering an ecological balance.