As the book title indicates, this work has a dual purpose: to tell the stories of imperial wives and concubines from Han times to Liao, and to discuss the sexual politics that lurk behind the stories. Keith McMahon structures his work by telling the stories chronologically, and by discussing the sexual politics in the prologue, the first chapter, the introductions and the conclusions to the stories.
By telling the stories of imperial wives and concubines chronologically, McMahon provides a history of China from an alternative perspective. This echoes what he points out in the prologue: “The state politics of men generally pretended that the sexual politics of women and the palace was completely separate. But sexual politics had an inherent effect on state politics” (p. 2). Although the main text starts with Han times, the author traces the history back to the archeological records about Lady Hao 婦好, who was the queen as well as a military commander of King Wuding 武丁 (ca. 1250–1192 BCE). The stories thus are divided into three periods: (1) “Early China, 1250 BCE–317 CE,” for which era, as McMahon observes, the historians set up themes and patterns to write about; (2) “The Eastern Jin to the Reign of Wu Zetian, 317–712,” a period noted for disunity and the emergence of nomadic customs, as well as the reign of Wu Zetian 武則天; (3) “The High Tang to the Liao, 712–1125,” which is famous for the love affair between Emperor Xuanzong 玄宗 and his Honored Consort Yang 楊貴妃, yet also noted by McMahon for its changing views of Wu Zetian.
The biographies of houfei 后妃 (empresses and consorts) in the standard histories are the basis of his book, but McMahon often juxtaposes official accounts with non-official sketches of the imperial women. He distinguishes himself from the historians and the storytellers by providing warnings about both kinds of sources. Because of the bias against female rulers, he explains, official historians tended to condemn and suppress stories about imperial women having lovers, and scandalmongers tended to let their imaginations run particularly wild with their accounts of women. McMahon instead integrates the stories into his examination of the sexual politics of China. Take the story of Zhao Feiyan 趙飛燕, for example. As the story's title, “A Wanton Empress: Zhao Feiyan, the Flying Swallow” (p. 76) suggests, Zhao is described in the Xijing zaji 西京雜記, the Zhaoyang qushi 昭陽趣史 and the Feiyan waizhuan 飛燕外傳 as a wanton woman. In place of this pejorative term, he proposes: “Less biased, more descriptive words are having lovers, having extramarital affairs, or gathering male favorites, with or without sexual relations” (p. 132). With these alternative expressions in mind, the author raises an interesting question: “When people accused powerful women of promiscuity, were they also in a subtle way accusing the women of adopting the privilege of polygamy, or at least a shadowy form of it?” (p. 132). We are not sure whether having lovers in Zhao's case was a shadowy form of polygamy, but McMahon spells out here how he reinterprets the stories that are usually considered trivial and fictional.
When he discusses the norm “only men should rule,” McMahon introduces a closely related norm “only men should be polygamists.” The latter was traditionally justified to ensure male offspring, but as McMahon points out “Chinese rulers also took concubines regardless of the need for sons” (p. 10). His examination of imperial polygamy thus enriches his discussion of the sexual politics in early and medieval China. In the first chapter, McMahon explores the fundamental principles that were established to address the issues of love and favoritism, women and state politics, and the strict division between the main wife and concubines (p. 9). He further cites ancient texts such as Shi jing 詩經 commentaries that mention harmony among imperial wives, and the Zuo zhuan 左傳 that argues against favored concubines’ competition with the main wife (neichong bing hou 內寵並后). The three cases from the Zuo zhuan that McMahon mentions (pp. 27–29), however, are not typical examples of favored concubines’ competition with the main wife. In the case of Duke Wu of Zheng 鄭武公, it was his main wife Wu Jiang 武姜 who favored their younger son Duan 段 over their elder son Wusheng 寤生. In the cases of Duke Xuan of Wei 衛宣公 and Duke Xian of Jin 晉獻公, it is not clear how the wives competed with one another. Particularly in the case of Duke Xian of Jin, his main wife Qi Jiang 齊姜 very likely had passed away before the Li Ji 驪姬 sisters were favored. McMahon includes these cases because he renders neichong as “inner favoritism,” a term that can refer to favored wives or sons, but neichong in the Zuo zhuan passage must specifically refer to favored concubines since it is followed by “competition with the main wife” (bing hou 並后), and favored sons’ competition with the eldest son of the main wife (bizi pei di 嬖子配嫡) is listed in the same passage.
The perspective of royal polygamy also allows the author to discuss sexual politics in a broader context. McMahon compares polygamy and female rulers in China with those in other cultures in the first chapter as well as other parts of the book. He demonstrates how polygamy was an affirmation of male and female potency. Even in the realm of Christianity where monogamy was practiced, male and female rulers had lovers, a practice the author calls polygamous mating (p. 11). In addition, McMahon finds that female monarchs in China are not alone in terms of the tendency of being accused of sexual crimes. Based on this observation, the author gives the reason why he does not discard these accusations for their doubtful authenticity, but includes them to elucidate the pervasive bias against women who challenged the norms of male rulership and polygamy. The notion of the close relationship between rulership and polygamy, moreover, leads to important questions as to how female rulers settled on their succession. As discussed in the stories about Wu Zetian, although she had male favorites in her later years, unlike a male ruler she was too old to produce offspring that might replace the earlier heir apparent. Alternatively, she almost appointed a Wu man as successor, and her granddaughter asked to be named heir apparent. Nevertheless, as McMahon writes in the conclusion to the second part, only in twelfth-century Jerusalem and the fourteenth-century Maldives did a woman pass the throne on to another woman (p. 207).
With the norms observed and challenged, there are stories about a wide range of people in this book: such as emperors like Liu Bang 劉邦, who ruled and practiced polygamy, as well as emperors like Yang Jian 楊堅, whose access to the rear palace was closely guarded by the main wife; from Prince Taiping 太平 and Empress Wang 王, who hoped to become another Wu Zetian, to Empress Dowager Guo 郭 and Empress Song 宋 who, even though urged by eunuchs and officials, refused to follow Wu's example. This volume thus goes beyond imperial wives and concubines. It will interest general readers with its stories from official and non-official sources, as well as students of sexual politics in prescriptive and descriptive senses.
