In theorizing and historicizing the richly suggestive concept of “studio authorship,” Jerome Christensen offers a model of film history and film interpretation to supplement purely institutional histories that say little about particular works and to supplant the evidence-free auteurist assertions that continue to underpin a good deal of film scholarship. A longtime literature scholar and repeat contributor to Critical Inquiry, Christensen accordingly brings a textual and sometimes theoretical focus to industrial film history. His approach at times leads to curious combinations and conclusions but also results in a rich cultural–intellectual–interpretive history, drawing from film-historical models such as Thomas Schatz's The Genius of the System (1988) and perhaps more prominently from works such as sociologist David Riesman's The Lonely Crowd (1950) and Peter Drucker's postwar management theory. Notably for Christensen, studio authorship does not equate to collaborative authorship, the co-construction of an artwork involving multiple creative sensibilities. Instead, studio authorship designates the processes by which business creates works that not only compete for consumer dollars but also powerfully if allegorically express studio identities.
Christensen's work is an impressive effort to bridge the gap between economic and aesthetic film history. As such, it combines abundant historical evidence regarding studio practices, and the roles and attitudes of individual executives and producers within those organizations, with detailed, nuanced readings of individual films according to their articulation of studio identities and values. In practice, such readings can appear to substitute a novel interpretive frame – one that sees film narratives and thematics as reflexive commentaries on their producing studios and sometimes their competitors – for the more familiar frames of ideological analysis based on gender, race, class, nationhood and so forth. Christensen demonstrates exceptional fluidity with historical literature on corporations, management theory, business law and other legal and intellectual models relevant to understandings of creative industries such as film entertainment. Yet as the words “corporate art” in the book's title may suggest, Christensen positions films less as cultural artifacts than as brand expressions. To read The Fountainhead (1949) as a statement about corporate personhood, Vertigo (1958) as an allegory of “bilateral monopolism” (222), Bonnie and Clyde (1967) as a rebranding exercise, and Batman (1989) and You've Got Mail (1998) as elaborate intercorporate communications takes extensive research and critical dexterity. Yet while these readings hardly drain the films of artistry and signification, their applicability may be limited. Still, with scholars productively mining Hollywood past and present in so many ways, the field certainly has room for carefully crafted work historicizing the view that films represent business strategies and function as advertisements for the studios releasing them.
The core of the book is a comparative study of MGM and Warner Bros. in the classical and postclassical eras of the late 1920s through the 1960s, rounded out with chapters on Warners following the 1989 Time Warner merger and on the 1990s Disney–Pixar alliance. Analysis of MGM's management and output through the mid-1950s comprises nearly half the book's content, with work organized around case studies of individual films and with digressions and contextualization framing or emerging from those studies. Christensen offers hugely insightful readings of films such as The Crowd (1928), Boys Town (1938), Battleground (1949), Singin’ in the Rain (1952), The Band Wagon (1953) and Executive Suite (1954) as allegories for MGM's corporate values. Rarely does other scholarship pursue this particular line of argumentation, so Christensen's approach has the virtue of originality as well as rigor. As with any interpretive paradigm, though, we might ask what its ultimate value or utility is. Christensen is careful to supply evidence of MGM executives’ and producers’ preferences, as articulated in various historical documents though chiefly in the studios’ catalog of films. By design, he less often accounts for the efforts of collaborative film workers such as directors, writers, technicians and actors. (Bonnie and Clyde screenwriters Robert Benton and David Newman earn some attention in the sections on that film, though for their claims in a 1968 Esquire essay, not for their work on the script.) Accounting for individual creativity is not the book's goal, and it scrupulously avoids the loose claims routinely made under the banner of auteurist critique. At the same time, Christensen's analyses serve in large part as critical interventions. Implicit in some readings is the notion that creative teams would not have been explicitly aware of the overarching corporate ideologies to which completed films would contribute. And while Christensen is careful not to advance unsupported claims about filmmaker intent or audience response, he regularly makes rhetorical connections and leads readers through speculation about creative decisions and textual signification. Often this material is engaging and persuasive, though the project would clearly benefit from some tighter editing to limit digression and analogy (as well as repeated crimes against punctuation and reasonable sentence length). For example, Christensen uses the case of Executive Suite, which employed designer Charles Eames as a consultant and earned a Fortune magazine profile's observations about its aesthetic, as the opportunity for a lengthy consideration of the Herman Miller furniture company and its corporate values, which then inform the intensive narrative and thematic reading of the film. Such potential digressions register alternately as quite original pathways of historical analysis or as highly subjective pursuit of an idiosyncratic research interest. Readers’ investment in Christensen's approach will depend on their belief in the explanatory power of his corporate analogies, or indeed their acceptance of the studio-authorship thesis as a productive lens through which to view film-industry activity and film artworks.
