For over a century, human flight has captured the interest and imagination of states and their citizenry. Through national control of airspace, however, states have also “captured” the citizenry’s right to fly. There are, of course, immense benefits to state control of at least some of the facets of air transportation. For example, the excellent safety record of the airline industry owes a significant debt to its national regulators. To many within and outside the industry, however, nationality-based restrictions on the economic dimensions of air transportation—principally relating to market access and the right to own and control an airline—present an unusual and debilitating paradox in an industry which has facilitated the globalization of so many others. In Beyond Open Skies: A New Regime for International Aviation, Brian Havel, who directs the International Aviation Law Institute at DePaul University’s College of Law, Chicago, approaches the current negotiations for a second-stage transatlantic agreement between the European Union (EU) and the United States (US) as one possible resolution of this paradox.
As the title suggests, Havel’s point of entry centres on the US’s “open skies” policy as an incomplete form of liberalization. Two principal restrictions effectively and systemically undermine further relaxations. The first relates to the restrictions placed on cabotage traffic—the right of a foreign airline to operate between two points within the home country. The second relates to the requirement contained in both bilateral agreements and national laws that nationals remain in control of both the ownership and management structure of the airline through the maintenance of “substantial ownership and effective control”, or what Havel refers to as a “citizenship purity” test. Together, these restrictions prevent the airline industry from both accessing global capital and moving from the current alliance-based arrangements to more meaningful merger-based consolidations. By eliminating the two restrictions and consolidating the two markets in a second stage transatlantic agreement, both regions can achieve considerable benefits for both the industry and consumers.
This is the dominant, but not the only, script of the book. In noting the confluence between transatlantic and global discussions on the liberalization of air transport regulation, Havel proposes to extend the agreement’s influence by leaving the agreement open for ratification by third parties. In this way, Europe and the United States can harness their collective influence to shape a new regime of global proportions.
Havel’s work is by far the most detailed single work on the liberalization of the transatlantic market since the signing of the first stage open skies agreement between the US and the EU. It is extremely well researched, and the research well documented both within the text and in asides contained within the footnotes. The author has taken great pains to reconstruct and compare these developments in detail, an effort for which the reader is most certainly well rewarded. Nor is this reconstruction wholly iterative of previous literature. Importantly, the book presents an alternative interpretation to the conventional wisdom of the “big bang theory” of US deregulation. In developing such an alternative, nuanced understanding of US deregulation as a process over time, the book challenges the dominant interpretation of US deregulation as an instantaneous decision as against the more calculated, gradualist process of European liberalization. While distinguishing between agreements based on direct regulation and open skies models, Havel is also clear that both types of arrangement are incomplete forms of liberalization. Only by removing market access and ownership and control restrictions can we move not only beyond open skies, but also beyond the “Chicago system” of bilateral micro-management.
Overall, the book is a thoroughly researched and engaging commentary on one of the most significant events in air transport regulation in the past sixty years. As a detailed and extremely well-informed analysis of developments at the vanguard of regulatory learning, those concerned with air transport regulation on a global scale will find Havel’s book certainly worth the read.
