With modest support from functionalist anthropology, Coffee draws forthrightly on Cicero (De Off.) and Seneca (De Ben.) to fashion a sturdy discourse for thinking and talking about the unwritten rules of exchange that promoted social cohesion among Roman élites as their government transformed from Republic to Empire. The epic poems of Vergil, Lucan and Statius, by virtue of their capacity for the literary enactment of contemporary ideology, are the testing ground for C.'s terminology for socio-economic morality at Rome. The result of this book is a synchronically defined vocabulary that is both accessible to non-specialists — its target audience is indeed literary scholars — and also versatile in its applicability to a host of epic character studies and to the diachronic evolution of Roman social values.
As the critical moment of social interaction that could define the quality of an élite Roman's character, exchange is defined by C. in terms of two primary valences: reciprocity and commodity. These are distinguished by the presence or absence of gratuitousness. In reciprocal exchange, the giver grants more than is necessary for a strictly equal exchange in an effort to create an ongoing relationship under a general sense of equity; ideally reciprocal exchange defies precise calculation and monetary value. In commodity exchange, by contrast, the value of the gift is reckoned with precision, and no debt or obligation remains; the completion of the transaction enjoins no future commitment from either party. Both socio-economic valences in turn manifest positive and negative moral counterparts: the generous and the prodigal man as countervailing agents of reciprocity, and the thrifty and the mercantile man as agents of commodity (schema on p. 23, though the dynamism of these ethical categories permits different configurations). Of these four character types, it is the enigmatic character of the merchant, with his paradoxical combination of acute, rational calculation and his irrational lack of control and overweening self-interest, which recurs in the greatest variety of guises throughout all three epic poems.
Once these character types are established in the Introduction, the book is divided into three parts according to poem, with two chapters in each part; the former chapter defines broadly the epic's socio-economic preoccupations, and the latter engages in case studies of particular characters. An extensive Subject Index and Index of Cited Passages can be used for expeditious reference.
For C., the Aeneid projects an idealized picture of aristocratic Republican economic ethics, wherein successful and admirable acts of reciprocal exchange (e.g. Aeneas’ pact with Latinus) produce a social order vulnerable to corruption by commodity behaviour. As the model of virtuous generosity, Aeneas is opposed to Juno, who defines her agenda with the calculating mercantile language of revenge and punishment (67–73). With an enviable grasp of secondary scholarship, here and in subsequent chapters, C. also offers fresh reappraisals of Dido, Nisus and Euryalus, and Turnus. And although it is corroborated by nuanced readings of key passages, C.'s socio-economic frame can also accommodate, and even account for, characters’ emotional complexity: Aeneas’ compromised position at the death of Turnus is reflected in the diminishment of his pietas by commodity language (108–10). As gratia, fides and hospitium become distorted by mercantile influences, it is argued, the failure of fragile reciprocal relationships leads to war.
Next, C. reads the three central figures of Lucan's historical epic to show how, in civil war, the distinction between reciprocal and commodity behaviour collapses under the venal self-interest of the supremely powerful. Caesar, as one who speaks in the calculating language of commerce, comes to epitomize the irony of how scrupulous commodification produces tremendous waste, as his desires for power and warfare, always carefully reckoned, are paid in the blood, bodies and goods of others (131–4). But it is Pompey's over-reliance on vestigial norms of Republican reciprocity that causes his downfall (157–62). The dysfunction inherent to reciprocal exchange within Lucan's internecine Republic leaves Cato as the only alternative figure for socio-economic stability. The archetypal Stoic stands, in C.'s terms, as the man of scrupulous frugality, who offers a social order along a praxis not of pietas but utilitas, as exemplified in his loan of his wife Marcia for utilitarian procreation (175–9). Cato attempts to model his household as the self-sufficient locus for Roman political order, but his atavistic ideal for a pristine Roman concord fades into obscurity with his own fate, outside the extant poem.
The epic society of Statius’ Thebaid, by contrast, is not only devoid of reciprocal practices, but is dominated by an insatiable desire for consumption which causes widespread destruction. Under pressure of a Jupiter entirely invested in engineering violent spectacle for his own interests, the lone individual can find a limited response to societal malaise in the private rectitude of pietas, reconceptualized, and in the private solace offered by clementia which is not subject to negotiation (225–40). Throughout his book, C. does not endeavour to supplant so much as to supplement scholarship on Roman epic with his theories of exchange. The final chapter on the Thebaid delivers the most extensive exception, as C. argues strongly for the singular differences between Eteocles (calculating, mercantile) and Polynices (the misguided prodigal), brothers who have been understood as virtually identical heretofore. Ch. 6 showcases the advantages to C.'s approach, as it re-appraises the dimensions unique to their respective characters.
As C. sifts, categorizes and articulates the experiences of a period of social history delivered to us in literary artefacts, this book comes to abound with close philological analyses of select passages attesting the norms, cues and violations of exchange behaviour possible in aristocratic Rome. C.'s defined yet malleable language for socio-economic morality as well as his many particular case studies deserve to gain traction in future scholarship on Roman epic and ancient literary studies more generally.
