Italian prima donna Francesca Cuzzoni (ca. 1698–1770) was the first internationally recognized virtuosa to sing high soprano women's roles. Although her work served as a model to the female performers who followed, no in-depth critical study has been written about her groundbreaking career on the opera stage of the Royal Academy of Music in London, where she was the celebrated prima donna from 1723 to 1728. During her tenure, the Royal Academy became one of the most important opera companies in Europe, rivaling those of the Viennese court, the Paris Opera, and the Italian opera houses of Naples and Venice. Her arrival on the London stage signaled a shift in the ways composers set roles in relationship to vocal categories and gender. In particular, Cuzzoni's superior virtuosic vocal abilities influenced and inspired German George Friedrich Handel's (1685–1759) compositional style and his musical treatment of dramatic elements.
Cuzzoni's 1723 London debut as Teofane in his Ottone caused a sensation, establishing her professional reputation “as the greatest soprano England had ever heard.”Footnote 1 Upon her successful debut, she was offered a contract for the next two seasons. Cuzzoni's triumph boosted the theatre's prestige, enabling its managers to steeply raise ticket prices by her second performance.Footnote 2 Eyewitness accounts of Cuzzoni's performances and descriptions of her voice attest to her artistry. One audience member named Mrs. Pendarve remarked after hearing her in Handel's Alessandro (1726) that “my senses were ravished with harmony.”Footnote 3 One year later, while she was performing the aria “Sen vola” in Handel's Admeto (1727), an audience member cried out from the gallery “Damn her! She has got a nest of nightingales in her belly!”Footnote 4
Charles Burney (1726–1814) recorded firsthand impressions of her skills from prominent musicians. One, from German flautist and composer Johann Joachim Quantz (1697–1773), praised her “tender and touching” expression, her ease and grace in inserting embellishments, and her “innocent and affecting” style of singing. Burney, who witnessed Cuzzoni's last performance in 1750, related that she “rendered pathetic whatever she sung” and that her ability to control and adjust musical phrases with rubato made her a “complete mistress of her art.” He described her capacity to “conceal every appearance of difficulty” in fast divisions, praising her “creative fancy” and her high notes, which were “unrivalled in clearness and sweetness.”Footnote 5 Giovanni Mancini (1720–78) offered this glowing account of Cuzzoni's powers:
This woman possessed all the necessary requisites to be truly great. … Her high tones were unequalled and perfect; intonation was born in her. She had an original and inventive mind … and her choice of embellishments was something new. She left aside the usual and common and made her singing rare and wonderful.Footnote 6
In London, Cuzzoni achieved equal status to that of the lead castrato, Francesco Bernardi (ca. 1680–ca. 1750), popularly known as Senesino, who had also joined the Royal Academy. She also commanded a salary that was unprecedented for a female singer. Haymarket manager Johann Heidegger (1659–1749) advanced her £250 for traveling expenses and guaranteed her what was, for a woman singer, an unprecedented £2,000 for the season. That sum not only surpassed the salary of her predecessor, Durastanti, whose salary had been £1,200, but equaled the salary of the academy's primo uomo, Senesino.Footnote 7 Both on and off the stage, her appearance and success at the Royal Opera challenged structures of power.
Cuzzoni and Senesino appeared as exotic, expensive birds on the puritanical English landscape, and how they were received in London was deeply shaped by social conventions regarding gender and power. Historical evidence from letters, pamphlets, and newspaper articles illuminates English attitudes toward Cuzzoni and the castrati who joined the Royal Academy, including a xenophobic rejection of their ethnicity and assumed religion and a refusal to accept presentations of gender that challenged a rigid gender system.
As with most eighteenth-century institutions, opera seria organized itself according to a set hierarchy, in this case a hierarchy of vocal categories. It dictated that the higher pitched the voice, the higher its rank in the order. Castrato singers received the lead male heroic roles, although women in breeches sometimes replaced them. Soprano castrati also played in female roles. Low-pitched voices were reserved for “common” or “vulgar” personages.Footnote 8 The hierarchal ordering of voices meant that castrati and women en travesti took the lead roles and thus received much higher pay than tenors or (especially) bass singers.Footnote 9
While disparities between castrato and women singers in training, status, and pay created an unequal playing field, they shared barriers to professional success based on their dubious social standing in European society. The focus on solo singing in the early seventeenth century had required specially trained virtuosi, and the rigorous musical characteristics of the new genre had demanded a level of professionalism unheard of in the previous era. According to John Rosselli, “the castrati—thanks to an unbroken period of study from childhood, less hampered by social custom than the education of girls—were best able to meet this demand.”Footnote 10 The successful solo careers of several famous castrato singers in the eighteenth century helped establish the reputation of castrati as virtuosi who were celebrated for their expertise. Truly to grasp Cuzzoni's novelty as a masterly female artist, a virtuosa, it is vital to picture the operatic landscape on which she surfaced.
Handel and the Royal Academy of Music, 1711–1722
By 1715, Handel had produced three full-scale Italian operas—Rinaldo (1711), Teseo (1713), and Amadigi di Gaula (1715)—at London's Haymarket theatre. Subsequently, however, the great expense of producing operas and divisions in the royal family led to a dearth of Italian opera there from 1716 to 1720. To offset the expense, the royal family, the nobility, and landed gentry decided to form a joint-stock venture in which subscribers bought yearlong subscriptions to fund the shares. This arrangement constituted an operatic enterprise unique in all of Europe.Footnote 11
Until this time, operatic productions in London had been local adaptations taken from Italian libretti; no one had yet composed an authentic Italian opera specifically for the London stage.Footnote 12 The new theatre was to serve several political and social functions for the English royalty and nobility. When the Royal Academy was formed in 1719, it was to bolster the public image of George I while directing and controlling the public taste by limiting the types of subject matter employed, thus setting the moral tone of operas produced. The subject matter of the operas was to come from historical and classical material that was “intended to illuminate how the great should behave.” Their purpose was “not only to please but to inform, to arouse emotions in the audience and to impart wisdom and teach a theory of decorum.”Footnote 13 The word “academy” appeared in its name because, like the French Academy, it was meant to teach moral lessons as well as provide public entertainment.
On 2 April 1720, the Royal Academy opened its doors at the King's Theatre in London. In May 1720, the Lord Chamberlain commissioned Handel to travel to Italy and hire the finest singers available. Senesino, Margherita Durastanti (fl. 1700–34), Matteo Berselli (1685–1721), and Giuseppe Boschi (1675–1744) were then engaged to come and sing for the academy. On 19 November 1720, the academy opened its first full season with Handel's Astarto (1720) with Senesino in the title role for his London debut.Footnote 14 In 1722, Cuzzoni came to sing with the Royal Academy. Anthony Hicks writes that with Handel, Senesino, and Cuzzoni, the company was in possession of “three reigning international stars.”Footnote 15 In conjunction with Nicola Haym's (1678–1729) reduced adaptations of earlier libretti and the inspiring interpretive genius of his star performers Cuzzoni and Senesino, Handel created what Hicks lauds as “artistically probably the pinnacle of opera in London.”Footnote 16
Castrato and Female Singers 1550–1800
By 1600, castrati were admitted to the Sistine Chapel choir in Rome, where they were referred to as eunuchus, eviratus, and castratus. The castrati's combination of superb musicianship, agile singing, and powerful lung capacity was the result of both rigorous training and surgical castration performed before the onset of puberty. The castrati grew to maturity with the lung capacity of male Olympic swimmers and the vocal cords of boy sopranos or altos. Because of their rigorous training and repressed hormonal growth, castrati had small larynxes and disproportionately large chest cavities. This combination of great lung capacity and laryngeal efficiency enhanced their ability to deliver florid musical phrases of a length impossible for normal singers to produce.Footnote 17 In 1607, a castrato was cast in Claudio Monteverdi's (1567–1643) production of Orfeo; he sang two female parts. Castrato singers were thus associated with Italian opera from its earliest productions. However, it would be several decades before they were regularly cast in the primo uomo, or protagonist, roles.
