Ritu Khanduri's Caricaturing Culture in India is the first monograph to focus exclusively on a history of Indian cartoons. Khanduri picks up this mantle with caution. Her focus on newspaper cartoons, an admitted delimitation to Hindi and English-language forums, and a neat selection of some of India's key cartoonists streamline both the archive and the questions of the book. These allow her to probe, marvelously, the grids of social, political, and cultural significations that have framed cartoons in India, and still do. These also release her from the burden of enumerating and indexing the entire genre of Indian cartoons, a freedom that saves the book from becoming another illustrated compendium of cartoons of India, veering unsurely between a coffee-table catalogue and half-baked history. What Khanduri offers us instead is a dense ethnography of cartooning as a profession, not cartoons or caricatural iconography. A “lateral history and collateral anthropology” (p. 7) of (newspaper) cartooning—“cartoon-talk” (p. 29) as she calls it—is her focus and method for connecting practice to context, profession to politics, and humor to discourse. This historicization of the genre—the frames, vagaries, and slippages of the profession—is timely to understand not only the political in India, but also the transnational politics of humor.
What strikes me most about the book is its architecture. The organization of the chapters—along themes of “colonial times,” “national times,” and “global times”—seems more than a temporal schema to structure the rich material Khanduri gathers. I would conjecture that temporality in itself is Khanduri's chosen trope to connect and juxtapose form with history. Her matrix of the profession of cartooning becomes the text of that interaction and friction. As a harness, therefore, temporality allows her to speak of caricature through its multilayered historicities. What Khanduri avoids effectively is an easy analysis of cartoons as representational of political events of the day. Cartooning becomes, instead, a mode of not only commenting on the times, but also producing the times in which they were made, with a historic agency as it were, in forming the political. Her use of each chapter as a vantage point is productive in this wider ethnographic-historical methodology of understanding the political. As Khanduri's cartoonists and their consumers speak across the book, readers get the opportunity to remain alert to the parallel, concentric, and intersecting histories of the political in twentieth-century India, be it colonial knowledge production, Gandhian politics, Nehruvian modernity, or majoritarian, communal, or caste politics. As cartoons and politics co-produce each other, in our current times too, their fluid interfaces become palpable in Khanduri's book, in ever so active ways.
For Khanduri, cartoons become many things: forms of knowledge, affective registers of imperial experience, sites for constructing norms and exclusionary practices, and political fields with boundaries and transgressions, loaded with a “surplus of meaning” that becomes the site for the curious political lives of cartoons. Khanduri's ethnography of humor-as-profession opens up the more ambiguous fields of public opinion, with internal critiques, and the nuances of liberal, nationalist, and majoritarian humor. While treating cartoons as a melting pot, Khanduri hints at both the dialectical nature of humor—“aesthetic dilemmas of cartoons” (p. 297) whereby newspaper cartoons provoke laughter and generate at once a “counter-community that questions humor and expresses hate”—and the “fragmented public” of humor, with the impossibility of “shared sensibilities” (p. 297) of humor between the cartoonist and audience. The closer we go to the question of the caricatural form, however, the more the profession and the public of newspaper cartooning seem to eclipse the visceral quality of the caricatured body itself. One might miss some notes on the rich domain of printed cartoons in periodicals (going back to the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries) that occupy the shadow zone between newspaper cartoons and the caricatural art of protagonists like Gaganendranath Tagore, who also published pictorial reviews of the political events of the year.
With due respect to the limitations of scope and the rich material addressed in Caricaturing Culture in India, some questions remain open still; for example, what is the space of the regional in Khanduri's meta-treatment of Indian cartooning? Khanduri's use of primarily Hindi and north Indian journals restricts her conceptualization of the regional. The politics of humor in India went beyond binaries of anti-colonial critique, or liberal critiques of Nehru. One wonders if the cartoonists interviewed, or the genres explored, could have been prodded more to tease out the different conceptions of postcolonial humor at play. For instance, the “dark” style of a cartoonist like O. V. Vijayan, while noted, remains marginal to Khanduri's analysis. It is tempting to wonder what would have changed in the book's narrative if cartooning from the “peripheries” of Delhi or Bombay were treated too, or if newspapers that are not mainstream were foregrounded. Do cartoonists become institutionalized too? Perhaps along the grain of Khanduri's rich ethnography of cartooning as a “peripheral form” (p. 3), new political histories of humor can emerge that explore cartoons from the peripheries of the Indian nation-state, as the political surveillance of humor or resistance itself grows in ever so visceral ways in the country.
