The central question addressed in Lattouf's historic overview of women's education in the Middle East is why improvements in women's education have not led to concomitant increases in women's status and well-being. Importantly, the book demonstrates that although there is a perception that women in Lebanon have many more rights and opportunities than their counterparts throughout the region, Lebanese women remain subordinate to men. In the process of developing this thesis, Lattouf explores the relative degrees to which formal and informal education shape women's lives. Formal education in this analysis includes state and private systems of schooling that have gradually opened up for women and girls. Informal education, on the other hand, is taken to encompass all other processes of socialization and cultural learning. A nod to the theoretical work of Foucault helps frame the conceptualization of socialization, education, and power, although the book focuses on describing women's experience rather than attempting to reframe or develop theories of power, gender identity, or cultural sociology per se. In the end, Lattouf concludes, informal education, specifically socialization into the relatively narrow roles of wife and mother, overpowers the effects of education in broadening women's participation in politics, society, and the economy.
The data for Lattouf's analysis come from ten months of research conducted in the mid- 1990s. The book combines select quotes from informal, nonsystematic interviews, review of historic documents, reference to limited statistical data, and frequent citations gleaned from al-Raida, a newsletter published by the Institute for the Study of Women in the Arab World, located at Beirut University College (renamed Lebanese American University in 1994).
Because data on religious affiliation have not been available since the Lebanese War, Lattouf is unable to assess differences in the ways particular religious ideologies help to define and circumscribe women's lives. Rather, religion is conceptualized as generically patriarchal with cursory allusion to core texts and acknowledgment that much could be done by feminists to reclaim the pro-womanist elements of their respective traditions. For an in-depth analysis of feminist movements within and outside of the region's religious traditions, scholars and students should look elsewhere. Lattouf is also careful to point out the limited availability of reliable statistical data on both employment and education.
In spite of these data limitations, her monograph provides an interesting overview of the growth and development of women's education in Lebanon as well as the region in general. This historical review is the real strength of the book. Lack of a larger sample of systematic interviews or survey data make it difficult for Lattouf to provide a more rigorous test of her hypothesis or explore more specific ways in which religious or community subcultural emphases on the importance of wives and mothers undermine what are expected to be the liberating effects of formal education. Some points seem overstated—for example, claiming that women have no voice in politics or that the economic system exaggerates the limited number of women in government office and family business. This is not to suggest that these fields are not restricted or that more could be done to open opportunities or give more weight to women's voices in all fields. Nevertheless, such statements weaken the credibility of the overall point that women's public participation has not kept pace with their access to education. It would also be helpful to learn more about how women are able to cautiously reinterpret religious texts or become involved in developing new interpretations of life and roles not based on biology. The existence of the women's studies program suggests that for some women, at least, there are active outspoken advocates of broadening opportunities for women beyond the roles of wife and mother.
Overall, Lattouf provides a fine overview of the history of women's education in Lebanon during the transition from Ottoman Empire through independence and rebuilding after the civil war. Perhaps most importantly, it points to a number of significant questions, such as the importance of attending to political structures as well as local culture (particularly religious and family culture) in shaping gender ideals. In addition, Lattouf's analysis underlines the ongoing frustration of women in the region with persistent sexism (e.g., biases that women are not as trustworthy as men, that they are not committed employees, that women's work is not “real” work). Also important are the connections between rhetoric mobilized around themes of national stability and crises that have the unintended consequences of undermining pro-women legislation. Attention to variations in women's educational and life experiences across class (such as access to public, private, or vocational training) would also be helpful in advancing a new generation of theorizing the intersections of ideology, agency, and personal resources within the Middle East.
