Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-7pwfn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T08:06:22.406Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Architectural Design at Bagan and Angkor: A Comparison

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  03 October 2016

ALEXANDER KOLLER*
Affiliation:
Royal Asiatic Society ak10019@gmail.com
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This study looks at the crucial features of Cambodian and Burmese monumental architecture at the peak of the two empires. By necessity, the overwhelming majority of sites are religious, as residential structures of almost any type, with the exception of some monastic buildings, were made of perishable materials and do not survive.

Information

Type
Research Article
Copyright
Copyright © The Royal Asiatic Society 2016 
Figure 0

Figure 1.(1239) Nan-hpaya: one of the earliest examples of the Burmese “gu”, a hollow structure with a cella, surmounted by a śikhara, and a deep porch extending towards the East.

Figure 1

Figure 2.(1568) Shwesandaw: built under Anawratha in the eleventh century, it introduces revolutionary elements into Burmese stūpa architecture like the concave anda (bell shape) and the stepped pyramid with axial stairways, one of the few example of a direct borrowing of a Khmer feature in classical Bagan architecture.

Figure 2

Figure 3.Lei-myet-hna (‘four-faced’) ground plans: (482) Thambula (left) and (1391) Myinkaba Gubauk-ngè (right).

Figure 3

Figure 4.(374) Alopye: ‘gu’ crowned with a stūpa; for the alternative śikhara finial, see Fig. 1 (above).

Figure 4

Figure 5.Khmer prasat (Phnom Krom): this early-tenth century example shows the fully-formed tower sanctuary with its superstructure of diminishing storeys.

Figure 5

Figure 6.Chau say Tevoda: the large protruding hall at the front of the prasat is the maṇḍapa, characteristic of many main sanctuaries in Khmer temple complexes after the middle of the tenth century.

Figure 6

Figure 7.Ta Prohm, Hall of the Dancers: one of the most ambitious attempts in Khmer architecture to create a large-scale interior space.

Figure 7

Figure 7a.Banteay Kdei, Hall of the Dancers: a similar – possibly slightly earlier – version of the same type of building; it still shows the system of four overlapping cloisters that form this rectangular hall.

Figure 8

Figure 8.(803) Pya-tha-da: this probably unfinished temple of the mid-thirteenth century demonstrates the crucial importance of vaulting in the ‘hollowing out’ of the structure.

Figure 9

Figure 9.Beng Mealea: partially collapsed corbel vaults demonstrate the limitations of this construction technique.

Figure 10

Figure 9a.Phimeanakas: the undercutting of the corbel vault in parabolic shape may indicate an, at least visual, knowledge of true vaulting techniques.

Figure 11

Figure 10.Phnom Bakheng: the most perfect realisation in Khmer architecture of the concept of the cosmic Mt.Meru as the abode of the gods (early tenth century).

Figure 12

Figure 10a.The oddly named “Prang” at Koh Ker, the tallest stepped pyramid ever built by the Khmer, unsurpassed in its monumentality and clarity of line.

Figure 13

Figure 10b.Phimeanakas: located within the palace enclosure and reconstructed c.1000, it shows an increasing preoccupation with the decorative mouldings of the terraces and stairways.

Figure 14

Figure 11.Candi Sewu, Central Java (second half of the eighth century): the concentric layout of both Hindu and Buddhist temples in Java can be regarded as a major influence on the compositions of Khmer State temples.

Figure 15

Figure 12.Mahābodhi (c.1215): a close paraphrase of the Vajrasana Temple at Bodhgaya which introduced several un-Burmese features to Bagan in the early thirteenth century.

Figure 16

Figure 13.Baksei Chamkrong: begun in the early tenth century, it stands at the beginning of decades of experimentation with the State/mountain temples and its compositional complexities.

Figure 17

Figure 13a.Ta Keo: this unfinished temple represents perhaps the apogee of early-Angkorian architecture, in its clarity of composition and dramatic sequence of spaces and level changes.

Figure 18

Figure 14.Preah Vihear, uppermost levels: in this temple complex, Khmer mastery at interpreting natural settings and enhancing them by architectural means, is most clearly expressed; Preah Vihear is also the most radically axial of all great Khmer compositions.

