The poet-cardinal Pietro Bembo (1470–1547) is often overshadowed by his literary and philosophical predecessors, Boccaccio and Petrarch. Nevertheless, Bembo was a seminal figure in Italian Humanism whose manifold accomplishments deserve independent recognition. After all, the man systematically codified Italian in his Prose della volgar lingua or ‘Discussions of the Vernacular Language’ (1525) whilst conducting a torrid affair with Lucrezia Borgia and catalysing the invention of the madrigal. He also masterfully wrote his way through diverse literary genres, in both verse (Rime, 1530) and prose (Historia Veneta, 1551). Happily, therefore, two volumes discussed in this review redirect the spotlight towards Bembo by discussing his artistic and literary pursuits.
Susan Nalezyty has provided an accessible and beautifully-illustrated celebration of Renaissance material culture. The volume's key aim is to reconstruct Bembo's art collection and outline how he assembled and displayed it. N. bases this reconstruction not only on Bembo's famed epistles, but also on hitherto unpublished archival material and the accounts of visitors to the collection. These sources come to life in N.’s hands: drawing on her comprehensive curatorial experience, she delivers a seamlessly integrated book introducing Pietro Bembo through his famed art collection.
N.’s first chapter (5–30) orientates the reader by providing a clear biography of Bembo and outlining the key challenges faced by Renaissance art collectors, including falsi (‘modern fakes’, 11) and a precarious ‘gift economy’ based on patronage networks (21). N. demonstrates that Bembo successfully navigated his way through these obstacles by employing his poetic instincts and Classical learning. As a result, he found himself at leisure to enjoy true otium within his coterie of aristocratic art-lovers: ‘We laugh, joke, play, eat, study, and even sometimes compose’ (27 on Bembo, Lett. I.262).
This languid lifestyle was nevertheless overshadowed by the complex tie which linked Bembo with his father. Unlike Williams’ tome, which focuses on the tensions between father and son, N. describes the heart-warming aspects of their relationship in her second chapter (31–67). She credits Bernardo with his son's artistic development by noting how the pair often travelled together on diplomatic missions, during which the young Pietro was exposed to a brilliant variety of artists and patrons. She also reveals their lifelong bond through shared manuscripts and paintings. Readers will want to balance this narrative with W.’s discussion of the contrasting attitudes that occasioned conflict between the Bembos.
Ch. 3 (69–101) explores Bembo's personal relationships through his paintings. It concentrates on a small group of sixty-four portraits which constitute a mere third of his stockpile. Nevertheless, these pieces are bound by a cogent theme in that they all depict Bembo's nearest and dearest and thus introduce the social fabric behind Bembo's collection. Here N. describes how Bembo was frequently disappointed in his son Torquato (70–1) and constantly concerned about the marriage prospects of Elena, his precocious daughter (73–4). She also showcases the engraved copy of a lost painting which Titian painted of Elisabetta Querini, Bembo's close friend, and interprets its cryptic motifs: the sitter's painted hands, for example, connote intimacy since they have been stripped of their gloves (99). The following chapter (104–42) primarily discusses the acquisition and display of antiques in the Bembo collection. N. identifies some of Bembo's Roman coins and cameos as counterfeits (111–20). Moreover, she highlights his penchant for neoclassical art (120–8) and examines the mythological motifs of which he was especially fond (128–32). Here N.’s theoretical discussion of visuality (132–42) stands out as an adept introduction to the interplay between image and text.
The final chapter (143–82) describes the various places in which Bembo showed his collection and highlights how visitors responded to this display. It emphasises the deliberate and effective way in which Bembo decorated his multiple residences, including the Villa Bozza near Padua and his city townhouse in Padua, and features several objets d'art from these domestic locations. N. also discusses how Bembo's treasures inspired the output of visiting artists such as the sculptor Jacopo Sansovino and the medallist Valerio Belli (167–82). The volume ends with two useful appendices: a catalogue of object descriptions and a chronology of accounts describing the Bembo collection. N. provides a well-researched, well-written and fascinating (though necessarily selective) contribution to scholarship on Bembo which impresses with its focused scope and accessible tone.