Instead, like the castrato in Orfeo, castrati usually sang female roles. That is because in 1588 the pope decreed that women were not to appear onstage in papal states. The first ban was lifted in 1590 and then reinstated again in 1676 and was sporadically enforced until 1798.Footnote 18 Eventually, castrati so dominated the operatic stage that the years 1550 to 1800 encompass the classical period of the bel canto (literally “beautiful singing”) style and correspond to the “appearance, development and decline” of the Italian castrato singer.Footnote 19
Years of war and plague precipitated a severe economic crisis in early seventeenth-century Italy, and the possibility of securing an income as a professional singer became an attractive option for capable boys from poor families.Footnote 20 In Cuzzoni's lifetime, male castrato singers received their musical training in Italian conservatories. Musicologist John Rosselli attributes the idea that “a boy's throat was more valuable to him than his testicles” to the 15th century priest Zaccaria Pasqualigo.Footnote 21 Although elaborate institutions were formed to prepare castrato singers for potentially lucrative professions, girls were not admitted to such establishments and usually received their musical training at home from a relative. It was considered a waste of time and money to train girls, who had virtually no prospects for earning a living.
The castrato singer's musical training began at age seven or eight and continued until adulthood.Footnote 22 At the conservatory, training consisted of up to ten hours a day of solfeggio (a teaching method using sol-fa syllables for vocal exercises and sight singing), music composition, language, and literature and lessons in movement and comportment. This rigorous training lasted for eight years. Students also took singing lessons with master teachers and practiced keyboard technique. The vocal music of the early baroque period concentrated on a lower vocal tessitura (vocal range) rather than on high pitches. Thus, the music written for women and male sopranos corresponds to the modern-day mezzo-soprano range, seldom rising higher than A′′.Footnote 23 Singing masters were able to extend the castrato singer's range by developing his falsetto, without which the castrato range was very limited.
Opera became the chief profession for the castrati. Those who failed to obtain livelihoods as professional singers could become priests. Due to their literary and musical training, some castrati were also able to secure work as book dealers, teachers, and historians.Footnote 24 Such occupations were either closed to women or required skills beyond the training that women could obtain so as to compete for them.
Even in the Venetian operas of the 1640s and 1650s, however, castrati were not systematically cast in the male lead roles. When no castrato singer could be engaged, the impresario would settle for a female soprano singing en travesti at lower pay. Directors also occasionally cast women in lead male roles during this time, and both female and male heroic opera seria roles were written for the soprano voice. The aesthetic of the period demanded a powerful and relatively high soprano voice, which was considered to epitomize the qualities of the male heroic ideal. These roles were composed for the castrato's superior musical abilities and vocal prowess. Male roles thus constituted the majority of principal roles in early opera, and castrati or women could both sing secondary female roles. According to Rosselli, the groups of castrati were large enough to have been “a feature of everyday life” in Italy. The female singers of Cuzzoni's generation thus had lifelong competition from the castrati.Footnote 25
Women faced many other obstacles in their quest to become professional singers. Finding and obtaining proper training in itself was a nearly impossible task. Cuzzoni was one of the lucky few who had access to some of the training necessary to launch a professional operatic career. Many others were not so fortunate. Training with the teachers who worked with castrati was impossible: the majority of castrati boarded with a teacher or in an institution, and social strictures prohibited girls from boarding with unrelated males. Another option for training for girls was the Venetian ospedali (all-girl orphanages). While the girls' training there was thorough, they were expected to marry or become nuns and were not encouraged to work as professional singers. In addition, girls in the ospedali received instruction only in sacred music, leaving them deficient in their knowledge of the secular repertoire that was well known to castrato students. Some women, however, obtained instruction from monks or choirmasters or from family members who were professional musicians.Footnote 26 Cuzzoni obtained her training from her father, who was a professional violinist. She also studied with clergyman and composer Francesco Lanzi.Footnote 27 However, most tutors were less inclined to train girls because the professional prospects for women singers were few.
Simply being active in public presented another problem for female singers. During the baroque period, respectable women in Italian and other Mediterranean cultures seldom frequented public places. Women professional singers were shunned socially because many assumed that they indulged in questionable behaviors with their male peers and patrons. In 1740 a Naples official in charge of theatres made the following statement about professional female singers:
They have never been held to be respectable, since the singing profession carries with it the harsh necessity of dealing with many men: composers, instrumentalists, poets, and music-lovers; anyone who witnesses all this coming and going in and out of a woman's house readily concludes that she is immoral, whether she actually is or not.Footnote 28
Further, in seventeenth-century Naples, “a woman performer [was] of all women a target for sexual advances.” Regardless of how skilled female performers as musicians and actors might be, it was widely believed that they were, in fact, little more than courtesans. An anonymous Italian monk stated around 1700 that although virtuosic performance brought honor, it was suitable for “all ages and conditions” but for women: “‘since being in itself a sweet and soothing art, it [virtuosic singing] would add magic spells to their attractions.’” For this monk, women were already dangerously attractive, but when they became accomplished singers, they were irresistibly seductive. Female performers were always seen as “at once dubious and entrancing.”Footnote 29 They were dubious because they earned money for public performances (associating them with prostitution), and they were entrancing because they were always the objects of male desire. Although castrati had to contend with the social stigma associated with questions about their sexuality and altered bodies, they were members of a privileged class of singers whose entitled access to professional employment was secure. In contrast, for women singers, access was barred and entitlement was out of the question.
By 1697, opera was no longer a specialized diversion found only in a limited number of locales but had become “an art form and a social focus”Footnote 30 that had spread all over Europe. By 1716, a system of theatres and a regular market for singers was in place. Its development corresponded with the period when Cuzzoni was trained and the portion of her career before she went to London. Senesino and Cuzzoni represented the first generation of virtuosi to usher in a new style of highly technical, florid singing that less-skilled singers could not perform. The spread of the Italian form also offered new opportunities and influenced changes in gender casting and vocal hierarchies. Theatrical vocal specializations were created that “established not only the castrato as leading man (primo uomo) but also the female soprano specialising in high-lying parts.”Footnote 31 These “high-lying” roles were written to utilize the upper range of the high soprano virtuosa, which was much higher than that of the soprano castrato.
Although women had been performing in the English theatre since the Restoration, early eighteenth-century European opera connoisseurs were suspicious of virtuosa singers and saw them as unsuitable female interlopers. Nevertheless, women had entered the profession, and their presence on opera stages meant that the ambiguous treatment of masculinity and the nature of operatic heroism found in Venetian operas came under scrutiny. For example, in 1708, jurist and man of letters Gian Vicenzo Gravina (1664–1718) insisted that character representations should conform to their actual nationality, age, social class, and sex.Footnote 32 Gravina's concern reflects the great shift in ideas about biological sex and gender and the conviction that representations of them should be based in verisimilitude. This attitude was related to a growing concern in eighteenth-century European society about classifying and containing natural masculinity. In earlier times, the notion that women were biologically inverted males had produced what Wendy Heller defines as a fluid “transience of gender categories.”Footnote 33 Eighteenth-century scientific investigation, in contrast, revealed starkly defined physical differences between male and female bodies, leading to speculation about what constituted “feminine” and “masculine” behaviors and thus what onstage depictions of gender should be.Footnote 34 The way that gender had been represented in traditional operatic conventions needed to be reconciled with new thinking about male and female functions and gendered decorum.
