Published in 2013 against the backdrop of the political unrest that has gripped Syria since March 2011, Rebecca Joubin's The Politics of Love analyzes a repertoire of over five decades of Syrian television drama to offer insight into Syrian politics before and during the uprisings. Based on six years of fieldwork and an extensive analysis of 250 serials, the book uncovers the nuanced political critique embedded in constructions of gender and metaphors of love, sexuality, and marriage in Syrian television and their treatment of authority and power in family relationships.
Joubin begins her account of Syrian musalsalāt by elaborating the political environment of the industry. The author engages Lisa Wedeen's “safety valve” theory and miriam cooke's “sanctioned criticism” arguments that explain subversive content in Syrian drama; Joubin argues that theories of coercion cannot fully explain the critical content of Syrian drama. Rather, she sets herself apart from the functionalist arguments of the coercion arguments, and attempts to distance herself from the coercion and resistance binaries characterizing these earlier works. Joubin chooses instead to search for answers in the politics of the complex gender dynamics of Syrian drama.
In Chapter 2, Joubin presents a meticulous analysis of musalsalāt plots and dialogue as she demonstrates how the convergence of political disenfranchisement, economic marginalization, and corruption engender an embattled masculinity that resorts to crime to overcome its marginality. In doing so, the shows indict the pinnacles of power for enabling these political and economic conditions. In this chapter, Joubin also argues that family metaphors serve as a mode of social and political critique. Chapter 3 builds on Joubin's argument, as the author deconstructs the common trope of the absolute patriarch in Syrian musalsalāt and posits that the condemnation of the oppressive father figure acts as a criticism of Assad as the “father of the nation.”
Chapters 4 and 5 transport the study of gender portrayals to the historical drama genre that was widespread in the 1990s and 2000s. Joubin explores the ties between femininity and sexual purity in historical musalsalāt, arguing that such tropes denote a nostalgic longing for community in a time that predates the identity crisis brought about by colonialism. These chapters also address the role the anticolonial struggle in drama played in inspiring the 2011 uprising. While Joubin notes that struggle of neighborhood strongmen, or qabaḍāyāt, of the 1990s musalsalāt served as nationalistic, religious opposition to the Baʿthist regime and the oppressive strategies it adopted from the French (p. 157), Joubin argues that historical musalsalāt did not inspire the revolution. Instead, she convincingly shows that the state insinuated this linkage to discredit the revolution as reactionary and Islamic, and as antimodern as the genre from which it ostensibly emerges (p. 225). While Joubin's analysis of the role of historical musalsalāt is persuasive, her argument that revolutionaries were inspired by the modern lifestyles of Turkish telenovelas is far less so, since Turkish soap operas can neither address Syrian issues nor overcome the modern image of the regime and its enlightenment projects.
Chapters 6 and 7 deconstruct metaphors of masculinity and femininity. These chapters show that the popular qabaḍāy trope and the hegemonic masculine culture it captures are symptomatic of a gender anxiety that results from political emasculation. In parallel, securing female sexual purity to ensure a man's honor represents a central means through which masculinity may be actualized in musalsalāt (pp. 235, 345). In Chapter 9, Joubin illustrates the continuous effort of cultural producers to negotiate gender constructions in drama. As she demonstrates in her analysis, the deconstruction of femininity and sexual purity has been more challenging due to the symbiosis of femininity with authentic national identity (p. 403). In her conclusion, the author provides an overview of Syrian drama during the uprising, illustrating the threats that surround musalsalāt producers, and the particular importance of their art in the context of political unrest.
Overall, Rebecca Joubin's The Politics of Love is a welcome addition to a small, yet growing literature on a highly influential cultural production industry in the Middle East. However, this comprehensive account of Syrian musalsalāt lacks an equally thorough treatment of media theory and a careful engagement with the existing literature. Examples include misunderstanding the key role agency plays in Donatella della Ratta's “whisper strategy” theory, dismissing Christa Salamandra's analysis of tradition and religion in Syrian drama as simply “the use of Islam to folklorize religion,” (p. 35) and mischaracterizing Salamandra's work on the Arabic-dubbed Turkish drama as inattentive to reception (p. 205). Equally, the book does not engage with existing theory on the politics of gender construction in Arab television such as the work of Lila Abu-Lughod on Egyptian television. Moreover, its encyclopedic quality may overwhelm the reader.
Nevertheless, in its treatment of five decades of drama, the book is nothing short of masterful. Joubin's fluency in Arabic, and the Syrian dialect in particular, lends her a remarkable ability to analyze individual dialogues. Finally, the treatment of a diverse body of sources including interviews, Facebook pages, and fan pages enrich the book and make it a valuable resource to scholars of Arab and Syrian television for years to come.