In contrast to N., Gareth D. Williams’ volume provides a literary focus. His rigorous analysis takes Bembo's 1496 dialogue De Aetna (‘On Mount Etna’) as its starting-point. In this dialogue, Bembo relates Classical accounts of Etna to his father-interlocutor along with his own experience of climbing the mountain. As the Introduction highlights (1–21), however, this mountaineering narrative is but a metaphor for Bembo's life. His unconventional career path is mirrored by his unique determination to climb a volcano, his Humanist interests manifest themselves in the Classicising language which features in the mountain's description, and the locus horridus of Etna is but a canvas upon which Bembo paints a reflection of his own character.
Accordingly, W. maps out his approach to Bembo's life by investigating the three key elements of the De Aetna, namely Mount Etna, Humanism and introspective landscape writing. The first chapter (23–71) comprehensively addresses ‘The Etna Idea’ by exploring intertextual descriptions of the mountain from Pindar to Ovid. In the following chapter, ‘From Memory to Modernity’ (73–112), W. builds upon this catalogue of precedents by examining the Classical motif of mnemonic topography. He discusses ancient models for Bembo's figurative journey, such as Aeneas’ visit to Pallantium (Verg., Aen. 8), and cleverly links spatiality in the De Aetna to Ovidian and Propertian elegy. Having taken care to ground Bembo's work in Classical geopoetics, W. devotes the latter part of ch. 2 to antiquarian travel in the Renaissance and the rise of Humanist thought. Eschewing theocentric explanations of natural phenomena, Bembo instead adopts naturalist interpretations when describing Etna on the edge of eruption.
W. anticipates the reader's next question, ‘How did Bembo become a Humanist?’, in ch. 3 (113–45), which traces Bembo's education ‘From Venice to Sicily’. Rather than delivering a dry list of Bembo's tutors, however, W. instead deftly frames the biographical material as part of wider Turgenevian tensions between Bernardo the father and Pietro the son. The former fulfilled his patrician duties by serving Venice as a statesman and ambassador, while the latter confounded the expectations of the gens Bembina by evading public life for the sake of scholarship. This latent drama continues in the following chapter (147–82), which zooms in on Bembo's Humanist acquaintances, ranging from Ermolao Barbaro to Angelo Gabriele, and discusses his vernacular works such as the Gli Asolani (‘The People of Asolo’), three dialogues on love which owe as much to Petrarch as they do to Plato. Ch. 5 (184–220) is an interlude which centres upon early printing in Venice. Although W. anticipates accusations of digression by stating that scholars have so far failed to recognise ‘De Aetna’s importance in the history of the printed book’ (184), large parts of this chapter will appeal only to Aldine Press enthusiasts. Nevertheless, W. makes a strong effort to link this segment to his wider narrative by discussing, as N. does, the Bembos’ shared interest in the interplay between text and image. In so doing, he highlights the role of artistic endeavours as a rare point of cohesion between father and son.
This concord gives way once more to intergenerational strain in the following chapter (221–67). W. explains how tensions between father and son spill into the landscape descriptions of the De Aetna, where their reactions to the natural scenery reveal their clashing outlooks. Pietro Bembo, who possesses the soul of a poet and the mind of a Humanist, sees something mirum (‘remarkable’) in the eternal ebb and flow of the volcano; Bernardo is less impressed, remarking that his son's observation is not at all mirum (222–3, on De Aetna 38). W. rationalises these contrasting views through the lens of villa culture in Renaissance Venice. He makes a convincing case that Bernardo, whose experience of nature is limited to carefully tended gardens, is unable to comprehend the sublimity which Pietro, having spent a good part of his childhood in rural Noniano, experiences during his ascent of wild Etna. The chapter also discusses the subversive hexameters which the younger Bembo wrote in boyhood to chastise his father for transporting him out of his countryside home. These rebellious undertones, which burst forth in the De Aetna despite being couched in Classical allusions, highlight the universal themes of Bembo's work, which charts the eternal battles of otium against negotium and gravitas against lusus. W. ends his volume with a well-written chapter (269–306) which provides an intimate glimpse into the relationship between Bembo's art collection and the De Aetna. A text and translation of de Aetna (307–53) follows, along with a comprehensive bibliography (353–416) and Greek and Latin indices (417–19). Sixteen beautiful colour plates crown W.'s incisive tour-de-force.
