Memory and Violence in the Middle East and North Africa is the product of a workshop held at Rice University in 2001. The book attempts to fill the significant gap in research on memory in the Middle East, but the overrepresentation of a few countries and lack of discussion on most others constitutes a major shortcoming. The volume includes four chapters on Palestine/Israel, two on Algeria, and two on Lebanon. Although it frames the historical discussion in terms of colonialism, it surprisingly omits the Ottoman Empire, whose dominion over the area lasted until the end of World War I. An issue common to edited books based on conferences—the question of whether the separate papers justify their inclusion in a volume—also applies to this one. While most of the chapters deal with issues of memory, violence, and reconciliation, there is an imbalance in terms of the contribution the different chapters make to the topic. Another shortcoming of the book, which is possibly related to the time involved in producing edited volumes from conferences, is that the material is somewhat dated. The analyses of the authors tend to pertain to contexts that had in many cases changed by the time of publication.
The first part of the book, “Violence and Sacrifice,” includes chapters by Glenn Bowman on a Palestinian community, James McDougall on Algeria, and Yael Zerubavel on Israel. Discussing the murder of a Christian Palestinian by a fellow Palestinian in 1981, Bowman suggests that the meaning of this death changed with the rapidly changing political context of Palestine/Israel. He argues that the case demonstrates the solidarity of the Palestinian community during the first intifada and its increasing fragmentation following the Oslo agreement. However, the author seems unable to account for the forgetting of the murder despite increased tension between Palestinians and Israel in recent years. As in many chapters of this book, the fact that the author discusses events only up to the early 2000s prevents the inclusion of important recent developments that changed the political context. In the second chapter, James McDougall argues that violence in general and martyrdom in particular were normalized during the struggle for Algerian independence (1954–62) through recourse to a historical narrative that opposed Islamic and Christian civilizations. Similarly, Zerubavel argues that the Zionist narrative normalized violence and sacrifice for the nation from 1948 until the 1980s. She shows how Jewish history and legend were used as a means of buttressing this notion of sacrifice.
The second part of the book, “Resolution and Reconciliation,” includes chapters by Shira Robinson on a Palestinian community, Anja Peleikis on Lebanon, and Benjamin Stora on Algeria. Robinson discusses the commemoration of a massacre of Palestinians in 1956, showing how Palestinians’ subsequent commemoration of the event challenged its official silencing. Peleikis illustrates how the experience of the Lebanese Civil War resulted in differential memories of the past by members of confessional groups. At the same time, the chapter suggests that the war has been silenced in official Lebanese historiography and the public sphere. Benjamin Stora demonstrates the limitations of the colonial categories “Middle East” and “North Africa” and of the nation through an astute analysis of the way the history and memory of “French Algeria” and the Algerian war shapes contemporary French national identity, domestic politics, and immigration policy. Stora suggests that the history of the Algerian war was officially erased in France until recently, while its memory continues to haunt the different and divided groups whose contemporary identities have been largely shaped by it (whether through firsthand experience or transmitted in the form of postmemory). Stora's study contributes to an understanding of the deep roots of racism, which shape the attitude of many European countries toward immigration and the expansion of the European Union.
Part III, “Archaeology of Memory,” includes articles by Gabriel Piterberg and Nadia Abu El-Haj on Israel and by Saree Makdisi on Lebanon. Piterberg insightfully discusses the abstract language of the state in Israel that justified and made more palatable the expulsion of Palestinians. In his view, an important means of erasing history and ensuring forgetfulness was the destruction of all signs of Arab Palestine from the landscape. Piterberg also uses the case of the transfer of Yemeni Jews in 1930 from their places of settlement to exemplify discrimination against “Oriental” Jews in Israel. However, he argues that their very status in Israeli society results in the internalization of the hegemonic narrative by such groups. Saree Makdisi discusses the silencing of the civil war in the official histories of Lebanon. He argues that the reconstruction of central Beirut that began in the mid-1990s constitutes the erasure of memory through the manipulation of space. According to the author, a historical narrative of the civil war is replaced by fragmented images, which make it possible to avoid facing an experience Lebanese prefer to forget.
Nadia Abu El-Haj approaches history and memory through a detailed analysis of the institutionalization of the field of archaeology in Israel. She shows how archaeology was used as a means of inculcating belief in the notion of the return of the Jews to their homeland. Of most importance, she shows how archaeology functioned to ensure that the Jewish population normalized what in fact was a meticulously constructed notion of belonging to the land. It is odd, however, that in discussing the imposition of a Jewish historical narrative upon the landscape of Palestine, El-Haj makes no reference to the seminal work of Maurice Halbwachs, On Collective Memory, about the transformation of this space into the “Holy Land” in Christian tradition. While some chapters in this volume (such as those by McDougall, Stora, and El-Haj) stand out in terms of their contribution to the study of memory in particular societies, it is difficult to conclude that the book contributes to the theoretical literature on memory studies. This volume will be of particular interest to scholars working on Palestine/Israel, Algeria, and Lebanon and may be useful in courses in Middle Eastern studies.