Figure 19

Figure 15.Baphuon (mid-eleventh century).

Figure 20

Figure 15a.Angkor Vat (first half of the twelfth century).

Figure 21

Figure 15b.Bayon (late twelfth – early thirteenth centuries).

Figure 22

Figure 16.Preah Khan d'Angkor.

Figure 23

Figure 16a.Ta Phrom.

Figure 24

Figure 17.(1192) Naga-yon, central chamber: the dramatic verticality is emphasised by the parabolic vault that springs from ground level; the effect of lighting devices in the form of openings in the upper parts of the structure is diminished by the modern whitewash.

Figure 25

Figure 17a.(285) Wetkyi-in Gubyauk-ngè: even though reduced to featuring a restored Buddha image, this late eleventh-century temple is a good example of the mystical cave/gu effect of early Bagan sanctuaries.

Figure 26

Figure 18.(2171) Ananda: this temple can be regarded as the apogee of early-classical Bagan architecture. It combines the “gu” effect with the ancient lei-myet-hna configuration of four Buddha images around a solid core and, as harbinger of things to come, increases interior lighting and accessibility from all four sides.

Figure 27

Figure 19.(1589) Shwe-gu-gyi: one of the most uncompromisingly vertical structures in Bagan, albeit only single-storey, by virtue of its extremely high plinth and elongated śikhara (That-binn-yu in the background).

Figure 28

Figure 20.(1597) That-byinn-yu: this temple represents the most radical emphasis on the upper storey, by treating the ground floor as a mere plinth and through a powerful accentuation of cubic masses, crowned by a curiously squat śikhara.

Figure 29

Figure 21.(748) Sula-mani: this temple is often seen as the ultimate statement of Bagan-period architecture; in it is achieved a harmonious equilibrium of horizontals and verticals. The best indication of the accuracy of this view is the fact that most subsequent projects on this scale follow the “Sula-mani type”.

Figure 30

Figure 22.Bagan, panoramic view.

Figure 31

Figure 23.Preah Khan d'Angkor, Eastern gopura of the 3rd enclosure: even when taking the profuse growth of vegetation into account, this massive entrance pavilion would have blocked any view of the complex behind it; whilst approaching on this main axis, the visitor has no idea what awaits him behind the gopura.

Figure 32

Figure 24.Angkor Vat, naga causeway and view of the central mass from the West: the clear lines suggest a simple, regular, concentric layout of the main building.

Figure 33

Figure 24a.The cruciform courtyard-gallery across the 3rd enclosure of Angkor Vat is one of the most remarkable achievements of Khmer design. Not only does it interrupt the concentric configuration of the central mass, it is spatially and visually closed towards all other parts of the complex and rests entirely in itself.

Figure 34

Figure 25.Roluos site plan: note the alignment of all of Indravarman's projects, i.e. Bakong, Preah Koh and the baray; furthermore that of Bakong and Lolei, and the reference made to the (earlier) Prei Monti.

Figure 35

Figure 26.The Bagan map shows the irregularly laid-out city walls of the ninth century and clusters of temples radiating from this centre in all directions in a wholly unplanned fashion.

Figure 36

Figure 27.Despite encompassing several layers of urban planning and major changes over a span of at least three centuries, all main features of Angkor correspond to a geometrical grid. The central square of Angkor Thom, in fact the youngest of these features, was an ingenious scheme of reconstructing the capital around the old palace site and central temples (Baphuon, Phimeanakas).

Figure 37

Figure 28.Minnanthu Lei-myet-hna monastery, Bagan (dated 1223). The ground plan shows two roughly concentric enclosures; the inner enclosure contains four monumental structures and divide the space into as many basic units. In contrast to Khmer complexes, the centre is left empty.

Figure 38

Figure 29.Preah Khan d'Angkor: the linking of spaces (see also Figs. 16, 16a) is characteristic of late Angkorian architecture; it emphasises the compositional nexus between sub-enclosures but also makes the understanding of the complex as a working space extremely opaque. Contrast this with the Theravada/Burmese isolation of individual structures within the greater context of the monastery.