W.’s volume is a carefully-crafted delight which interweaves rigorous scholarship on the Classical intertexts and Humanist influences of Bembo's De Aetna with a beautiful thread detailing the painfully human relationship between Bembo father and son.
Few readers of this journal will wonder why one should read Latin literature or indeed Neo-Latin at all, but most will be aware that convincing others of the joys of Latin can be a challenge. Jakob Balde's Expeditio Polemico-Poetica (1664) thematises this struggle in its first part entitled Castrum: learned Renaissance men attempt to sack the castrum Ignorantiae and enlist the help of the Latin poets of old. Many of us — and those teaching in particular — might have a good idea where said castrum might be located, be it in the back of a classroom well-shielded by iPhones or in a specific corner of the library. Balde, however, situates it in an imaginary borderland between Arcadia and Boeotia whose inhabitants had the reputation of simple-mindedness (18). The second part, called Elenchus, consists of a register of 489 argumenta or themata, often in the form of aphorisms which Balde recommends to young, enthusiastic and gifted readers. Indeed, this Alterswerk of the Jesuit Jakob Balde (1604–1668), one of Germany's most important Neo-Latin poets, is clearly meant for the learned and constitutes advanced (German) humour — in Latin (17).
Balde has found his perfect reader in Eckard Lefèvre, who after a lifetime of propping up Western culture has dedicated himself to editing, translating and commenting on Balde's works. His edition provides a detailed introduction setting the Castrum, and the Elenchus with which it is paired, into their educational context and places them side by side with Balde's other didactic works (1–8). L. then illuminates the various prefaces, dedications and epilogues to both works (8–14) before discussing aspects such as originality and satire (14–17), content (17–24 for Castrum and 25–48 for Elenchus), form (49–52), reception (59–66), and finally textual matters (67–71: there are in total three editions of the work, published in 1664, 1726 and 1729; L. lists and compares the errata). Two brief appendices to the introduction deal with the role of Greek literature in Balde's work and compare the figure of the hunter in his Sylvae 1 (edited by L. in 2011) to that in the Castrum (72–4). This is followed by a Latin text with facing translation of the Castrum (76–155), a detailed interpretation (159–233) and finally the Elenchus (235–356), where translation and commentary follow each Latin argumentum. Jesuits needed to gain permission to publish from their superiors and L. even includes the two seventeenth-century readers’ reports (censurae) which have survived to the present day (357–69). A bibliography, the brevitas of which demonstrates the neglected status of Balde's oeuvre, concludes the volume (371–5). Importantly, so L. points out, for Balde ignorantia constitutes not simply ‘ignorance’ but rather the ‘ignoring’ by critics of the work of the Renaissance poets and the intellectual movement in which they partake. The Renaissance poets thus literally call upon the poets of old, Catullus, Claudian, Ennius, Horace, Juvenal, Lucan, Lucretius, Martial, Ovid, Persius, Plautus, Propertius, Seneca, Silius Italicus, Statius, Terence, Tibullus and, above all, Virgil for help, all of whom are introduced and characterised with their respective strengths and weaknesses. This manifests the cultural conflict and simultaneously explains why these poets deserve to serve as exempla in the first place. The learned reader greatly enjoys the irony with which Balde assigns a place and activity to each poet (often in accordance with the genre in which they work or simply by personal preference) and imitates them in style and content. Occasionally this game becomes so learned that — particularly in the aphoristic Elenchus — even the advanced reader will gratefully seek refuge in L.’s explicative notes. L. certainly has done Balde proud.