In his Della perfetta poesia italiana (1706), historian and literary critic Lodovico Muratori (1672–1750) complained that music had “become unduly effeminate”:
[It was] thus more apt to corrupt the souls of those in the audience than to purge and improve them. … Whether this effeminacy is … produced by the voices of the singers, who are all either naturally or artificially womanlike [i.e., castrati], and consequently inspire undue tenderness and languor in the souls of the audience; … or from the words, which often lack integrity and abound in lasciviousness, or from the practice of using women singers in the theatres; … modern theatre music is extremely harmful for the public mores.Footnote 35
Muratori's inferences that castrato singers “inspire undue tenderness and languor” and that including women onstage was “extremely harmful for the public mores” illustrate the depth of concern about who was singing, what was being sung, and how those factors could influence the morals of audience members.
A contributor to Mist's Weekly Journal in 1726 expressed the depth of anxiety about the current fashion of women dressing in male attire: “Who could ever bear the Thoughts of an Hercules or Achillas [sic] dress'd in Petticoats. … who could ever with Patience reflect upon the Behavior of an insolent Camilla, a bold Penthefilia, or a masculine Semiramis?” He compared everyday women to literary figures here and contended, “… it were much more fit for an army of Heroines or Amazons…” to cross-dress and most “…[un] becoming [of] the Beauty and Delicacy of the most beautiful and delicate part of the Universe.” The author who was deeply offended by the “improper” behavior of these women en travesti urged men to stop their “Encroachment and Usurpation.” He believed that if the “Partition between the Species” was broken down and “two contrary sexes” were united into one, only licentiousness could follow.Footnote 36 These comments illustrate the degree to which the scientific classification of people by gender had permeated European culture; according to this commenter, men and women were members of different species, not even from the same human group. Maintaining the boundaries between these two groups became a primary concern to some. Both women's pursuit of professional careers in leading roles and the gender ambiguity that castrati and women singing male roles presented threatened the rigid social order some wished to impose.
While the introduction of women singers to the various European stages prompted strong reactions, the appearance of Italian castrati precipitated a reaction that was truly complex. At issue was how to weigh the essential part the castrati played in the baroque operatic art form against the potential threat to gender conventions they presented. In 1709 a French traveler, the abbé François Raguenet, outlined the differences among the voices and stage presence of French women singers, French male singers, and Italian castrati. Raguenet likened the sound of the castrati to nightingales, marveling at the length of the phrases and ornamented passages they executed.Footnote 37 For Raguenet, the softer (perhaps meaning higher) vocal quality of the Italian castrati made them better suited for lover roles in opera than French male singers.Footnote 38 He also thought that the castrati's superior training and powerful voices made them better than female singers, whose voices seemed to him to be too weak to project loudly enough in larger opera houses.Footnote 39 He wrote:
Their voice is as soft as a woman's and withal it's much stronger; they are of a larger size than women, generally speaking, and appear consequently more majestic. Nay, they usually look handsomer on the stage than women themselves.Footnote 40
Thus, Raguenet saw castrato singers as perfect male lovers and at the same time as more beautiful than women. In contrast, Frenchman Étienne d'Silhouette (1709–67), who traveled to Italy in 1729, found that castrato singing had “no heart, an indifference quite natural to persons who are rendered incapable of sentiments, and who buy a beautiful voice at the expense of their humanity.”Footnote 41 Thus, to some, castrated singers were morally repugnant because they were considered to have lost their humanity, the essence of their biological maleness. Historian Dorothy Keyser details that the absence of the male growth hormone in the castrati resulted in abnormally long legs and arms. Keyser surmises that this condition made them move awkwardly onstage and that their roles were written to privilege vocal prowess over physical action.Footnote 42
Articles in the press convey the extreme discomfort of some members of the London public with the presence of Senesino. In the Weekly Journal or, Saturday's Post, an article titled “To Seignor FRANCESCO BERNARDO detto SENZINI [i.e., Senesino], At the Opera-House in the Hay-Market” recounted a dispute the author had had over the sexual identity of the castrati. To him, they represented a middle sex “betwixt us and Angels” demonstrated by “the Sweetness and Melody of [their] voice[s].” In answer, his adversary had quoted Milton: “The wise Creator peopled highest Heaven With Spirits Masculine.” Furthermore,
he inferred that you could have no Business there; … I put him in Mind how many persons of your Sex have been endowed with great Wisdom and Sagacity, this he also denied, pretending to prove from natural Causes and Effects, that there could be no Wisdom where there is no Beard.Footnote 43
Some members of the British public had great difficulty grappling with the allure of castrati's singing, the sexual ambiguity they presented, and their representation of idealized male figures. Corinne Blackmer and Patricia Smith (1995) sum up the sexually ambiguous situations presented on the operatic stage during the period of early commercial opera (roughly 1650 to 1750):
Castrated men with high voices are heroes who rescue cities and defeat foreign enemies; … ambitious female courtesans employ their sexual charms and the figures of classical rhetoric to gain their worldly ends; female mezzo-sopranos and contraltos play Greek demigods, shepherds, oracles, foreign princes… sopranos appear as everything from femme romantic leads to angelic young boys [and] the “natural” or “logical” sex of various family members is regularly … subverted.Footnote 44
Ambivalence toward the castrati eventually gave women an advantage in the competition for primary roles. The presence of women singers helped resolve the dilemma for eighteenth-century European audiences about what was “appropriate” in onstage representations of gender. Women also changed the visual and aural qualities of the operatic aesthetic. Although castrato singers were still sought after and acclaimed as performers, women singers gradually gained equal stature with their male counterparts, thereby creating new professional and social standards.
However, women performers did not attain this new place easily. Like their Italian counterparts, English female performers initially had trouble gaining professional acceptance or social respectability. When Charles II (1630–85) was restored to the throne in 1660 after the Commonwealth period and the theatres were reopened, he declared that women performers were required as “useful and instructive representations of human life.”Footnote 45 Even though this declaration provided new opportunities for English actresses, women on the stage were still thought to have questionable morals because they displayed themselves on Restoration stages to please mostly male audiences, in theatres where they were subject to sexual harassment from members of the public and theatre managers. The sexualized objectification of women performers became less acceptable after Jeremy Collier's famous 1698 treatise A Short View of the Immorality and Profaneness of the English Stage attacked specific playwrights of the period and after the Licensing Act of 1737. The act, which was originally created to censor political satire, also legitimized professional actors of both sexes, classifying as “vagabonds and rogues” only those who acted in unlicensed theatres. Notwithstanding these gains, “actresses [as professionals] were regarded as threats to middle-class notions of femininity.”Footnote 46
Cuzzoni's Predecessor in London: Anastasia Robinson
Throughout her time in London, Cuzzoni contended with prejudices based on her gender. Women had been allowed to perform on the English stage for only sixty one years before Cuzzoni arrived and were still regarded with skepticism in 1722. The experiences of an earlier English soprano at the Royal Academy help explain the social norms within which Cuzzoni was working.
