The essays in this volume, authored by eminent scholars of blackface performance, investigate recirculating images of blackface, arguing that, though the minstrelsy form may have died out, blackface has never disappeared. Capturing a general theme in the volume, Catherine Cole notes that recent scholarship ‘has attempted to move beyond the extremes of uncritical celebration and moral condemnation to analyse how blackface operated, what cultural and political work it did, and how it worked on both its producers and its consumers during very particular moments of our national history’ (pp. 223–4).
Arguing that Americans have ‘themed and fetishized their racism’ (p. 36), W. T. Lhamon Jr highlights persisting instances of the Jim Crow icon ‘despite continual attempts to erase him’ (p. 29). This initial essay frames blackface minstrelsy theoretically rather than historically, which might be disorienting for a newcomer to the field but also enables diverse connections. Dale Cockrell's historical approach discusses issues of class and commodification, focusing on the shift from popular entertainment to ‘concerts’, with the latter considered more European, moral and middle-class – and with a higher ticket price. Johnson's essay is as much historiography as history, with a ‘microhistory’ of posthumous accounts of early blackface performers. Johnson avoids ‘expansive narratives’ (p. 74) and exposes not only the ‘overwhelming racism at the core of blackface’, but also ‘a set of quite different, competing racisms’ (p. 97). Louis Chude-Sokei examines blackface through lenses of technology and sexuality, from P. T. Barnum through Karel Čapek, viewing minstrelsy as a blend of ‘African aesthetic’ and ‘machine aesthetic’. Linda Williams provides a new look at a little-known film as D. W. Griffith's ‘racial apologia’ (p. 141), arguing that the filmmaker is trying to modernize, though not correct, his racial views from Birth of a Nation. Rather than offering easy answers, Williams suggests avenues for re-examining representations of race. Nicholas Sammond points out how early film animation encouraged audiences to make associations between cartoon characters and blackface minstrelsy, with Mickey Mouse as ‘vestigial minstrel’ (p. 165). Sammond further suggests that the animation industry appropriated blackface minstrelsy as a creative outlet. Alice Maurice looks at Spike Lee's film Bamboozled, which she uses to illuminate racialized audience–performer dynamics in reality television shows: ‘contemporary popular culture still thrives on the stereotypes and racial humor of blackface minstrelsy … this kind of racism is forgotten but not gone’ (p. 209). Cole connects two seemingly dissimilar events, American ghetto parties and Ghanaian concert parties, showing how blackface circulates internationally, relating global examples of blackface to colonization.
This volume will not replace existing comprehensive studies of blackface minstrelsy, nor does it aim to do so. Yet its chapters span time, culture and media, engaging gender, colonialism and class in demonstrating the troubling endurance of blackface minstrelsy. This is an important contribution and will be useful to courses that examine the subject in depth and across contexts.
