This important volume is the published outcome of a conference held at the University of Texas at Austin in 2003. As one would expect from the capable editorship of Patrick Olivelle, the book is a landmark contribution to the study of early Indian history and culture. The work has a commendable focus – unlike the published proceedings of many conferences – and addresses the period ‘between the empires’, that is the centuries between the Mauryan period and the rise of the imperial Guptas. The list of contributors includes Dilip Chakrabarti, J. Mark Kenoyer, Frederick Asher, Himanshu Ray, Shailendra Bhandare, Harry Falk, Patrick Olivelle, Stephanie Jamison, Madhav Deshpande, Alf Hiltebeitel, James L. Fitzgerald, Johannes Bronkhorst, Gregory Schopen, Richard Salomon, Paul Dundas, Aloka Parasher-Sen and Michael Witzel. As will be evident to anyone who has worked on ancient India, this is a list of ‘major players’ in the archaeological and cultural history of South Asia. With the sole exception of Bhandare, all the contributors are senior scholars, doyens at the peak who, based on long research experience, have formed and consolidated their particular vision of Indian civilisation. Regardless of what one might think of the individual results, Between the Empires presents much that is new and will be essential reading for anyone working on the years between 300 bce and 300 ce.
This six hundred year period – if we can call such a long span of time ‘a period’ – was marked by crucial developments in religious ideas, iconography, numismatics and textual formation. I suppose we should expect nothing less in six centuries. It is of course a provocative misnomer to describe this whole time as ‘between empires’. Aside from the kind of polity implied by the word ‘empire’ – a problem in itself – the Kuṣāṇa kingdom, which stretched from the edges of Bihar to central Asia was a trans-national and trans-regional political formation of immense scale. The Kuṣāṇas are mentioned in several places in the volume and contributed much to the early Gupta state, but there is no separate article on them. Of course one cannot have everything in one book and the editor notes some of the gaps in the preface (p. vi). I suppose the most notable gap is the also most difficult: there is no study of Manu or the Arthaśāstra, works composed, it is generally agreed, in or slightly after the second century ce. Both are of utmost importance for the later history of India. Until the date of these deliberately anachronistic texts is settled there cannot be much progress. The authors who composed these texts did not sit down and write free-standing works in a vacuum, unrelated to the political and social circumstances of their time. I think they must have been written for a patron, that is a king who had clear and ambitious ideas about the kind of state – or indeed empire – he hoped to achieve.
Whatever we finally decide about Manu and the Arthaśāstra, in this volume the problem of textual formation ‘between the empires’ is dealt with in Olivelle's essay “Explorations in the Early History of Dharmśāstra”. This is a detailed and informative study of the term dharma and the texts which flowed from the exploration of that concept. Olivelle notes (following Pollock, see p. 188) that ancient writers, under the influence of Mīmāṃsa, deliberately excluded reference to the lived reality of their times. The sūtra-literature defies chronological definition because the texts, in the words of Jan Gonda, “deal solely with country or village life. Of the social and political conditions they contain almost nothing” (Gonda, Ritual Sūtras, p. 623). In actual fact, the world of the sūtras is consciously ahistorical and circumscribed. The texts appear timeless because their compilers had turned their backs on the urban centres and international economic networks of Buddhism and early historic India. We cannot really deal with these texts historically unless we look outside the texts, a difficult task because gaining intellectual control of the corpus is a life's work in itself. Still, progress is being made towards an understanding of the historical footing of many early Sanskrit works. In this volume an important contribution in this area is James Fitzgerald's study of the compilation and dating of the Mahābhārata in his “Negotiating the Shape of ‘Scripture:’ New Perspective on the Development and Growth of the Mahābhārata between the Empires”. His view (notably pp. 270–272 and 276) of the epic as a vision of reality as the personal deity Viṣṇu Nārāyaṇa supporting royal action after the example of Viṣṇu Kṛṣṇa is well taken. For the historian the only problem with Fitzgerald's exemplary study is that if the present Mahābhārata (as recovered in the critical edition) dates to the fourth or fifth century and if the Kuṣāṇa-period epic was different (as we know from the Spitzer MS in Berlin), then it becomes difficult to understand (or indeed accept) why or how redactors working in Gupta times would have carried forward an “anti-Mauryan or anti-Aśokan” agenda (see pp. 259, 276). Fitzgerald offers virtually no extra-textual historical data for his analysis which is surprising given that the post-Mauryan period is far from an archaelogical and historical blank. In fact his “complex process of negotiation between some members of the brahmin elite of northern India and the putative new brāhmaṇya kṣatra whom those brahmins wished to coax into a mutually beneficial existence through invoking the ‘Great’ Bhārata,” (see p. 258) is a fitting description of the early Gupta period. Of course we could not make observations of this kind without Fitzgerald's penetrating analysis which, necessarily, will be the basis for future work. Fitzgerald's contribution is just one of many stimulating essays in this volume and, for want of space, not all can be commented on here. There can be little doubt, however, that historians will be discussing the many ideas this book contains for many years come.
