“Accountability” and “democracy” are high on the list of frequently used and abused buzzwords in global political discourse, and some clarifying attention to them is always welcome. The central proposition of Craig T. Borowiak's first book is that our ideas about democratic accountability must be stretched beyond traditional confines to accommodate the facts and norms of politics in the twenty-first century. Readers will find plenty of room for dispute over the reasons for, and ramifications of, this claim.
The author deserves credit for going where other scholars would fear to tread. He admirably illustrates the wide range of political phenomena and social-scientific literatures that bear directly on the subject of accountability.
Chapters on ancient Athens and on the debate over ratification of the US Constitution of 1787 deal with important phases in the institutional and intellectual history of democratic accountability. The nonelectoral procedures of Athens for sanctioning official conduct and the Anti-Federalists' recommendations for ways to make electoral procedures result in popular control are both discussed in a sympathetic vein, but the author presents these cases not to evaluate institutional designs but to avoid a “narrow” (p. 95) conception of his subject. The two cases suggest that robust institutions of accountability may both require and produce a robust civic culture of solidarity and participation, but both were also predicated on criteria of political membership that are restrictive by late-modern standards.
Chapters on principal–agent theory and deliberative democracy address two relevant schools of social-scientific research on accountability. The former's emphasis on “punishability” and the latter's on “answerability” both have a place under the author's broad umbrella, but his preference for the latter is palpable. Principal–agent theory, he contends, relies on an outdated and inherently oppressive conception of state sovereignty. But deliberation's “transformative potential” for changing minds and mitigating disagreement receives an elaborate defense (pp. 107–11), with no mention of the empirical evidence that deliberative processes often do not perform this function. Borowiak's favor for deliberation is qualified by repetition of his concern about “exclusions.” Deliberative theory is at its best, though, when it expands the boundaries of participation to include all affected parties. Though the “all affected” principle is not feasible in all circumstances, it does at least represent genuinely democratic norms that ancient Greek and modern electoral varieties of democracy equally neglect.
Finally, chapters on “market accountability” and global governance attempt to assess future prospects. Market accountability could be the kind of decentralized, nonstate, and horizontal system that the author's critique of state sovereignty requires us to seek out, but it is undone by bad information and asymmetries of power. Given that he cannot take refuge in the democratic nation-state for protection from the oligarchic ravages of global economic institutions, Borowiak turns to arguments for and against cosmopolitanism. Here, the problem is that both liberal-cosmopolitan and skeptical-pluralist analyses of democratic accountability on a global scale fail to respect “aspirations of self-governance and principles of freedom and equality” (p. 151). Suspicious of institutions in general, the author instead advocates accountability “practices” that are variously described as “critical,” “reflexive,” “disruptive,” and “insurgent.”
If there is any weakness in the outline of the book, it is that a panoramic view can make it hard to focus. Still, two distinctive propositions stand out, raising vital theoretical issues of broad importance to political science. First, procedures of accountability are always locked into interactive relations with ideas of civic identity (who has the power to judge?) and norms of justice (by what standards do they judge?). This is an equally valuable caveat for empirical or theoretical studies: Accountability takes place on the back of settled assumptions about who participates and what standards apply but has the potential to unsettle those assumptions in the process. Second, accountability cannot be democratic within the principal–agent framework of a sovereign state. Using Thomas Hobbes as a foil, Borowiak perceptively notes that sovereign power is by definition unaccountable, but then adds the normative premise that unaccountable power is by definition tyrannical (and therefore undemocratic; pp. 6, 16), leaving the reader to complete the syllogism. How an infinite regress or virtuous cycle of democratic accountability must therefore operate in practice becomes the central problem of the book.
“Critical accountability” is Borowiak's answer to this problem. It stands for a theoretical posture aligned with “radical and agonistic democrats” like Romand Coles, according to which democracy is a spirit or ethos, rather than a form of government (p. 165). Its practical upshot is that “social mobilization” is required to challenge all institutions, including formal procedures of accountability themselves, through “a politics of disturbance” in the realm of “trans-national civil society” (pp. 163–67). Although the apparent objective is to change attitudes rather than to evaluate institutions, a few real-world examples are briefly discussed. Nongovernmental organizations have challenged the World Bank in recent years by “staging protests, confronting Bank leadership, and demanding answers for Bank policies” through “name-and-shame tactics” (p. 73). A civic group in India, the MSKK, organized public meetings at which official records long kept secret were revealed, showing that various members of the group had been cheated out of their wages by local government (pp. 169–70).
This is as specific as critical accountability gets, and the focus on scrutiny at the expense of sanctions, truth at the expense of consequences (did the Indian laborers get paid?), is emblematic of the deliberationist character of the book as a whole. The benefits of democratic accountability are always couched in terms of “answerability” for its own sake. “Insurgent” squatter communities are said to “seek answers for their marginalization” (p. 166), not improvement of fortunes or control over destinies. “Public demonstrations” are commended because they “make power naked,” “confront society members and institutions with public obligations,” and “challenge and destabilize mainstream assumptions about the world” (pp. 167–68), not because obligations are heeded or new assumptions acted upon. “International citizens' tribunals” are exemplary because they “appeal to the power of public opinion and the judgment of history to deliver sanctions” (p. 169) for things like the Iraq war. The problem with this kind of accountability should be obvious: An early-modern king might have heeded “the judgment of history” if he believed in divine punishment in the afterlife, but a late-modern prince might be inclined to agree with George W. Bush's reaction to the potential judgment of history when he said that “we don't know, we'll all be dead.”
Borowiak's “deliberative” emphasis on answerability over punishability is joined to his “radical” emphasis on inclusion, with the effect that the concept of democratic accountability has been dramatically expanded beyond the formal institutions of national sovereigns. Readers may wonder whether it has been weakened at the same time. The nonelectoral Athenian mechanisms of sanction could be brought into conversation with the nonelectoral deliberative mechanisms of scrutiny but are not. As a result, marginalized persons must be included in political deliberation, but the practical effect of their inclusion is uncertain. The authorities might bow to discursive pressures in any given case, or they might defy and defuse them through rhetorical and material dispensations. Thus, broader conceptual issues are at stake in the largely implicit and unargued theory of democracy on which Borowiak's analysis of accountability rests. Ancient Athenians would have said that the modern Western version of demokratia involves a larger demos (i.e., includes more people) and a smaller kratos (i.e., gives them fewer institutional powers). Critical accountability seems poised to carry this long-range counter-Athenian trend still further in both directions.
