In the last few years there have been a number of publications that have changed the approach to the study of criminality. Carlos Aguirre, Pablo Piccato, Sarah Chambers and Arlene Díaz are some of the scholars who have raised new questions and brought new perspectives to the study of the administration of justice in Latin America. This list cannot be completed without taking into account Ricardo Salvatore's work on justice and rights, leading over the years to a rich and extremely valuable body of scholarship for those interested in these subjects. This volume updates previously known material written over the last 15 years, bringing it together in a way that showcases the magnitude and importance of Salvatore's contributions.
The book begins with a clear and relevant introduction that guides us through the path that led to its creation. The particular blend of ideas taken from the work of Michel Foucault, E. P. Thompson, Norbert Elias, and subaltern studies helps us to understand the foundation of Salvatore's research, and his desire to bring the question of the subaltern to the understanding of the process of state formation and the problems of representation in the legal system. But the introduction is not only helpful in identifying the author's intentions; it is also an excellent introduction to the world of possibilities that researching the interactions between subaltern subjects and legal institutions can bring to scholars. After reading this book it is all the more evident how important Salvatore's approach is to addressing questions about gender and the formation of modern identities, for example. In that sense, this book works both as concrete evidence of the important renewal that has been taking place in the study of the legal system, and as a promising glimpse at work still to come.
The book covers the history of Argentina from 1829 to 1940, the period both of a transformation of the way in which justice was administered, and of the emergence of the state and its prisons as the institutions that articulated a civilised way to administer punishment. One of the characteristics of Salvatore's craft is his careful and detailed work with sources, some of them previously unanalysed, and his precise investigation of the materials available. This is particularly evident in the chapters dealing with the first half of the nineteenth century, which are full of references to interesting and compelling documentation. For example, his claim that labour markets were much more mobile and autonomous than is traditionally understood is quite important, especially as it is based on evidence concerning different subaltern practices that supported fundamental individual and civil liberties. Most significantly, there is an important way in which this topic is connected with race and with how slaves searched for justice and understood their rights.
The chapters dealing with the positivists and science are sometimes less effective, mostly because there is no account of the chaotic state of science by the end of the nineteenth century, the emergence of new fields of study, and the debates about Herbert Spencer's ideas and the nature of evolution. The evolutionary logic that was dominant at the time in the legal profession explains the selective system of punishment that treated some prisoners well and others as expendable. This was not merely a matter of returning to colonial policies, as Salvatore claims, but also of the crucial determination of who had evolutionary potential and who did not. In this sense the new evolutionary logic was closer to some of Rosas' ideas than those of his enemies, as some had discovered to their surprise by the end of the nineteenth century.
Since Salvatore is so engaged in subaltern studies this book might attract criticism among those who disagree with this approach. There have been many debates on the uses of subaltern studies in the study of Latin America. One of the many criticisms is the size of the umbrella created by the term ‘subaltern’ and the lack of a proper differentiation among the realities of those grouped under such terms. In the case of this book this appears as a problem in the analysis of scientific views, and of the application of positivist ideas to the study of crime. If we pay attention to the reception of the racist science that branded the inhabitants of uncivilised areas as inferior, regardless of the social position and power they might enjoy, we can see that certain ideas affected a larger group than the subalterns studied by Salvatore. The members of the elite themselves were placed under suspicion of deficient evolutionary potential. They might not have been seen as criminals, but certainly many of them painfully felt their inferiority, and saw themselves as at risk of returning to an uncivilised and primal state, as many texts of Octavio Bunge show, for example. Salvatore's emphasis on economic conditions and on the need to develop a productive workforce is well argued, and important, but it is not the whole story. Racial categories also implied the inferiority of those in power, which helps explain why the state emerged as a neutral apparatus of observation and classification, geared toward creating a better population for the future. The evolution of the country depended on the effective selection of the individuals who would triumph in the struggle for life, and the culling of those who allegedly had not been favoured by nature.
My comment does not question Salvatore's conclusions, but implies that there are even more connections to be explored with respect to the complexity of subaltern identities as articulated in scientific terms. Such an approach would not be opposed to the essays gathered in this volume, but would help us to understand in more detail the nature of subaltern categories by the end of the nineteenth century. Finally, this book is indispensable reading for those interested in the history of Argentina. Even those who distrust subaltern studies will find it unrelentingly fascinating, and a first-rate collection of research that raises important questions about state formation and the emergence of a modern legal system.
