In a book that has been viewed by some as controversial, Benner, Sutphen, Leonard, and Day, authors of Educating Nurses: A Call for Radical Transformation, argue that nurses in all programs of study are currently undereducated for contemporary nursing practice demands. Although this may be difficult to acknowledge, the authors’ straightforward evaluation of nursing practice and education, and their commentary on the present practice-education gap, is an essential starting point if we hope to improve on nurses’ ability to uphold and implement foundational professional values at the bedside.
The authors bring a variety of perspectives to this critique of the status quo in nursing and nursing education. Patricia Benner is a distinguished senior scholar with the Carnegie Foundation and professor emeriti at the University of California, San Francisco. Molly Sutphen is a research scholar at the Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching and assistant adjunct professor at the University of California, San Francisco. Victoria Leonard is a family nurse practitioner and child care health consultant at the University of California, San Francisco. Lisa Day is a clinical nurse specialist for neuroscience and critical care at the University of California San Francisco Medical Center.
Written for a wide audience, this book addresses substantive challenges faced by nursing education in meeting the needs of nurses who must function as part of a profession that is undergoing profound change. The work, based on the results of a multi-year study recently released by the Carnegie Foundation, included site visits to diverse nursing education programs and national surveys of nursing faculty and students. In reporting current findings, the authors also provide historical context for readers—many of the challenging issues discussed are not new to the profession.
The book’s 13 chapters are divided into five parts, plus an introduction and appendix describing methods for the Carnegie study. In the introduction, after noting that nursing education has failed to keep pace with the changes in healthcare and the complexity of caring for clients and families, the authors forward a call to redesign nursing education from structure and process perspectives. Bold actions targeting the domains of professional knowledge and the provision of nursing education at student, faculty, and program levels are suggested.
In part one of the book, the authors explore in greater detail the current landscape of nursing practice in the United States. Chapter 1 describes a transformed healthcare system and the associated responsibilities, challenges, and opportunities ushered in for nurses by such a significant transformation.
Chapters 2 and 3 discuss teaching and learning in clinical, laboratory, and classroom settings, focusing on effective ways of teaching the nursing knowledge base and helping students learn to use knowledge effectively. In chapter 4 the authors consider essential shifts that must be made by individual nurse educators and programs.
Parts two, three, and four of the book are structured around exemplar cases of excellence in teaching that demonstrate the importance of integrating knowledge, skilled know-how, and ethical comportment during the educational experience. Benner and co-authors provide examples of nurse educators who have made the recommended “shifts” in their approach to teaching. Paradigm cases are used to demonstrate teaching nursing students to think in relation to the particular demands of a situation (i.e., teaching for a sense of salience); teaching them to connect classroom and clinical settings (i.e., clinical imagination); and teaching for professional formation (i.e., moral imagination).
In part five, the authors call for a wholesale redesign of nursing education and offer recommendations targeting educational programs and policy. These persuasive arguments and recommendations focus on issues such as entry to practice, transitions between educational programs, diversity among students and faculty, licensure and accreditation, and national oversight.
I am convinced the authors are correct in viewing the present moment as a tipping point for nursing as a profession and that they have expertly articulated key areas for improvement in nursing education. They call for the profession to unite and act to regain excellence in nursing education in the face of mounting external and internal challenges. Yet, our collective inability as nurses to do just this sort of thing—unite and act—could be viewed as the root cause of the professional challenges described by the authors.
Regardless of nurses’ individual desire to uphold foundational professional values at the bedside or evolve pedagogic approaches, it could be argued that the capacity for change or transformation of the magnitude described by Benner and co-authors simply does not exist for nurses in healthcare settings or higher education. Although the authors’ underlying notions ring true, their arguments are compelling, and they outline an inspiring vision for schools, service providers, and the profession, my pragmatic nature leads me to doubt that our profession has the real capacity in our current healthcare system to unite and act across these levels.
As such, care is required in interpreting the magnitude of the change proposed in this book. As much as we want the profession to unite and act to bring about change, sadly, from the healthcare system perspective, nursing care has never been the coin of the realm. The caregiving rendered by the professional nurse continues to be viewed as an institutional cost, rather than an essential element associated with improved client outcomes. And from the perspective of higher education, teaching nursing fares no better than nurse caregiving in a clinical setting and continues to pale in comparison to research, publication, and receipt of external funding in the march toward earning tenure.
To this end, Educating Nurses: A Call for Radical Transformation, identified by some as a landmark publication, serves as a starting place at a significant moment in healthcare reform in the United States, and it provides an opportunity for self-assessment and growth. From the teaching perspective, I leave this work inspired to make the changes required to teach for a sense of salience and situated cognition. Yet I recognize my place in a system that will not reward that effort and those changes. From the chaotic healthcare system perspective, I remain hopeful that nurses in those systems will rise to the challenge and lay essential groundwork to move away from the current climate that rewards short-term focus and cost-saving over quality professional nursing care.
This work is a valuable contribution to the ongoing debate about essential changes needed to transform the profession. I laud the authors for undertaking an analysis of problematic issues facing the profession and for providing targeted recommendations for action. I suspect this work will serve as a needed catalyst for the change that must take place if we truly value nurses’ ability to uphold and implement foundational professional values at the bedside.