English native Anastasia Robinson (1695–1755) first appeared in Creso in 1714. She came from a household of modest resources, and her father was an artist. Burney quotes Robinson's close friend indentified only as “Mrs. Delany” that men of “refinement and genius” frequented their house and that she behaved well in society as a “gentlewoman.”Footnote 47 She was courted and attended to by “persons of the highest rank” and eventually married Charles Mordaunt, Earl of Peterborough (1658–1735).Footnote 48 In 1722, Robinson premiered in the title role of the Royal Academy's production of Bononcini's opera Griselda. What set this production apart from the academy's previous nine operas was that the lead character was a woman; all of the protagonists of the academy's earlier operas had been kings or princely heroes. The production is noteworthy for another reason as well: it is an important example of the shift toward submissive roles for women in opera. A review of the academy's first performance of Griselda in The Freeholder's Journal noted that “Griselda[,] … the Heroine of the last new Opera[,] … was a Lady Renowned for Patience and Submission, the most noble Feminine Virtues.”Footnote 49
Robinson was quite comfortable with the new, more submissive roles. In October 1722, she wrote to an acquaintance complaining about her role in Handel's Ottone: “Those songs that require fury and passion to express them, can never be performed by me according to the intention of the Composer … Nature design'd me a peaceable Creature, and it is as true as strange, that I am a Woman and cannot scold.”Footnote 50 Handel and the librettist altered the part accordingly. Robinson's rejection of roles that displayed “masculine” traits and her preference for stage roles that illustrated her “feminine” disposition signal her cultural conditioning. Her complaints reveal an inner conflict about her onstage performance of gender and her cultural representation of gender. On one hand, by refusing to portray roles that did not adhere to decorum and culturally sanctioned performances of “femininity,” she was intentionally complying with the dominant social ideology. Yet her pursuit of an occupation in the public sector challenged hegemonic gender models. Robinson resolved this conflict when she married in 1724; she promptly left her public profession behind to begin a more “appropriate” private role as wife.
Robinson's preference for submissive female roles contrasts starkly with the Italian women singers who routinely portrayed male roles and aggressive or seductive/enchantress female characters. Her choice to accept limitations on her performance of gender may have mitigated her audience's acceptance of her as a professional singer. Robinson's preferences and demands would have far-reaching implications in the development of the pathetic heroine roles Cuzzoni would later portray, which were modeled on the early modern ideals of womanhood exemplified in Robinson's Griselda. The pathetic roles Cuzzoni played in London also presented socially sanctioned constructs of femaleness, omitting the “masculine” attributes of earlier heroine roles. Robinson's “pleasing, modest countenance” as a “gentlewoman,”Footnote 51 Griselda's patience and submissive attributes, and Robinson's depiction of “a Woman [who] cannot scold” became essential ingredients of Cuzzoni's roles.
Cuzzoni in London: The Development of a New Role for Virtuose and the Decline of the Amazon
When Cuzzoni arrived in London in 1722, Handel took control of her talents to mold a new “feminine” role type to better conform to a male-driven ideology regarding gender roles. Although Robinson had introduced the fundamental ingredients of pathetic female roles to the London opera stage, she lacked Cuzzoni's high soprano, virtuosic vocal skills: Robinson had a lower voice, and her vocal range was very limited in comparison with Cuzzoni's. It was Cuzzoni's abilities that provided Handel with the consummate package he needed to create the high soprano pathetic heroine.
Cuzzoni's virtuosity meant that Handel no longer had to make compromises in the quality of his compositions, and he began to create principal roles specifically to highlight her skill. Handel scholar Steven Larue relays that
Cuzzoni's London début … provided the catalyst for change in the Royal Academy operas, in which singers began to define their roles not just in terms of their musical abilities as they applied to individual arias and scenes within individual operas, but in terms of consistent musico-dramatic roles from opera to opera.Footnote 52
What LaRue describes here is an operatic Fach, or role category. After Cuzzoni's arrival, Handel was free to focus on creating a role type that better aligned her voice with audience expectations about gender.
A short examination of the roles and casting practices before Cuzzoni arrived at the Royal Academy shows the extent to which things changed after her appearance. Handel always made extensive musical and dramatic revisions for the revivals of his operas, basing the changes on his current cast of singers. Of all the operas he wrote prior to 1728, he made the most changes in terms of gender and voice-type casting for Rinaldo (1711)—the first opera Handel had set specifically for the London audience. An alto castrato premiered the warrior king Rinaldo in 1711, a female contralto sang the role in the 1713 revival, and an alto castrato sang it in 1731. Handel took advantage of the talents of his virtuosi to make changes in voice and gender categories. Contrasting Jacopo Peri's early opera Euridice (1600) and Handel's Floridante (1721) reveals the kinds of changes he made in gendered casting. Peri's original cast had consisted of one woman playing a woman, one boy playing a woman, two castrati playing women, and six men (one a castrato) playing men. In Handel's Floridante, an alto castrato sang the lead romantic male, a soprano castrato played a secondary man, two basses played men, one high soprano woman played a woman, and one contralto woman played a woman. The casting for Floridante represents the usual role constellation in opera seria.
With the addition of Senesino to the London cast in 1720, Handel stopped using high soprano castrati in lead male roles; instead, he cast alto castrati as the lead male lovers and heroes. After Senesino's arrival, only secondary castrati and mezzo-soprano women cross-dressed. At this point, the lead heroine sang with a high soprano voice and the lead male hero with a low soprano or alto voice. These sounds better represented normative female–male gender constructions than had previously been the case. The presence of women such as Cuzzoni, then, had a significant impact on the place of castrati in opera. Composers began to write primary female roles for high-voiced virtuose. Toward the mid-eighteenth century, castrato singers usually sang romantic or heroic primary male roles, cross-dressing mostly for comic secondary roles. The emergence of virtuose thus signifies a shift in priorities that advanced professional women singers to primary female roles and on equal footing with the castrati as purveyors of the soprano sound within the theatre hierarchy.
Handel made decisions about gender—whether located in the pitch of the voice or in the biology of the singer—one opera at a time. Floridante served as the template for the operas he composed for Cuzzoni and Senesino: it was a three-act heroic opera seria with a lead male alto castrato and a high soprano female counterpart playing the primary romantic pair. The new template also included a secondary pair and an older male sung by a bass or tenor. With the exception of Cleopatra in the 1724 Giulio Cesare, the lead male and female roles no longer included cross-gender casting or warrior queen characters.
One consequence of the new paradigm for female virtuosi was the decline of roles for women that featured “masculine” traits. Although Handel's Armida (1707) included what Joseph Addison referred to as an“Amazon enchantress,” and contralto Durastanti's role in Handel's Muzio Scevola (1721) was an Amazon role, such roles for women decreased precipitously in London operas.Footnote 53 This was a significant change: although the majority of protagonist roles in early opera had been male, during this period, Amazon/warrior queen operas had featured strong female figures. According to Daniel Freeman, about 15 percent of Venetian operatic productions in the period 1650–1730 included Amazon/warrior queens. These libretti were based on Greek legends and served to warn to men about the inherent dangers of female-dominated societies. Consequently, Amazon/warrior queens were always defeated in the end and were usually forced to renounce their powers and marry male suitors.Footnote 54
These changes corresponded with the prevailing British distaste for Amazonian characters. In the following excerpt from Mist's Weekly Journal (1726), the author contrasted Amazonian traits with the docile behavior he preferred to see in women characters:
Her Talents are not masculine indeed;
To weild the Sword, to bend the twanging Yew,
To Lash the foaming Steeds, and drive the Car
With rapid Wheels o'er mangled Carcasses,
She knows not—These are Amazonian Virtues.
Yet is she not the less repleat with Honour;
And noble Sentiments confirm her Soul.
With Female Softness she bewails her Country…Footnote 55
By Handel's time, then, composers and librettists had begun to change the patterns of earlier operas by limiting the portrayal of female roles to submissive, “weak” women who were subject to male control. Opera seria librettists and composers were charged by public sentiment, reflected in newspapers and pamphlets, and by opera reformists such as Metastasio with modifying the encoded gender messages of roles to match social norms and dictates. This concern led Handel and librettist Haym to adjust Cuzzoni's roles: reworking older libretti to lessen Amazonian or “masculine” traits and imbuing them instead with passive “feminine” qualities.
