Many historians are familiar with Otto Dov Kulka as an important scholar of the fate of Jews in Nazi Germany. The recently translated volume he coedited with Eberhard Jäckel, The Jews in the Secret Nazi Reports on Popular Opinion in Germany, 1933–1945, is a vast trove of well-presented documents, indispensible to any student of the Holocaust. Over the years he has written important articles and monographs and edited valuable volumes on antisemitism, Nazi Jewish policy, and Jewish emigration to Israel. He has gained a reputation as a balanced, careful scholar with an immense knowledge of the vast documentary record of his field.
Landscapes of the Metropolis of Death therefore initially appears as an anomaly: it is an unusual, indeed in many ways unique, combination of Kulka's childhood reminiscences of Birkenau; his ruminations about the content and shape of these memories and their place in the record of the past; and his recognition of the link, and more importantly, the vast abyss, between that experience and those memories, and the objective, detached, careful, and balanced work of the historian.
Precisely because of Kulka's distaste for hyperbole, his insistence on separating the personal and the professional, indeed, his immersion in the documentary record of an event that some have referred to as incomprehensible, the observations presented in this book have a particular weight and importance. What several generations of scholars of Nazism and the Holocaust have strenuously avoided, what Kulka himself has always shunned, is at the very core of this extraordinary text. It is, as everything he has written before, entirely devoid of embellishment, sentimentality, and self-pity; it also has no trace of ill will or a desire for vengeance, even though it reveals an understanding for this sentiment within its specific Jewish context. But at the same time it constitutes a statement about the inability of the historian, even—or perhaps especially—the historian who was “there,” to capture, reconstruct, and comprehend the experience of the very event he or she may spend a lifetime researching and rewriting.
This does not mean that Kulka's book is a cry of despair—professional or personal. He recognizes the role of historians as providing the factual and explanatory record of the past, and he retains his humanistic sensibility, never proposing that the annus mundi in which he spent his childhood denies the possibility of hope and undermines our trust in the potential of human kindness. But at the same time he notes, coolly and without drama, that there is no connection between the manner in which we have come to think of that world, or think about our present existence, and his personal and intimate experiences as a child in Birkenau. What he learned there, and what became part of his mythology, is a product of those years in the “Metropolis of Death”; it is what he calls the immutable law of the camp, the law that all were subjected to and could only accept, namely, that they would all die. That law, as he depicts it, transcended everything else—the will to live, the urge to resist, the appreciation of beauty—it was a reality that no one could escape, a fate as true and simple as gravity. He recalls staring at the blue sky with silver airplanes flying high above and perceiving the sheer beauty of it as a moment that has always remained with him and yet never negated that immutable law of the necessary, inevitable, impending annihilation. His mother's struggle to survive, to give birth to a baby, to live even after that baby's murder, must end in accordance with the logic of that law. The Soviet prisoners executed in front of the inmates, for all their courage and defiance, must submit to this law. It is a law above the law, a kind of law that he can only think of as that depicted by Kafka, a merciless, indifferent, arbitrary law, a gate that would close as soon as one asks about its purpose, let alone justice.
“The experiences that I remember from there unquestionably form the moral basis of my approach to culture, to life, almost to everything, as it took shape within me during those few months, at the age of ten and eleven, between September 1943 and the camp's liquidation in July 1944” (p. 18). And yet this is the riddle that Kulka struggles with and cannot resolve. The historian analyzes the significance of the fact that the family camp of former Theresienstadt inmates had conducted a life akin to that of a ghetto; the individual recalls it as “a place where plays were staged and concerts performed—and all this, of course, a hundred and fifty or two hundred metres from the selection platforms and three hundred to four hundred metres from the crematoria” (p. 18). The child he recalls cannot remember cruelty and violence or even despair. But the inexorable logic of that realm of death is implanted in the child for the rest of his life; the haunting images of black spots on white snow, the people shot on the death march; the visit decades later to the destroyed gas chambers he had not entered and the nightmares of being guided there by an older version of Doctor Mengele, who “was here all the time” (p. 94), as he says in the dream. Can the grown man and historian reconcile these worlds? He writes, “what I am doing here actually runs contrary to all my decisions, all my feelings, the whole awareness of my imitations, or former limitations that came to mind: limitations of language, primarily doubts of my ability to intermix these mythological landscapes with landscapes that are receptive to communicative transmission” (p. 78). He notes “the paradoxical duality of my study of that period, with its systematic, total avoidance of integrating any detail of biographical involvement into the arena of the events of that history; indeed, into the very heart of those historical events” (p. 82).
But now Kulka has done just that, and all students of history and human experience should pay heed. Because for all its fragmentary, ambivalent, jagged, and deeply unsettling nature, Landscapes of the Metropolis of Death reveals that when all is said and done, historical understanding cannot divorce itself from individual experience, even if, as this humane and utterly honest historian must eventually conclude, despite his urge over the years “to confer interpretation and meaning on human existence in the past” (p. 78), “the world, with the Metropolis and the immutable law of the Great Death having been, can no longer and will never again be able to free itself of their being part of its existence” (p. 83).
