This book begins with a deceptively simple observation as its first sentence: “The ‘first photograph’ is hard to see” (2). Stating the obvious but unacknowledged about Nièpce's View from the Window at Le Gras allows Smith to dedicate what follows to probing two central contradictions about the introduction of photography: how it “revealed the limitations of human sight even as it offered its prosthetic compensation,” and how it “extended the realm of the visible” and at the same time “suggested that some things would remain forever out of sight” (8). She does so over seven chapters and an epilogue, interspersed with what Smith calls “visual pauses” and “focal points” – insertions of her own photographic work that “engag[e] indirectly questions and strategies examined explicitly in the chapters,” not as illustrations but as “theoretical propositions themselves” (19). This unconventional but welcome approach of deploying images equally with words effectively pulls together what is an eclectic archive, while also allowing each chapter to stand alone.
While the book addresses photography generally, the case studies at its core are mostly drawn from the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, with chapters dedicated to photographs made by F. Holland Day, Eadweard Muybridge, Andrew J. Russell, Chansonetta Stanley Emmons, and Augustus Washington. Its first and last chapters focus on Barthes's Camera Lucida and the infamous Abu Ghraib photographs respectively, working to bookend the mix of earlier canonical and neglected photographic archives with later theoretical engagements with and negotiations of the diverse medium.
Smith is an especially nuanced close reader, both of photographic theory and of images. The chapter on Barthes offers an important new understanding of his concepts of the punctum and stadium so frequently cited in discussions of photography. It does so by looking closely at the images that Barthes deploys and reserves to develop these concepts, specifically pressing the underacknowledged centrality of race, class, and gender both in them and to Barthes's influential theories about photography, and uncovering the “race-based paternalism” in his concept of the stadium and the specific subjectivity of the photographic punctum.
Race, class and gender are consistently central to how Smith sees and theorizes her photographic archive and photography as a whole. The chapter on Day offers a specifically queer rethinking of pictorialism while attending to the place of race in Day's efforts “to elevate the pictorial into the pseudo-sacred realm of the original, auratic art” (69). In revisiting Muybridge's motion studies, Smith calls our attention to how the “photographs are at once scientific and excessive, clinical and pornographic, normative and homoerotic,” allowing her to demonstrate how, “Just as motion is invisible in these motion studies, the scientific evidence the images promise is often at odds with what they reveal” (77). The middle chapters recover the archives of two significant, but neglected, photographers: Russell and Emmons. Smith contends that Russell's photographs documenting the construction of and landscape around the Union Pacific Railroad “also helped shape the view of the West that would be incorporated by the nation,” even as they captured aspects of the West that would “soon disappear from view” – an effect of motion and human perception combining to make the foreground in views from a train window imperceptible (100). Again in this chapter, Smith makes the book's trademark double move of pairing visibility with invisibility, arguing that even as “Russell's images show what would soon be made imperceptible, they also perform their own obfuscations” by reinforcing “a racial blind spot in American nation-building, participating in the whitening of the West” by mostly excluding Native Americans and Chinese laborers from their view (100). Politics also structure her readings of Emmons's nostalgic fin de siècle images of labor, tools, and laborers from early New England life that contribute to turn-of-the-century discourse about America's Anglo-Saxon heritage. Smith positions these images along with Emmons's photographs of tenant farmers exploring the “legacy of plantation slavery in the South” and critiquing the continuing “racial and economic exploitation” of African Americans just before the Depression (147). From here Smith returns to the antebellum period and daguerrean portraits made by Augustus Washington, exploring the Liberian emigrant's portraits of John Brown and members of the Liberian government “as propositions about and performances of citizenship” and “claims on full participation in an imagined nation,” borrowing on Ariella Azoulay's theorization of photography as a “civil contract” (165). The chapter on the infamous Abu Ghraib photographs offers a new reading of these heavily theorized images and the tortures that they depict by drawing out their connections to the practice, spectacle, and documentation of lynching in the post-Reconstruction American South.
Given this persuasive combination of photographic theory, analysis and practice with history and politics, At the Edge of Sight should appeal not just to art historians and others invested in photographic theory and history, but more broadly to scholars and readers interested in American studies, visual culture, and US history.