The Pathetic Heroine
The emergence of the high soprano virtuosa at the Royal Academy enabled Handel and Haym to seize control of the fluidity in gender identification in opera. They altered female soprano roles to be more lyrical, fixing them into more “feminine” subordinate positions. These characters were at the mercy of Fate, in contrast to heroes, who dominated their environments. Following the model he had established with Robinson's Griselda, Handel chose to limit the dramatic range of Cuzzoni's characters to match the pathetic qualities that seemed more acceptable to London spectators. While most of the action for Cuzzoni's academy roles up to 1726 revolved around her, the attempts of her characters to alter their circumstances were usually ineffectual; they relied instead on the mercy of male counterparts.
In Handel's Giulio Cesare (1724), for example, Haym adapted Francesco Bussani's libretto of 1677. Haym retained most of Bussani's dialogue, cut several cross-dressing comic characters and minor scenes, and strengthened the drama by focusing on the amorous connection between the Roman emperor Cesare (Senesino) and Cleopatra (Cuzzoni), the queen of Egypt. For their version, Handel and Haym added Cleopatra's lament in chains, a scene whose addition effectively curtailed Cleopatra's strong Amazonian traits. In Haym's version, Cesare is portrayed as a brave soldier “but a still more ardent lover.” The music is more closely linked to the drama, the arias are more extensive than in the earlier opera, and the orchestration is more elaborate. Two principal figures are killed onstage, defying opera seria convention. This is a predominantly major-key opera that leans toward the sharp side, underscoring its “positive” and heroic tone.Footnote 56
This opera established Cuzzoni's reputation as an international star. Handel scholars Winton Dean and M. K. Knapp describe Cleopatra as “the equal of Shakespeare's and one of the most subtly drawn characters in opera.” They consider three of her arias to be “the supreme creations of their epoch.”Footnote 57 Cleopatra's emotional scope includes playful sensuality, confidence, and optimism in the power of her charms and her power over men. These qualities are apparent in her arias “Non disperar,” “Tutto può donna vezzosa,” “Tu la mia stella sei,” and “Venere bella.” The lament “Piangerò la sorte mia,” sung while she is in chains, shows profound heartbreak, helplessness, and fragility with momentary defiance, while “V'adoro pupille” is highly seductive. “Da tempeste il legno infranto” displays triumphant joy and relief.Footnote 58 Cleopatra was the most expressively diverse role written for Cuzzoni to that time.
As the victim princess Asteria in Tamerlano (1724), which premiered after Giulio Cesare, Cuzzoni donned a weapon for the last time when she revealed her plan to stab Tamerlano upon their first embrace. Subsequently, Tamerlano ordered her thrown into chains. Later, she attempted to poison Tamerlano but was again thwarted. Cuzzoni's characters never again indulged in “masculine” pursuits; instead they either resorted to female “wiles” (ineffectually scheming or disguising themselves as shepherdesses) to accomplish their ends, or they relied on unconquerable virtue and moral stature to rise above the low meanness of their tormentors. The pathetic heroine's only strength lay in her unswerving faithfulness and moral resolve. In all roles subsequent to Tamerlano, Cuzzoni was a victim of some sort—a faithful wife, daughter, or bride-to-be. Despite Asteria's failed attempts to take direct action against her persecutor, it was in that role that the characteristics for Cuzzoni's pathetic heroine roles first coalesced. She is a victim who, thinking herself betrayed by her lover, resorts to despairing laments designed to emphasize the sound of her voice via vocal lyricism, Cuzzoni's strong suit, as opposed to technical prowess.
Rodelinda (1725) is the first Handel opera in which Cuzzoni sang the title role, a role that represents the culmination of the elements that established specific musicodramatic characteristics for the emerging pathetic heroine. A full-blown dramatic heroine, Dean and Knapp describe Rodelinda as “among the most impressive of operatic heroines … magnificently in command of her destiny,”Footnote 59 and the strongest character in the opera. Even so, her command lay particularly in her moral rectitude, her unswerving loyalty to her husband, and the manipulation of her male counterparts to her advantage. Furthermore, she never resorted to forceful physical or verbal violence.
Despite Cuzzoni's proven ability to portray an aggressive warrior queen, most of Handel's roles for her were limited to the pathetic type. In contrast, Senesino's roles retained both heroic and pathetic elements; the soft, “weak” elements found in the texts and music are attributable to the perceived diluting effect of love and women on the strength of the hero. Also, because he was a castrato, thus weaker and more feminine, he was thought to be more susceptible to such influences. Although for Quantz “the role of the hero suited [Senesino] better than that of lover,”Footnote 60 Handel tended to decrease the heroic aspects of Senesino's roles in favor of the romantic and changed the focus of several roles from what they had been in the originals. Like Cuzzoni, Senesino was known for his abilities as a pathetic interpreter, and Handel capitalized on this propensity in all of his roles. Musicologist Steven La Rue notes Dean and Knapp's complaint that Handel's use of triplet passages and compound meters weakened the heroic strength of his character in the title role of Floridante and he argues that Floridante's only strength “lies in his single-minded devotion to Elmira”; that is, as a lover.Footnote 61
Handel continued this adjustment of roles away from the heroic in favor of the romantic qualities for the majority of Senesino's characters. Of the eleven roles he played alongside Cuzzoni, only four—Giulio Cesare, Bertarido in Rodelinda, Alessandro, and Riccardo I—engaged in traditionally heroic actions and behaviors. All eleven, however, indulged in romantic affairs, amorous fancies, and self-pity at one time or another. Musicologist Rodolfo Celletti offers the following description of Senesino:
Bernardi was destined to strengthen the tradition of the Handelian male alto as hero and lover. … He had a voice of fine timbre, powerful and flexible. He was skilled in agility singing, but he was apt to excel in the noble, pathetic style rather than in vocal acrobatics. Also, his manner of recitation and his tall stature singled him out as a fine interpreter of courtly roles. … [He had] skill in broad, grandiose phrasing. … [T]o judge from the tessituras given him by Handel, Bernardi can also be regarded as a fairly deep male alto. As far as range is concerned, Handel hardly ever took him beyond e′.Footnote 62
Senesino's low alto sound suited Handel's preference for casting low-voiced castrati in male heroic-romantic roles. His regal height and skill in both noble and pathetic styles qualified him as the ideal heroic-romantic lead. So even though Senesino's dramatic and vocal facility allowed him to play a variety of role types, Handel limited his range by standardizing his roles.
Handel's arias for Cuzzoni and Senesino reflected new norms about castrato and female behaviors. While an equal percentage of their arias are pathetic, Handel gave Cuzzoni more laments. There was another difference. Although Senesino's status as a castrato entitled him to convey more feminine “pathetic” and despairing emotions in lead male roles, forthright action always remained an option for his characters. Cuzzoni's female characters, in contrast, almost never took direct action, dissolving instead into hopeless laments about their fates or passively avoiding direct confrontation.
For both humanist and puritan writers of the early eighteenth century, women could bring men to spiritual ecstasy and offer moral stability, yet they still retained the capacity to drag them into sensual delights and irrational pleasures.Footnote 63 Handel resolved this cultural conflict in his final configuration of Cuzzoni's roles by emphasizing women's spiritual and moral qualities. Only as Cleopatra did she play a “harlot” seductress. The rest of her roles conform to the characteristics epitomized in the virtuous pathetic heroine of Rodelinda. Even though Rodelinda was the title character, her dependent, docile characteristics conformed to social norms.
