In The Arab Public Sphere in Israel, Amal Jamal analyzes the theoretically interesting and practically important question of how Palestinian citizens of Israel locate themselves in terms of Hebrew-language Israeli media, locally produced Palestinian media, and Arab media. Many studies on Palestinian Israelis portray them as doubly marginalized in terms of their place both within Israeli society and in the Arab world, but Jamal cogently argues that their in-betweenness is instead a potential resource because they are bilingual and accustomed to critically reading media from several different sources. Drawing on W. E. B. DuBois, Jamal finds that they have a kind of double consciousness, serving their “rational and instrumental” (p. 131) needs through Israeli media while cultivating an affective relationship with Arab media. This foundational study opens the door to much future research on media and Palestinians.
The first half of the book presents a literature review on minority media worldwide as well as a history of Palestinian Israelis’ engagement with media from the decades of harsh Israeli restrictions on media production between 1948 and 1966 until the relatively more tolerant atmosphere of today. The Israeli legal environment is much more favorable for private media than in the past, and some Palestinian entrepreneurs have taken advantage of this, but Israel still lacks state support for Palestinian-produced media despite its strong state-broadcasting system. The burgeoning of Palestinian media inside Israel includes the development of party newspapers with rather low circulation and Arabic-language weekly commercial newspapers that are distributed for free and are more widely read. The other major change in the media landscape has been the flourishing of Arab satellite television, a rich source for news and entertainment that, for most Palestinian Israelis, overshadows newspapers in importance.
The second half of the book presents data from surveys and focus groups carried out by the author—primarily a large survey on media consumption habits using a sample of all Palestinian citizens of Israel and a smaller one that asked the same questions to a group restricted to Palestinian elites—that show readers are not likely to place full trust in the commercial weeklies, and these newspapers are not likely to present in-depth coverage of issues of great concern to Palestinians, such as home demolitions. According to the data, Palestinians instead place a high degree of trust in satellite television. A majority of Jamal's respondents report feeling that Arab satellite television represents them. The author does not delve into the limitations a transnational station faces in covering a minority community such as Palestinian Israelis, though he briefly acknowledges that issues of concern to the latter are “not adequately represented” by Arab media (p. 132). These findings raise a number of questions. Amidst all of the other regional and international news, how much coverage can the concerns of Palestinians inside Israel receive from Arab satellite television? Can local media build on satellite television coverage in any way? A content analysis of news coverage might be illuminating in this regard.
One important contribution this book makes is to demonstrate that the globalization of media is a topic that must be addressed through myriad localized studies. Although much has been written about Al-Jazeera's “effects” on authoritarian regimes in the Arab world, its influence on a minority community such as this one is understudied. In contrast to other minorities around the world who speak a language other than the dominant one in their country, Palestinian Israelis have the advantage of speaking a language with a prodigious presence in global media. If, as Jamal demonstrates, they were profoundly isolated from 1948 to 1966, when legal and technological strictures prohibited them from consuming much media from neighboring Arab states (with the exception of the Egyptian Sawt al-Arab and a handful of other radio broadcasts), this has changed dramatically in the age of satellite television.
In a compelling chapter on Israeli media policies toward Palestinian Israelis, Jamal comments that “many Palestinians in Israel wanted to maintain the two worlds—the old Palestinian and the new Israeli—simultaneously” (p. 54). His language of “old” and “new” (as well as quotes from Palestinian Israeli poetry written for Israeli Independence Day) suggests we might not draw so stark a divide between a rational and practical affiliation with Israeli media and an affective and cultural relationship to Arab media and that the connection to Israeli media can also have an affective dimension. Perhaps in the early decades of the Israeli state, Israel indexed the new and the modern even for members of a minority community it suppressed. Now that the Arab world has developed tens of satellite stations, we might ask whether this divide is as clear today in the imaginations of Palestinian Israelis and what new meanings are associated with Hebrew-language and Arabic-language media.
This book also raises questions about what constitutes a “counter public” and what such resistant publics can do. In his conclusion, Jamal characterizes this minority media as a “counter public sphere that challenges the dominant majority public sphere” (p. 129). Yet active challenges posed by this counter public sphere—instances when, for example, media consumption has led to political organizing or social change—are difficult to identify. Is it a challenge to the dominant public sphere just to consume news that voices a different set of opinions if nothing comes of this politically? Jamal seems to identify a potential for challenges rather than actual challenges. Further, as the author notes, the commercial Arab papers do not necessarily cover issues of vital importance to this community in a way that satisfies their readers or decisively break out of the narrative set forth by the Hebrew-language press.
It may be that the oppositional nature of this public sphere does not spring from the Arab media's substance but from Palestinian consumers’ critical relationship to the media and their openness to viewing Arab satellite stations from inside Israel. Gaining more in-depth perspectives from these Palestinian news consumers might clarify this possibility in future research. What critiques do Palestinians offer of specific coverage? How do consumers conduct the creative and critical work of putting different media sources together to manufacture a coherent worldview? Audience research is notoriously difficult, and while Jamal's surveys cover all Palestinian Israelis, this kind of research would necessarily have been more narrow, with a much smaller sample. Perhaps my interest in seeing such data stems from my own background in anthropology.
Another possibility is that the Arab public sphere in Israel is oppositional simply because its existence confronts Israeli dominance. Jamal elucidates official Israeli policies of attempting to co-opt the Palestinian minority through media and of marginalizing Palestinians from the dominant public sphere. Jamal powerfully argues that Hebrew-language Israeli media—even privately owned outlets—are closely affiliated with the Israeli state. Given the pervasiveness of state influence, collective acts of critical reading, producing media in Arabic, and consuming media from Arab countries should themselves be considered a challenge to the dominant public sphere. Jamal's elaboration of the strictures of the Israeli public sphere is a crucial contribution. It reshapes our understanding of the range of constraints that exist in a society consistently regarded as being democratic and a home to free speech in the region. Jamal's findings are especially important because most literature on media in Israel overlooks its Palestinian citizens and neglects to examine the relationship between the Israeli state and Israeli media.
This study is of vital importance to scholars interested in Israeli media, Palestinians inside Israel, the far-reaching and diverse impact of Arab satellite news, and minorities’ patterns of media consumption, especially in situations in which they are in conflict with state authorities. I highly recommend it for sociology or political science courses on media in the Middle East and for courses on media and democracy.
