These two books concern themselves with the subject of the Arab Spring and the implications for the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region and US foreign policy, but with different emphases. Monshipouri focuses on the effects of new-media technologies, demographic trends (especially the growth of a young populace and their current situation regarding educational and economic opportunities), and the hunger for human rights and democracy among the youth. He also links Iran's Green Movement of 2009 with the Arab Spring while discussing the impact of these events, including Islamist participation in politics—especially of the Muslim Brotherhood in Egypt where he did his research apparently after the revolution that deposed Husni Mubarak—and Turkey's proactive foreign policy on US relations with Iran and the Arab world, especially Libya, Bahrain, and Syria. Rand, on the other hand, is concerned with the three “drivers,” operating in the MENA region during the 1990s and 2000s which eventually brought about the Arab Spring and focuses on Morocco, Tunisia, and Bahrain, respectively, where she did her research from 2005–2008, to highlight those three “drivers.” She contends that most academics were concentrating on the wrong subject over the past two decades—reasons for the apparent resilience of authoritarian regimes and behavior in the MENA region—and were thus caught off guard by the developments of the Arab Spring; instead, they should have been observing (1) “the growth of a public sphere beyond state control,” for example, independent journalism, satellite dishes, the Internet, and social media that continued to operate despite government attempts at censorship; (2) “deliberalization” and “de-democratization efforts” implemented by regimes in the region; and (3) the introduction of “limited” social, economic, and political reform programs that fell short of the public's and opposition's expectations. While Rand did not predict the Arab Spring, she felt that the “autocrats [were] struggling to manage change” (5).
In his initial chapters, Monshipouri points out that youth became frustrated with their inability to find employment and express their opinions freely, while endemic corruption and inadequate legal systems benefited autocratic regimes and their cronies. He provides some very important charts regarding demographic trends, unemployment rates, literacy and educational achievement and expenditures, and access to information and communication technology that highlight how political, social, and economic problems and grievances combined with “global interconnectedness has extended the scope of emotional identification at the level of humanity and increased the sense of moral responsibility for people at risk. … [This] identification has given masses of ordinary people a newfound feeling that they themselves can take control of their destiny” (95, 97–98).
The remaining chapters deal with US relations and the changing geopolitics of the MENA region. Monshipouri provides brief historical background on US-Iranian relations with emphasis on 1979 to the present. He points out that before the Islamic Revolution, Iran's nuclear program benefited from competition between American, German, and French firms and that since then Russia and China have provided assistance. Monshipouri also notes that the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty, of which Iran is a signatory, has ambiguous language that does not guarantee the “right” to enrich uranium, but allows the benefit of nuclear energy for “peaceful purposes.” He says that Iran's program “is neither legal nor technical, but rather political” (114–15). Nevertheless, Monshipouri contends that the only sensible course is diplomacy as there are a number of regional issues over which the US and Iran can cooperate—perhaps together with Turkey and Qatar—and that any military attack will “inflame Iranians’ nationalistic sentiment,” even among those opposed to the internal political restrictions imposed by Iran's government (126). Monshipouri notes that Bahraini Shi'ites see the United States as engaging in double-standard behavior as that country has done nothing to promote their civil rights, while it participated in NATO military action in Libya and has imposed sanctions on Syria in reaction to the human-rights violations of Muammar Qadhafi and Bashar al-Assad. He also asserts that the United States has been inconsistent in its policies by being open to negotiations with the Taliban, but refusing to have contacts with Hamas and Hezbollah. Such a move, he says, would improve American relations with Islamist parties in the Middle East; at the same time, Monshipouri supports a two-state solution, with security guarantees, to end the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Unfortunately, despite the 2014 publication date, this work was published in September 2013 and written before the overthrow of Muhammad Morsi by the Egyptian military, a few months earlier! Naturally, since then, regional geopolitics have changed once again.
Rand has no such problem as she provides some very valuable background information. Morocco under Muhammad VI has been able to weather the Arab Spring by introducing a new constitution and other reforms, appearing more enlightened than his father Hassan II, enhancing his legitimacy and being praised by the US even though he backtracked by cracking down on the activities of some newspapers and journalists. Tunisia was able to overthrow its autocratic president Zine al-Abidine Ben Ali even though he had constructed legal obstacles to blunt political opposition by reducing the power of NGOs and rolling back constitutional restraints on executive power. Bahrain under Sheikh Hamad bin Isa al-Khalifa instituted limited political reforms and is still in the midst of a low-intensity rebellion; unfortunately, just like Syria a minority sectarian group dominates power in the country. Rand provides examples of these “drivers” existing in other Arab countries. She asserts that the United States needs to establish clear “red lines regarding violation of free expression” in the MENA region and be consistent, utilizing Congressional actions to pressure those governments to respect human rights and not to backtrack or institute superficial reforms by only rewarding countries engaged in sustained and substantive reforms. Unfortunately, this might be easier said than done.
These two works complement one another and are useful primarily for scholars. Rand's work is better organized and more readable. For those in the lay public interested in understanding the Arab Spring the best works are Adeed Dawisha, The Second Arab Awakening (Norton, 2013), which provides much-needed historical background, and James L. Gelvin, The Arab Uprisings (Oxford University Press, 2012), which serves as a primer. For a more succinct overview and analysis, this reviewer has published an article entitled “Is It an Arab Spring or Business as Usual? Recent Changes in the Arab World in Historical Context,” Journal of Third World Studies 30, no. 1 (Spring 2013): 55–77, which is available at http://gru.academia.edu/MichaelBishku.