Gender and Music: Composing the Feminine
Just as women were deemed to require the control of a man, music also needed to be controlled. Music's emotional pull led writers to brand it as “a vain, sensual delight and an enemy to masculine rationality,” and in 1633 polemicist William Prynne (1600–69) wrote, “Chromaticall harmonies are to be left to impudent malapertnesse, to whorish musicke crowned with flowers.”Footnote 64 Music was often personified as a woman “because of its … ability to move the affections, to ravish the mind and, at its noblest, to inspire divine love.”Footnote 65 In music, chromaticism and discordant harmonies were identified as feminine qualities that needed to be resolved with straightforward, masculine tonality.
In the baroque period, music was thought to function as a direct conduit for the affections, or emotions, and each key had a specific affect (overriding emotional state) associated with it. Social mores and attitudes about gender underpin many of the tenets of the “doctrine of affections.”Footnote 66 Composer Johann Mattheson (1681–1764) stressed the intrinsic importance of the doctrine to the compositional style of baroque composers.Footnote 67 Many of its principles follow very specific gendered symbolism that was woven into the musical language of arias. Handel worked within this doctrine and made musical and gender choices for his characters that correlated with specific affects. Singers were also expected to adhere to the affect appropriate to their arias and bring them to an emotional pinnacle.Footnote 68
An overriding principle of baroque music and art was the contrast between opposing elements, the resulting conflict, and its consonant resolution. In art this is exemplified in the interplay between light and shadow, or chiaroscuro. In music, opposing elements include texture (thin versus thick), mode (minor versus major), and harmony (dissonance versus consonance). Ever present in these various conflicts is the tension between female and male. The female element is regularly aligned with the (perceived) weak, slow, minor, dissonant, and lyrical qualities, while the male element is aligned with the strong, fast, major, consonant, and forthright qualities. In the Handel operas composed for them, this contrast is exhibited in the distribution of major and minor keys in the arias of Cuzzoni and Senesino. Of Senesino's arias 64 percent are in major keys, 36 percent in minor; this compares to 55 percent major, 45 percent minor for Cuzzoni's arias. Included in this binary was the notion that sharp and flat keys had psychological associations that followed a pattern of “ever-increasing strength and brightness (or, conversely, weakness and sombreness).”Footnote 69 In this tradition a specific vocabulary was devised to characterize different keys. German theorist A. F. C. Kollmann (1756–1829) postulated that in the well-tempered tuning system,
the major scales of C, G, D and F, are the most perfect ones, and fittest for expressing serenity, calmness, and happiness; those of A, E, B, and F sharp, are more and more sharp [i.e., have an increasing number of sharps] and serve to express joy and heightened passions; and those of B flat, D flat, E flat, and A flat, are more and more flat and [are] calculated to express tenderness, sadness, and despair.Footnote 70
Handel wrote 34 percent of Senesino's arias in the keys of C, G, D, and F major, which Kollmann described as “perfect” and “pure,” compared to 17 percent for Cuzzoni. Twenty percent of Cuzzoni's arias are in the keys of A, E, B, and F-sharp major, which Kollmann characterized as revealing “heightened passions,” whereas only 10 percent of Senesino's arias are in these keys.Footnote 71 Handel set three of Senesino's arias in C major, which, according to novelist Wilhelm Heinse (1749–1803), signifies “purity, lovely innocence of youth, patriarchal living, [and a] golden age” or, per theorist Sethus Calvisius (1556–1615), “serv[es] to rouse an army.” None of Cuzzoni's arias is in C major. On the other hand, he set six of her arias in A minor, a key that, according to poet and musician C. F. D. Schubart (1739–91), supposedly indicated “pious womanliness and tenderness of character.”Footnote 72 None of Senesino's arias is set in A minor.
Handel created a coherent key scheme for each opera, with aria keys that conformed to the overall tonal pattern while still adhering to the principles of the doctrine of affections.Footnote 73 Each aria key fit his concept for each character's emotional makeup. For instance, in Tamerlano (1724), Asteria (Cuzzoni) sings in mostly sharp major keys, reflecting her “stronger,” more resolute character, while the “weaker,” more ineffectual Andronico (Senesino) sings in mostly flat major keys.
In addition to key, tempo and meter combined to imply mood and gender. The affect of happiness, for instance, was thought to be aroused through faster notes and major tonalities, whereas that of sadness was elicited with minor keys and slow tempi. Anger was expressed by harsh, discordant harmonies and loudness.Footnote 74 The key Handel used most often for Cuzzoni, B-flat major, indicated a positive or “hopeful cast” when the tempo was allegro in compound or duple meters. When the B-flat major arias had a compound 3/8 meter with an andante tempo, they become “graceful.” Eleven of Handel's thirteen B-flat major arias for Cuzzoni fit the description “tender…, soft, sweet, effeminate, fit to express transports of love, charm, & grace.”Footnote 75 Of the seventy-one known arias that Handel composed for Cuzzoni, three of them were traditional rage arias displaying “heroic contempt and defiance.” One example is the aria Lisaura's G minor, (a key variously characterized as “passionate outbursts of jealous fury”).Footnote 76 The aria “Non piu soffrir non voglio” from Alessandro (1726) is in an allegro 4/4 time.Footnote 77 In contrast, Berenice's “Com'onda incalza” from Scipione (1726), a C minor larghetto aria in 12/8 time, is characterized as an expression of abandonment to despairFootnote 78 and grief.Footnote 79 Her C minor allegro aria “Vanne, parti,” in 3/8 time, shows uncertainty and self-pity. Finally, her D major allegro aria “Scoglio d'immota fronte,” in 4/4 time, displays joyful exuberance and constancy.Footnote 80
The association of musical elements with gender constructions has also been applied to the qualities of triad chords. For eighteenth-century music theorist Georg A. Sorge (1703–78), major triads were male and minor triads were female. He believed that compositions in minor keys should end in a major triad or open fifth to strive for perfection, or the “wholeness… of God.”Footnote 81 Musicologist Hugo Leichtentritt (1874–1951) described C major as the Naturtonart (the natural key), which exhibited “elemental power, military discipline, frankness, [and] manly vigor,” citing Cesare's arias “Quel torrente” and “Presti omai” from Giulio Cesare as exemplars.Footnote 82 The unadorned C major has no accidentals to compromise its straightforwardness. In their description of Lucejo's aria “Come al natio” from Handel's opera Scipione, which Senesino sang, Knapp and Dean use the following gendered terminology: “strongly masculine with firm downbeats and no feminine dance measures.”Footnote 83 For Cuzzoni, Handel used keys laden with accidentals, such as F-sharp minor, to denote tragedy in Cleopatra's aria “Se pietà” and the Rodelinda duet “Io t'abbraccio.” The key signature serves to signal the “otherness” and deviance of women.
In accordance with codes of the day about femininity, Handel's versions of Cuzzoni's characters were usually constructed to illustrate soft, passive, weak elements, whereas Senesino's characters, perhaps due to his liminal status as a castrato, skated across the boundaries of masculinity and femininity. Handel's realignment of musical and dramatic elements according to voice and gender types constituted the “vocal and embodied Archetypes” that we later find in nineteenth-century opera. Cuzzoni's pathetic heroine roles were prototypes for later persecuted soprano victims.Footnote 84
Faustina Bordoni (ca.1700–81) joined the company in 1725, a mezzo-soprano who excelled in rapid passagework executed in the style of an instrumentalist. By hiring her, the academy directors hoped to round out the ensemble with a counterbalance to the cantabile (smooth, lyrical, flowing) singing styles of Cuzzoni and Senesino. Cuzzoni was best known as a pathetic and expressive singer, and though her vocal quality was unique, her acting abilities were less admired.Footnote 85 She was also unable to execute rapid coloratura. Quantz described her style as follows: “Her graces did not seem artificial:,… However, they took possession of every auditor by her tender and touching expression.”Footnote 86 This description explains how Cuzzoni moved the listener through her vocal interpretation more than through her acting style; it also reflects the ongoing conflict over what should take priority in operatic performance, the singing or the acting. Cuzzoni excelled at pathetic expression through musical expression but not through acting.
