If looking only for a simple, tidy explanation of why police reform succeeds (or fails), readers of Sabet's new book will be disappointed. As he himself states, the account is ‘holistic’ (p. 121), complex, contingent and non-parsimonious (p. 229). Sabet highlights the pernicious effects of informal patronage politics in Mexico's municipalities, but the strength of the book is its broad survey of the multiple factors that affect police reform and its analysis of how these factors operate in Mexico. As such, the book is a valuable vehicle for anyone seeking to understand the full range of challenges facing police reform.
Focused primarily on four metropolitan police departments in northern Mexico, the analysis is situated within a pressing security crisis, so Sabet offers an extraordinarily timely treatment of a topic of real-world importance, and includes a rich combination of personal interviews, original survey results extending beyond the four main cases, and archival evidence. Given his professional work promoting ‘culture of lawfulness’ reforms, Sabet also writes from a perspective informed by practical experience influencing institutional change.
The opening chapter offers an overview of policing in Mexico, organises theories of police reform into three main categories (individual, organisational and external explanations), and covers case selection. Chapter 2 examines factors internal to police organisations. Covering seven policy areas (selection criteria, training, salary and benefits, equipment, administrative and operational procedures, merit-based promotion systems and accountability mechanisms), Sabet finds progress in the first five and a lack of meaningful change in the last two. Chapters 3–7 examine external factors: municipal politics (chapter 3), organised crime (chapter 4), police–society interactions (chapter 5), civil society (chapter 6) and federal initiatives (chapter 7).
Sabet's organisation makes it easy for readers to go directly to the explanatory themes that interest them most. Readers most interested in the local, inter-branch and patron–client politics of reform should read chapter 3. Readers intrigued by the political incentives to confront, tolerate or collude with organised crime in Mexico can go directly to chapter 4. Chapters 5 and 6 should be read together by anyone interested in police–society relations. Chapter 5 introduces four areas of citizen action: compliance, co-production, support and accountability. It briefly describes general patterns in each area and proceeds to two main statistical analyses of tolerance of corruption and satisfaction with police. The daily participation of citizens in corruption and the need to alter cultural attitudes are strong themes here. Chapter 6 is an examination of citizen review boards and the potential for these bodies to become effective local mechanisms of accountability. Lastly, chapter 7 reviews the many federal initiatives to promote police reform, especially since 2008. This chapter should be most interesting to students of federalism and institutional change across levels of government.
Though helpful for identifying categories of explanatory factors, the book's organisation into thematic chapters makes the core argument regarding patronage politics harder to track, since evidence from the same reform processes in each of the cases is spread over various chapters. For example, Jorge Capella Ibarra appears in chapter 4 as a key, respected civic activist who becomes police chief (pp. 116, 120). Later, in chapter 6, we meet Capella Ibarra again and discover that he had been president of the local citizen security council before becoming police chief, and that counterintuitively, despite having a former council activist as police chief, the previously ascendant council became isolated politically and financially, and Ibarra may have been co-opted by the new administration (p. 177 n. 13). The fact that crucial events of the same reform process appear many pages or chapters apart generates a kind of fragmented, kaleidoscopic version of events across all the case studies. Without close process tracing, it is difficult to carefully consider the full trajectory of reform within each case, grasp the analytic and theoretic weight of events, and adjudicate among competing explanations.
Returning to the complexity of Sabet's argument, the multiple moving parts are evident across chapters 2–7. Further, Sabet mentions at least four other relevant factors: (1) foreign actors that can be leveraged to promote change (such as the accreditation group, CALEA); (2) local actors with national affiliates (such as chambers of commerce); (3) other criminal justice institutions who should advance parallel reforms that complement police (such as prosecutors, courts and prisons); and (4) the national policing model, which operates as a deep kind of legal-cultural frame, fundamentally shaping conceptualisations of the proper role of police within the broader criminal justice system and therefore of what is possible or appropriate in terms of changing the conditions, behaviour or expectations of police (see, for example, pp. 38, 46, 49, 52).
Sabet's complex account of police reform in Mexico is realistic and sobering, but this complexity need not hinder efforts to develop a more systematic theory of institutional development. His mention of research on ‘muddling through’ and ‘punctuated equilibri[a]’ (pp. 30, 231) hints at productive literatures that could be leveraged for this purpose. Other literatures that could yield theoretical insights include existing work on incrementalist notions of institutional change, such as Peter Hall's work on institutional learning involving shifts in policy paradigms, Kathleen Thelen's work on institutional layering and conversion, and Jacob Hacker's work on institutional drift.
Further, Sabet's multiple references to cultural or attitudinal factors include ‘attitudinal changes' (p. 93), ‘cultural attitudes’ and ‘legitimacy’ (pp. 150–1), ‘moral compass’ (p. 152), ‘culture of lawfulness’ (p. 160), ‘human agency’ (pp. 90, 165), ‘committed’ individuals and civil society (pp. 5, 172), ‘culture, habit, and custom’ (p. 231), and perhaps most strikingly, ‘highly committed individuals risk their lives and some lose them for the security of their city and the integrity of their beliefs’ (p. 5). The references to cultural-ideational factors suggest that attention to the causal role of ideas could add analytic insights. Ideational factors could help clarify what attributes characterise ‘reformist’ individuals (p. 104), the right ‘personality’ (p. 225) and ‘leadership’ (pp. 116, 221). Given that institutional insiders appear to be crucial to the three regional success stories of police reform – the United States, Chile and Colombia (pp. 220–1) – how can these insiders be identified or recruited? What are their ideational profiles? Avoiding the circularity of identifying reformists as those who pursue reforms, how do we know reformist insiders when we see them?
Overall, Sabet's book offers an in-depth, textured account of the challenges facing police reform in Mexico, and is a must-read for anyone concerned with improving public safety and security. The book should be appealing to a wide range of audiences interested in contemporary Mexico, the politics of public safety, and the difference between changing formal, de jure rules or institutions (reform in theory) and changing informal, de facto institutions (reform in practice). Sabet's analysis resonates well beyond Mexico and policing, complementing broader conversations on state-building and the construction of stronger democratic institutions.
