In Mothers of Conservatism, Michelle Nickerson focusses on southern California to show that in the 1950s and 1960s “a grassroots subculture of women” translated “widespread cultural assumptions about female intuition into a basis for asserting authority in local affairs” (xiii). Nickerson calls this new political sensibility “housewife populism.”
Nickerson recognizes that the roots of “housewife populism” are located in the first half of the twentieth century. She shows how Progressive Era reform movements “foster[ed] the sense of class and maternal obligation” (10); the post-World War I red scare and “one hundred percent Americanism” campaign infused the threat of foreign radicalism and intense patriotism; and opposition to the New Deal brought a unique brand of antistatism that championed “capitalism as a fountainhead of freedom,” while still supporting “authoritarian government measures to thwart anyone or any institution that interferes with the market economy” (5).
But Nickerson is careful to distinguish women's activism in the early twentieth century from the “housewife populism” that emerged in the 1950s. She points out three important differences. First, the “lower-brow, anti-intellectual, folksy styles” of “housewife populism” contrasted with Progressive Era female reformers who claimed that their authority came with their class position (2). Second, cultural shifts gave the American housewife iconic status in the 1950s, giving women an opportunity to utilize postwar domestic ideology to gain influence over political issues they could link to the home. Third, “housewife populism” reoriented conservative women's focus from national to metropolitan politics. By putting so much emphasis on the differences between women's activism in the first and second halves of the twentieth century, she resists the push by many scholars to write about a “long” conservative movement.
Nickerson shows that this brand of “housewife populism” took hold, in part, as a response to the growing importance and power of social scientists and bureaucrats in post-World War II American life. For example, conservative women in Pasadena marked progressive education administrators as elitist outsiders trying to take away parental authority in order to push the local board of education to fire its superintendent, William Goslin. Where some authors have downplayed the role of race in southern Californian conservatism, Nickerson argues that Goslin's plan to integrate local schools was the driving force behind this effort to remove him from office. Conservative women in Los Angeles also fused fears of forced integration with anticommunism and antistatism in order to expel UNESCO educational programs in 1952.
“Housewife populism” proved less effective, however, against the “mental health establishment” – a code word for psychologists, community health workers, and government bureaucrats involved in state-sponsored psychiatric medicine. Nickerson focusses on attacks against the Alaska mental health bill and the California community health bill. She shows that conservative women in southern California began to see the “mental health establishment” as a tool to squelch individual liberty and even conservative dissent. While some of their attacks read like a conspiracy theory novel, they did have a reason to be worried, as some psychologists were framing conservatism as a mental disease. But unlike the fight against progressive education, efforts against state-sponsored mental health facilities were ultimately unsuccessful.
Nickerson is at her best when explaining how conservative women employed the new language of “housewife populism” to further their political agenda. She does especially well in analyzing the intellectual tensions within this rhetoric and showing how conservative women reconciled their wealth and education with efforts to brand opponents as elitist outsiders. It should be no surprise that many of the women behind the anti-intellectual, folksy rhetoric were well-educated, middle-class women who went to schools like Smith and Vassar. Nickerson brilliantly reveals how women utilized gender assumptions to reconcile this tension.
Urban historians will also be interested in Nickerson's analysis of space. Nickerson sees metropolitan space as much more porous than do most urban historians, revealing how activists moved within and between the cities and counties of southern California. This metropolitan view of urban space departs from the typical urban–suburban dichotomy and shows the value of expanding studies of grassroots activism beyond the borders of a single city or county.
Nickerson is less successful, however, in explaining why conservative women in southern California were more successful in fighting against progressive education initiatives than against mental health bills. Consequently, she misses an opportunity to explore the limitations of “housewife populism.” This is not a problem unique to Nickerson's work. Historians have proven excellent at analyzing the origins, language, and organization of grassroots movements, but have not thought enough about why grassroots activists succeed or fail to fulfill their goals.
Nevertheless, this is an excellent book that should be read alongside Lisa McGirr's Suburban Warriors (2002) and Donald Critchlow's Phyllis Schlafly and Grassroots Conservatism (2007). Moreover, her use, and in-depth discussion, of oral histories make this a worthy choice for methods and oral-history courses.