Nevertheless, Cuzzoni's technical proclivities facilitated Handel's ability to codify and set the parameters for the high soprano, pathetic heroine role. Handel's roles for Faustina were low-voiced characters who could be aggressive or defiant, and were well-suited for her fast and fiery delivery of embellished lines, but the roles he set musically for Cuzzoni were dependent and compliant. This contrast was embedded in the musical construction of their arias. Handel wrote the majority of Faustina's arias in sharp, major, “positive” (or masculine) keys in (simple) duple meters, whereas Cuzzoni's were primarily in flat, sad (or feminine) major keys and in (complex) triple meters.
In early Venetian operas, female sopranos in the middle or mezzo voice range usually sang the roles of women in love. Although early heroines such as Medea, Dido, and Doriclea expressed agitation and defiance, they also displayed a decided element of pathos in the lament. After Faustina's appearance, the low-voiced mezzo-soprano took roles with more positive “masculine” characteristics, while the high-voiced Cuzzoni was assigned roles that illustrated more submissive, dissonant, or unstable “feminine” qualities. Although Cuzzoni had proven herself perfectly capable of portraying a dramatic heroine with both heroic and pathetic characteristics, after Faustina arrived she was more firmly fixed to the pathetic type, enabling Handel to isolate the elements for the prototype of the pathetic heroine.
Cuzzoni's arias were often the pathetic sicilianos that showcased her expressive, cantabile singing. When in disguise, her characters masqueraded as shepherdesses, whereas Faustina's characters disguised themselves only as men and warriors. The shepherdess had idyllic girlish qualities: she was innocent, pure, delicate, and coy. She inhabited the pastoral world. Faustina's characters might angrily chastise male betrayers, but Cuzzoni's only despaired and mourned in response to betrayal. In Handel's Alessandro, Lisaura's (Cuzzoni) text is intensely emotional in contrast to Rossane's (Faustina) more neutral and objective attitude. Lisaura's music is emotionally complex, confused, and destabilized by syncopation; Rossane's music expresses her optimistic, active, and forthright certainty. This contrast clearly demonstrates Handel's standardization of musical and dramatic characteristics for his female leads. Regardless of what combination of characteristics she possessed, the pathetic heroine would always have a high female sound, and her music would depict the dependent vulnerability “appropriate” to her sex. Perhaps because of its similarity to the male alto-castrato sound, the mezzo voice would be far less thoroughly “feminine.” The contrast between the voice types and styles of Cuzzoni and Faustina and the kinds of role in which they specialized was stark. Castrato Pietro Francesco Tosi (ca. 1653–1732) credited Cuzzoni and Faustina with having different but equal advantages for the stage.Footnote 87 Faustina's spontaneously embellished vocal lines and fiery passages were of a kind that had been performed exclusively by castrati. Thus, when either she or Cuzzoni delivered extemporaneous virtuosic embellishments, it must have seemed anomalous to early eighteenth-century sensibilities. However, this ability would probably have been more acceptable in a singer such as Faustina because of her more “masculine”-sounding (or castratolike) mezzo voice.
Cuzzoni's pathetic heroine roles are prototypes for historian Catherine Clément's nineteenth-century soprano category in which “almost all heroines are victims, persecuted by men, baritone or bass. … Violetta [La traviata], Sieglinde [Die Walküre], Lucia [Lucia di Lammermoor],… All sopranos, and all victims”—and all roles that require great high soprano virtuosa singers. Clément lists Azucena (Il trovatore) and Dalila (Samson et Dalila) as mezzo-sopranos who resist patriarchal control by participating in witchcraft, treason, and violent action (alternatives denied to high-voiced pathetic heroines). Senesino's roles were predecessors to later romantic tenor roles that Clément describes as “[y]oung, courageous, imprudent, heroes of a rebellion against the social order, fighting for love … the masculine equivalents of sopranos.”Footnote 88 Handel's creation of the pathetic heroine and his adjustments to mezzo and castrato roles provided archetypal templates for operatic role categories. Standing at the threshold of the modern and antique periods, Handel and his virtuose effected a change in the course of operatic composition.
The Body of the Other
The disgruntled operagoer's comments about the “Encroachment and Usurpation” of the foreign singers who transgressed the “Partition between the Species” reveals how the Italian star singers posed a threat to puritan and merchant-class views about decorum in the performance of gender. Senesino's condition as a castrato and Cuzzoni's status as a professional female singer ensured that, simply by virtue of who they were, they presented “out of control” representations of gender and an exoticized view of the Other. It was Handel's responsibility to take these exotic birds and package them for English consumption. This he accomplished, in part, through fixing gender identity in the roles and arias they performed.
Censorship and control of public taste were elements of Enlightenment thought that underpinned the presentation of opera seria in London. As Collier had noted at the turn of the century, art was not only expected to be based on virtue but also to teach it. However, because the singers embodied confusing gender roles, the appearance of Cuzzoni and Senesino together turned English social practice on its head. Despite Handel's efforts to mollify public opinion, he was unable to overcome the gender irregularities his star performers seemed to present. Senesino was ill equipped to portray virile male heroics or potent male lovers; his condition as a castrato rendered his body effeminate. As a professional virtuosa, Cuzzoni contradicted the submissive and dependent pathetic heroines she performed. Both she and Senesino threatened the gender paradigms of the time, and the London public was reluctant to accept them solely on the basis of their technically superior artistic skills.
Handel's attempts to contain these two anomalies through music and casting failed. Despite their artistic achievements, Cuzzoni and Senesino were held in contempt and publicly ridiculed. Because early eighteenth-century London already had an established English theatre tradition that did not include Italian castrati or virtuosa singers, audience members had to reinterpret the sounds these performers produced and the images they presented. And although the short run of Italian operas in London before the arrival of the virtuosi singers of Cuzzoni's generation did include soprano castrato singers, she was the first high soprano virtuosa to join the Royal Academy ensemble. The English singer Robinson's vocal range was smaller and lower than Cuzzoni's, and her training did not include the ability to sing or to embellish coloratura passages. The resentment that British artists felt toward the Italian singers is also clear in this 1723 comment by dramatist John Gay: “There is nobody allowed to say ‘I sing,’ but an eunuch, or an Italian woman.”Footnote 89 By 1726, an advertisement in Mist's read as follows:
Can then our British Syrens charm no more,
That we import these foreign Strumpets o'er,
At such Expence from the Italian Shore?Footnote 90
The critical judgments and prejudiced remarks in the London papers must have created tremendous pressure on artists who were performing a rigorous schedule while striving to maintain superb performance levels. Cuzzoni and Senesino could not escape their perceived Otherness and never achieved broader social acceptance beyond that of entertainers of the moment. The following newspaper excerpts from 1723 typify this reality. From the London Journal: “As we delight so much in Italian Songs, we are likely to have enough of them, for as soon as Cuzzoni's Time is out, we are to have another over.”Footnote 91 And this from Saturday's Post:
’tis not supposed that the present set of Performers will continue any longer here, than till they have filled their Purses; after which … they will go and purchase Principalities in Germany, since at the extravagant Price they are paid, they will carry away Money enough out of England for such a purpose.Footnote 92
Despite the negative publicity, Cuzzoni and Senesino's moment on the Royal Academy stage effected a shift in the domain of higher registers. Formerly, operatic heroes had sung the most prominent roles with high voices.Footnote 93 After Cuzzoni and Senesino joined the academy, the high soprano sound became the domain of the female high soprano. Thus, regardless of their failure to garner social acceptance, they left an indelible mark on the musical landscape.
