Gabriella Hecht's Being Nuclear: Africans and the Global Uranium Trade sets out to challenge conventional narratives in the nuclear age. What Lynn Eden's acclaimed 2006 book Whole World on Fire accomplishes in revealing how and why the predictions of mass nuclear fires were systematically absent from US strategic plans, Hecht's analysis does for our understanding of the role of Africans in uranium production and trade. Hecht employs the term ‘nuclearity’ as ‘an expression of technopolitical power’ (p. 319) and the connoted notions of exceptionality and contention that things designated as ‘nuclear’ acquires. Uranium's nuclearity is juxtaposed with its banality of being ‘just another mineral’ to be left to economic (as opposed to political) forces; neither adjectives are self-evident to uranium, i.e. uranium is not ‘born nuclear’ or banal. Herein lays the value of Hecht's text, through meticulous archival and interview research it illuminates the politics practiced when the meaning associated with uranium is tugged between the exceptional and the everyday so as to serve the agendas of state makers, mining corporates, health regulators, liberation fighters, activists and scientists.
Although the book traverses several continents to tell the story of how the global uranium market originated and expanded, Hecht's focus is especially on African uranium and its paths out of the continent, but importantly also how uranium's dangerous tails entered the bodies and lives of miners in Africa. As such the book is both in the ambit of international political economy (IPE) and subaltern studies. As an IPE text, Hecht's historical analysis in part 1 of the book entitled ‘Proliferating Markets’ makes visible what Adam Smith would call the invisible hand(s) of the uranium market, giving these hands faces and names, such as the Nuclear Exchange Corporation that published projected exchange values (prices) of uranium based on limited information (pp. 66–68). The analysis further shows how uranium production and trade mimicked colonial relations, how African agencies were initially manipulated to reproduce these relations in post-colonial times and later how African statesmen used uranium production to exert sovereignty. Today still, the political instrumentalisation of uranium explains much of the politics in international nuclear forums, such as the Nuclear Suppliers Group, the organisation tasked to set controls for nuclear exports to prevent nuclear weapons proliferation. Suspicions among the Non-Aligned Movement members persist that the ‘nuclear haves’ use export controls to manipulate nuclear markets (including the uranium market) to maintain dependency in the system despite non-nuclear weapon states' inalienable right to nuclear technology for peaceful purposes.
In Part II entitled ‘Nuclear Work’, Hecht tells the stories, and from her interviews, lets African miners tell their own stories that reflect the meaning of uranium in the daily lives of the uranium subalterns. These stories include how working on uranium mines affects health, how apartheid as a political system and mind set filtered the knowledge production about uranium mining, and how miners in Madagascar fashion uranium as a theme in existing cultural narratives and practices such as cattle keeping.
In a way Hecht's book is also about heroes and villains. One such heroine is Barbara Rogers, who resigned from the British Foreign Office and joined the anti-apartheid struggle, frustrated by Britain's ambiguous policies that tacitly endorsed South Africa's occupation of Namibia (p. 100). One such villain is J.K. Basson of the South African Atomic Energy Board, whose limited study of white miners in the 1970s concluded that lung cancer did not increase by radon exposure (p. 195), a conclusion that was used to justify unhealthy levels of radon exposure at uranium mines for decades to come.
Being Nuclear is a fascinating text in an under-researched area of matters nuclear and contributes significantly to our understanding of geopolitics and the uranium trade. It is a must read for those interested in resources politics, African colonial and post-colonial relations, nuclear matters and subaltern agency.
