C. W. Marshall's The Stagecraft and Performance of Roman Comedy fills a long-standing need. For more than fifty years, anyone interested in the performance of ancient Roman drama did best to begin with William Beare's The Roman Stage (1st ed. London: Methuen, 1950). Beare's book is a fine introduction, but much of its approach is now decidedly dated. Marshall not only replaces Beare, but his insights into how the plays of Plautus might have been performed go well beyond anything Beare offered.
After an introduction to Plautus and Roman comedy, Marshall dedicates Chapter 1 to what he calls “The Experience of Roman Comedy.” He reviews the evidence for costume, stage properties, audience, when and where plays were performed in Rome in the second century b.c., and how plays got from playwright to producer to performance. In Chapter 2, “Actors and Roles,” Marshall considers what the personnel of a Roman theatrical troupe might have been like and how they might have performed Plautus' plays. Following earlier studies, he notes that although Rome did not share the “3 actor rule” of ancient Athens, economics probably encouraged much doubling of roles. Marshall proposes that most plays of Plautus could be produced with four to six actors, and that most also include a “star part” designed for a lead actor. Terence's plays, Marshall hypothesizes, generally needed more actors.
In Chapter 3 Marshall addresses one of the thorniest questions of ancient dramatic performance: the use of masks. Some sources seem to suggest that Roman actors did not usually use masks in Plautus' day, others that masks were always used in Roman comedy and tragedy, as they were in ancient Greece. Marshall agrees with most modern scholars that Plautus' and Terence's actors were masked. He proposes that masks combined features that would immediately reveal a character's type with others that would give the character individuality. In Chapter 4 Marshall considers possible stage action in terms of focus, pace, tone, and routines. The dialogue of Roman comedy, he notes, would make much of the action on stage clear, even though there are no stage directions outside of the characters' words.
Marshall dedicates Chapter 5 to music and meter. Accepting the conclusions of earlier scholars that scenes written in one meter (iambic senarius) were delivered without accompaniment whereas those in other meters were performed to the accompaniment of a reed instrument called the tibia, he analyzes each of Plautus' plays in terms of what he calls “arcs,” consisting of an unaccompanied scene or set of scenes followed by accompanied performance. He then offers a brief analysis of Roman comedy's most common meters.
Chapter 6 is Marshall's most daring. Drawing analogies from improv, jazz, commedia dell'arte, and other improvisatory modes of performance, Marshall suggests that Plautine performance was highly improvised, so that the texts we have often vary considerably from the verses that were actually delivered on stage. In an appendix he charts the metrical patterns of each of Plautus' plays.
Marshall's many strengths are evident throughout the book. His greatest assets are his thorough knowledge of the relevant primary and secondary works, and his reasonable response to both. For every aspect of performance Marshall discusses, the ancient evidence is a minefield: we have virtually no contemporary archaeological evidence for Republican Roman performance, and much of the literary evidence is unreliable and contradictory. Marshall treads carefully, and he provides both a balanced review of earlier work and some provocative new proposals of his own. One notes, for example, his intriguing suggestion, contrary to scholarly consensus, that individual plays were regularly performed more than once at the same dramatic festival.
Another of Marshall's strengths is his ability to apply contemporary theories of theatre and performance. This is especially evident in Chapters 4 and 6, where he effectively uses Keith Johnstone's theories on improvisation to explain how characters dominate the stage to varying degrees and how Plautine performance was something in between purely scripted drama and pure improvisation.
Although Marshall's work will replace Beare's in most respects, in some ways his reach is narrower. He moves beyond Plautus and Terence only for supporting evidence, so readers will still need to look elsewhere for a complete history of Roman theatre. Indeed, even the use of “Roman comedy” in the title is a bit misleading, for this is largely a book on Plautus, with Terence discussed only sporadically.
Marshall himself has both acted in and directed numerous performances of ancient plays, including some by Plautus. He puts this experience to good use in many places, including his useful description from experience of what it means to act in a mask. Although his insights as a performer and director are priceless, sometimes they lead him astray. For instance, Marshall assumes for Roman comedy a set of expectations regarding such things as comic timing similar to what one would find on the modern stage. Although this is not impossible, we should also consider the possibility that Roman drama, like the theatre of many early and non-Western traditions, worked with an entirely different set of basic principles. Marshall also assumes that the driving force of Plautus' comedies was farcical humor, and there is no doubt that much of Plautus was the liveliest of farce. There is nevertheless much more to Plautus than just farce, and Marshall misses nuances when he assumes that everything that happened on the Plautine stage was designed to produce a laugh.
These concerns notwithstanding, this is an excellent book. Anyone with an interest in Roman comedy should read it, and it will also prove a valuable source of ideas for those studying other theatrical traditions.