The notion of the soprano as curiosity prompts an analysis of Cuzzoni's achievement on a purely social level, calling into question the historical myth that discounts her as just another haughty prima donna.Footnote 94 The incident cited most often to prove this occurred at Cuzzoni's very first rehearsal with Handel. She supposedly refused to sing the first aria from Ottone, “Falsa imagine,” on the grounds that it had been written for Durastanti. It was an old-fashioned continuo aria and would be the first thing she sang for the London public. Handel's response was to call her a “veritable devil,” pick her up by the waist, and threaten to throw her out of a second-story window.Footnote 95 Even though this incident is unauthenticated, it is often mentioned in biographies of Cuzzoni and is frequently used to prove how difficult she was to work with.
Decoding how the outward manifestations of sexual and class oppression might have prevented her from attaining social and professional acceptance provides an explanation for her behavior in hostile circumstances. Faustina, who came from a patrician Venetian family, had the advantages of professional and social contacts that gave her immediate access to high-quality instruction, professional connections, and prominent stages. In contrast, Cuzzoni came from provincial Parma, which prohibited her from obtaining not only access to such training and connections, but also exposure to upper-class social graces. Even so, she was able to compete with more advantaged performers and excel in the competition, making her triumph even more remarkable. It was Cuzzoni's tenacity and virtuosic ability that cleared the way for Faustina's appearance in London.
Frank Mercer, editor of the 1935 edition of Burney's text, wrote, “The great favour of Cuzzoni received little addition from her personal charms; as Mr. Walpole … says she was short and squat, with a doughy cross face, but fine complexion.”Footnote 96 While such accounts are superfluous to Cuzzoni's achievements as an artist, later historians have perpetuated them nonetheless. If we are socialized to receive performances according to the male normative gaze, then we are left to identify only with the male hero and desire the heroine because of her physical attributes, just as the male hero does.Footnote 97 The onstage heroine must fit an aesthetic ideal. We may feel for a homely or “squat” woman, but a woman who is considered beautiful is more compelling because she is the object of our desire. If, according this standard of beauty, Cuzzoni presumed to embody the prototypical pathetic heroine, then she should possess an attractive face and figure along with a ravishing sound. Otherwise, how could the hero fall in love with her or the audience sympathize with her plight?
On the other hand, early modern expectations for womanly beauty were also in flux. Historian Robert W. Jones alludes to a redefinition of beauty in the rising British merchant class, describing a link between the “unbeautiful face” to virtue and the “nature of feminine sexuality.”Footnote 98 Jones concludes that, in eighteenth-century British society, “Ugliness, because it ha[d] no pretence to authority, produce[d] a temper at once mild and amiable.”Footnote 99 The earlier complaint by the disgruntled operagoer also includes this value system:
It is … divine Virtue that enhances and gives a better Turn to all other Qualities however amiable and agreeable in themselves. … 'Tis this that embellishes [women], not with outward and superficial but real and noble Ornaments … and makes every Feature appear more lively, gay, and beautiful.Footnote 100
The conflict over whether to privilege physical (as Mr. Walpole's comment suggests) or inner beauty (as reflected in certain newspaper articles) continued to play out with regard to the heroine in early British novels. Scholar Isobel Grundy outlines the evolution of this conflict in eighteenth-century writing. She points to Richard Steele's 1711 advice to Spectator readers to find the “honest and laudable Fortitude to dare to be Ugly.”Footnote 101 In the novel Sophia (1762) by Charlotte Lennox (ca. 1730–1804), the title character's more virtuous disposition is privileged as being more valuable than her sister's greater physical beauty. By 1785, the norm had solidified. Portrait artist Frances Reynolds (1729–1807) wrote that “without virtue, [there is] no beauty.”Footnote 102 Taking these attitudes into account, that Cuzzoni wasn't considered beautiful could actually have worked in her favor in the development of the virtuous and compliant pathetic heroine. Even so, Jones alludes to clergyman James Fordyce's 1782 sermon to young men in which he asserted that while women can have a civilizing effect on men in social settings, “women who entered too readily into ‘the gaze of the glittering throng’ [such as the professional performer] were incapable of virtue.”Footnote 103
In spite of the evidence confirming her musical and professional achievements, Cuzzoni has been judged to have failed to perform the correct gender decorum, and this judgment has unfairly marred her stunning contribution as a consummate artist and pioneer. Nevertheless, she succeeded in changing the trajectory of operatic performance and composition for the pathetic heroine and pioneering the usurpation of the high soprano sound for professional virtuose.
Senesino's reputation has not been similarly shaped by judgments about his physical attributes and public persona. Even as his status as castrato posed a threat to the status quo, Senesino's status as a great singer of his time has remained relatively intact.Footnote 104 Cuzzoni's artistic merit, conversely, has seldom been allowed to stand on its own without qualification regarding her indecorous behavior as a woman.
Cuzzoni's Legacy
After Cuzzoni, composers wrote for a higher vocal tessitura. According to Celletti, her musical abilities facilitated changes that became common features in the arias Handel subsequently wrote.Footnote 105 One of the primary features was wide rising intervals as a feature of syllabic and semisyllabic singing. This led to a broadening of the melodic arch, infusing it with a dramatic surge. A second feature of this new style was insertions of fioriture (light and flowery) passages in which the voice makes sudden leaps upward in conjunction with elaborate coloratura passages. Women singers worked within this style to develop their dramatic expressive abilities and so compensate for their smaller lung capacity.Footnote 106 What made Cuzzoni's style so unique was her great ability to convey the depth of her character's feelings through the emotional intensity of her vocal sound. Celletti designates Cuzzoni “the first great high soprano in history,” adding that her style was characterized by “sensuous, languid emotion.”Footnote 107 Combined with her ability to sing virtuosic coloratura lines, the sound quality of the high-flying tones Cuzzoni produced and the fact that she was biologically female must have presented a wonderful curiosity to her audience. Her vocal compass was Ć to Ć, making her “the first [virtuosa] Italian singer with the characteristics of a high soprano.”Footnote 108 Celletti writes:
The greatest soprano used by Handel was Francesca Cuzzoni, … the possessor of one of the most beautiful voices of the eighteenth century, for its resonance, evenness, and its sweet moving timbre. Cuzzoni inflected and softened her tones to produce thrilling effects. While she phrased with hypnotic effect in the languid-elegiac and pathetic styles, she was also clean and flexible in agility passages, although she was not outstanding in rapidly moving coloratura.Footnote 109
Cuzzoni's abilities facilitated a new kind of character type that fit European sensibilities about gender roles at an opportune moment. Handel used Cuzzoni's superior musical skill and dramatic ability to create a prototype for the new operatic heroine as a role type adjusted to the sound of the high soprano virtuosa. This prompted him to change the role of the castrato as high-voiced singing became associated with feminine roles and characteristics and low-voiced singing became associated with the masculine. Although he was responding to public taste, this innovation altered public perceptions of women performers and the operatic form itself. Cuzzoni's work thus altered the drama, music, and performers of opera in ways that are still valid today. Her transgression of gender, class, and professional boundaries transformed her immediate social landscape and opened the terrain for future generations of women artists.
