The central thesis of Saeed Zeydabadi-Nejad's new book is that a strong and steady link exists between cinema and politics in Iran today. In view of the fact that such a link has existed without interruption since the inception of Iranian cinema over a century ago, the book raises a number of relevant questions such as: What, specifically, are the mechanisms through which the link between cinema and politics is reinforced today in postrevolutionary Iran? What are the dictates of state ideology and politics over cinema in the Islamic Republic, and how are they implemented? What does it mean for cinema to be “Islamized”? Zeydabadi-Nejad argues that the “Islamizing” policies since 1979 have been political at their core and have sought to control the most significant aspects of cinema culture to ensure that all social and artistic expression serve the purposes of the ruling establishment. Thus for three decades now, the Iranian regime has been “politicizing culture and cinema in particular” (p. 2).
The author outlines three historical phases in the implementation of state-controlled policies, each phase marked by transformative sociopolitical events: the Islamic Revolution (1978–79), the Iran–Iraq War (1980–88), and the growth and development of a reformist movement spanning Mohammad Khatami's two terms as president and ending with the election of Mahmoud Ahmadinejad (1997–2005). In each chapter, Zeydabadi-Nejad discusses the state's ruling ideology and cultural policies in terms of their impact on cinema to demonstrate the way politics and cinema are entangled in Iran today.
This book is based on fieldwork the author carried out for his doctoral dissertation at the School of Oriental and African Studies at the University of London. It consists of five chapters, along with a conclusion, bibliography, and filmography. Throughout the study, Zebdabadi-Nejad maintains a focus on key topics such as mechanisms and policies of state control, artistic visions of filmmakers, the risks and perils filmmakers face, the reception of social and political films within Iran, and the responses of politically minded Iranian film critics to international acclaim bestowed on Iranian films.
In each chapter, the author discusses theoretical and contextual frameworks before exploring key topical questions. Chapter 1 is a lengthy introduction to the book in which the author lays out the theoretical and methodological foundations for his study. As he explains, he is less concerned with the artistic and cinematic approach to Iranian cinema than with the historical and sociological one. Zebdabadi-Nejad accordingly analyzes films within the historical and political context of postrevolutionary Iran. Using interviews with film directors and viewers in Iran, he sheds light on a number of significant social and political questions. Zeydabadi-Nejad also provides definitions for concepts such as “ideology,” “confabulation,” and “radical media,” among other concepts he employs throughout the book.
Chapter 2 addresses the contradictory nature of postrevolutionary Iranian cinema by asking questions such as: How can one explain the screening of a number of socially and politically critical films in Iran given the strict and paralyzing censorship on filmmaking? Are not censorship codes clearly defined by the Ministry of Culture and Islamic Guidance? To what extent are films protected from the censors? How are screening permits issued? In their efforts to obtain a permit or to release a banned film, are filmmakers up against impenetrable ideological machines in the censorship establishment, or are there blurred and shifting “red lines” that are recognized and can be manipulated for political expediency? The correct identification of such shifting lines may in some cases allow room for complex negotiations with the censors conducted through particularities and sensitive dynamics that are unique to Iranian politics of negotiation. Through interviews with officials and filmmakers, Zeydabadi-Nejad demonstrates that although intense negotiations with the authorities, a common practice under the reformist presidency of Mohammad Khatami, may still be the only hope for obtaining an eventual green light for a film, these negotiations have become increasingly difficult under the presidency of Mahmoud Ahmadinejad (p. 53).
Zeydabadi-Nejad devotes Chapter 3 to a discussion of controversial “social films,” or films with social and political themes such as forgotten promises of social justice, widespread drug addiction, postwar trauma, or the place of the clergy in postrevolutionary Iranian society. Drawing on interviews with leading directors including Mohsen Makhmalbaf, Ebrahim Hatamikia, Bahman Farmanara, and Kamal Tabrizi, the author argues that these “social films” are widely perceived by audiences as political commentaries on the state of affairs in present-day Iran. Further, he contends that the voices of “counterdiscourse” in these films represent those of the more politically moderate circles within the establishment, whose support of these filmmakers is a way of pushing for social and political reform and raising consciousness among audiences. Thus some filmmakers hope that cinema goers sensitive to political meaning and “hidden messages” in films will resist ideological imposition and state control (p. 103).
“Social films” focusing on women's issues are treated in Chapter 4. In view of the “challenge [that] they pose to patriarchal values and institutions in society” (p. 104), these “women's films” are in effect strong political films. Zeydabadi-Nejad examines the reception of such films among both male and female viewers. Through the group discussions that he organizes, the author observes that whereas the reaction of most traditional-minded viewers to the feminist challenge through film is predictable, that of more “modern” men is not so clear-cut. That is, middle-class men striving to be more open and “modern” still have difficulty accepting the reality of educated women in Iran and women's demand for social justice (p. 105). In a similar vein, an interview with feminist director Tahmineh Milani reveals the many challenges facing female directors today, such as: what to include/exclude in the script, how to deal with the censors and negotiate with government authorities, how to portray and comment on traditional values and cultural “certainties” that discriminate against women, and how to respond to hostility from both the media as well as some male filmmakers. “So, I zigzag through,” confides Milani (p. 123).
The last chapter of the book discusses the implications of the international prominence of Iranian cinema. Among the questions addressed in this chapter are: How has the political engagement of Iranian cinema been affected by international acclaim? Why is it that uncensored copies are only shown abroad? How do these films represent and/or shape the identities of Iranians living inside and outside Iran? Are the international film festivals held in the West politically motivated in drawing attention to films that portray poverty in Iran and a “negative representation” of Iranians (as claimed by suspicious critics inside Iran, including movie directors)? The author follows this discussion through interviews with critics and audiences alike whose varied responses confirm that those who scrutinize films do so primarily for their content and rarely for their artistic merit.
This book is thoughtful, well researched, and clearly organized. It is a balanced contribution to our present knowledge of Iranian politics, state censorship, and ideological dictates upon cinema today. While some improvements might be suggested both in content and form, such as the inclusion in the group discussions of the voices of viewers not sympathetic to the cause of reform in Iran (p. 26), or the correction of a number of print errors, this book would be beneficial to anyone interested in Iranian cinema and politics.
