Benjamin Poore's The Contemporary History Play: Staging English and American Pasts is an ambitious and engaging study of the contemporary history play. In it, Poore argues that the genre has changed considerably in recent years as contemporary playwrights engage with the various forms of historical representation prevalent in the twenty-first century and adopt aesthetic approaches that are increasingly complex and elaborate. This book, published in 2024 as a part of the Methuen Drama Engage series, seems to rebut mainstream critical thinking with original and interdisciplinary perspectives on history plays.
The introductory chapter challenges the conventional and rather limited understanding of a history play, proposing this definition: “any play that states or indicates that it is set in the past, whatever its genre or mode, is a history play” (1). This broader definition allows for a more inclusive interpretation of history plays, encompassing works that explore historical themes innovatively rather than adhering strictly to traditional forms. Besides the Introduction, the book comprises four main chapters and a coda. In the first chapter, “History versus Dramaturgy,” Poore discusses the theoretical frameworks driving the study of history plays. He contrasts conventional dramaturgical approaches with innovative, more interdisciplinary ones. The latter involve such elements as the inclusion of the visual arts, music, or multimedia elements in the representation. Poore thinks that these new forms of representation reflect a more general cultural obsession with history within the frameworks determined by the media, education, and politics. This chapter is pivotal, as it introduces key theoretical concepts and contextualizes the evolution of the history play as a genre. It also serves as a lens through which the rest of the analysis of the book can be understood.
The next chapter is “The Bibliographical History Play,” which covers plays dealing with the lives of historical figures. Through various plays such as Morgan Lloyd Malcolm's Emilia and Charlie Josephine's I, Joan, Poore discusses the challenges of portraying real-life individuals onstage, including the ethical considerations and artistic liberties often taken with dramatic portrayals. He interrogates how these plays reconcile historical fact and creative interpretation. Poore explores how these plays navigate the tension between historical accuracy and creative interpretation by blending fact with fiction to offer new insights or highlight specific aspects of the characters’ lives.
Entitled “The Intergenerational History Play,” Chapter 3 focuses on a particular type of history play that works its way across generations, depicting historical events through family and generational conflict. Plays such as Richard Bean's Harvest and Samuel Adamson's Wife supply the basic examples for illustrating the ways in which intergenerational conflicts foreground historical and political themes. Poore elucidates how these plays often reflect larger sociopolitical narratives and national identities. He remarks that the genre is often used to point out national decline, with members of a family symbolizing the friction facing nations during periods of rupture due to internal and external forces.
In the fourth chapter, “Polychronic History Plays,” Poore explores plays that intertwine multiple timelines and historical periods. He introduces the term polychronic to describe “any history play that takes place in two or more distinct periods of time, extending beyond a single human lifespan” (153). This genre enables the playwright to compare the past and present events, both of which provide a deeply panoramic view of history. Poore's discussion involves plays such as Alexi Kaye Campbell's The Pride and Winsome Pinnock's Rockets and Blue Lights, both of which put polychronic structures in action in the name of complicating historical stories and motivating active historical interpretation.
The book concludes with a Coda, “Alternate and Fantastic Histories,” in which Poore explores speculative and counterfactual history plays. This is another section that underlies Poore's conviction about how fluid and generous the history play can be as a category. Works he discusses, including Alistair McDowall's The Glow and Anne Washburn's Mr. Burns, highlight the creative possibilities of reimagining historical events and the genre.
One of the real strengths of Poore's work lies in his ability to synthesize a wide range of contemporary plays and theoretical perspectives. He does not merely categorize and describe the plays but offers a detailed analysis of their thematic and dramaturgical complexities. In this sense, his approach is interdisciplinary and comparative, with examples from English and American theatre supporting his argument. The interdisciplinary approach taken by Poore proves especially effective in showing how these plays do more than simply reflect historical events. Instead, they are engaging in current issues of society and politics. He draws on theatre history, literary criticism, and performance studies to build his arguments. This approach creates a multidimensional analysis that deepens our understanding of contemporary history plays.
Another notable aspect of Poore's analysis is his focus on the aesthetic strategies that contemporary playwrights use to represent history. He discusses how techniques such as nonlinear narratives, fragmented structures, and metatheatrical devices serve to complicate and enrich the audience's understanding of historical events. The emphasis on form as well as content is a crucial aspect of Poore's argument that contemporary history plays are becoming increasingly sophisticated and layered in their approach to historical representation. Poore's interdisciplinary approach highlights the interconnectedness of theatre with other forms of cultural production. His analysis underscores the importance of considering plays within their broader cultural and political contexts, offering a more holistic understanding of how theatre engages with history.
The Contemporary History Play: Staging English and American Pasts is a crucial text for scholars and students of theatre, as well as for playwrights interested in the interplay between history and drama. Poore's thorough and insightful analysis provides a valuable framework for understanding how contemporary theatre engages with historical narratives. He broadens the definition of what constitutes a history play and highlights the innovative techniques used by contemporary playwrights. This approach provides a fresh and compelling perspective on a dynamic and evolving genre while challenging conventional critical paradigms and opening new avenues for exploration and analysis. This book will undoubtedly inspire further research and creative experimentation in the field of history plays.
