Hussein Ghubash, the United Arab Emirates ambassador to UNESCO, originally published this work in French in 1998. In examining Oman from the mid-18th to the 20th centuries, he argues that its history and culture have been forged by an Islamic democracy based on the principles of shūrā (consultation), imāma (an elected imam), and sovereignty as defined by Ibadi political theory.
The book is divided into two parts, “The Imam State from its Formation to the British Colonial Order” and “From the Colonial Challenge to the Imamate Response.” Part I starts with a general overview of Omani history from ancient times to the 18th century and proceeds to chapters dealing with Ibadi doctrine and the medieval imamate; the period of Portuguese domination of the coast, with mention of French and Dutch involvement in Oman; the Yaʿariba period as an example of the ideal Ibadi state in early modern times; and the establishment of the Al Bu Saʿid state and its transition from an imāma to ṣultāna system of government. This part ends with a chapter on “Sahel Oman” (roughly, the current United Arab Emirates), focusing on its separation from Oman in the mid-18th century to the British protectorate of 1891, and a very brief conclusion. Part II begins with a discussion of the general features of modern Omani history, with the chapters on Omani relations with East Africa from ancient times to the Anglo–French declaration of 1862 recognizing the independence of separate sultanates of Muscat and Zanzibar, events surrounding the revolution and reign of Imam ʿAzzan b. Qays Al Bu Saʿid, the reign of Sultan Faysal b. Turki (1888–1913), Oman's struggle between independence and British domination, the 20th-century Ibadi revival, the subsequent division of Oman into imamate and British-dominated sultanate in Muscat, the “Revolution of 1955–1964,” and events surrounding the reunification of Oman by Sultan Saʿid b. Taymur. A general conclusion follows the Part II conclusion. Annexes present a list of imams and the Al Bu Saʿid sayyids/sultans, a genealogy of the Al Bu Saʿid, four maps, and a glossary of Arabic terms.
What Ghubash gives us is a fairly general survey of Omani history from ancient times to the accession of Sultan Qabus in 1970, with an emphasis on brief periods of imamate rule, especially since the early modern period. In between, Ghubash devotes nearly as much time to nonimamate history and international affairs, an approach acknowledged in the general introduction when the author states his intention to “study and portray Omani political history as a whole” (p. 11). The formative period of the development of Ibadi political theory and the medieval Omani imamate are briefly covered, with Ghubash recognizing the Khawarij origins of Ibadi political theory but placing much more emphasis on the inspiration of the Rashidun caliphate. The discussion of the “Islamic democratic tradition” begins in earnest with the description of the reign of Imam Sultan b. Murshid al-Yaʿribi (1624–49) (pp. 55–62), events that occurred over 500 years after the last effective period of imamate rule. The imamate ideal then disappeared for another 200 years, until the “revolution” and brief reign of Imam ʿAzzan b. Qays Al Bu Saʿid (1868–71) (pp. 122–35). The third (and last) example of Islamic democracy comes during the relatively long period of 1913–65, or the imamates of Salim b. Rashid al-Kharusi, Muhammad b. ʿAbd Allah al-Khalili, and Ghalib b. ʿAli al-Hinaʾi, with the reigns of the first and last again being termed “revolutionary,” the first because of his success in reestablishing an independent imamate state in the interior of Oman and the last for his struggle against Sultan Saʿid b. Taymur Al Bu Saʿid's successful effort to reunify Oman. Surprisingly, given the argument that Islamic democracy is a defining principle of Omani culture, Ghubash asserts that the imamate is “now [an] outdated institution” that is no longer “the historical alternative it once was and its political role no longer [meets] the demands of contemporary Omani society” (p. 202). So much for defining principles.
In its theme and organization, this book closely resembles John C. Wilkinson's The Imamate Tradition of Oman (Cambridge University Press, 1987). Wilkinson tends to be more thematic in discussing events to 1913 and emphasizes the importance of “tribe” over the Ibadi political ideal to the Omani polity; Ghubash is more chronological in his approach and, although he acknowledges the significance of tribe, focuses on the “Islamic democratic” ideal. The books closely parallel each other for 20th-century events, with both characterizing the actions of imams al-Kharusi and al-Hinaʾi as “revolutions.” Wilkinson does a better job on the impact of oil on reunification, and Ghubash brings in some new information about Arab League and United Nations discussions of the “Oman Question.” Both agree that the imamate tradition is no longer viable. In this reviewer's opinion, Wilkinson has written the superior work.
One can always find fault with sources, and I try to heed the advice of one of my graduate mentors that to do so is usually a “cheap shot.” However, Ghubash asserts that the “demands of objectivity and method have led us to have recourse to various sources, which have mostly not been much used or even known; among them French and English diplomatic archives, most of which are used for the first time here” (p. 11). This is a heady statement and generally not true. There are few French and English diplomatic archive sources, which have been the bread and butter of historians of Oman, that have not been used before, and although Ghubash has used several Ibadi sources published by the Omani Ministry of National Heritage, one should consult the Wilkinson book for a much more extensive list of primary sources, both from Oman and North Africa, most still in manuscript form. Finally, although of recent publication, research for the book seems to have concluded about 1991, but even a few important works published prior to that date seem not to have been used, most notably Patricia Risso's Oman and Muscat: An Early Modern History (New York: St. Martin's, 1986), on the early Al Bu Saʿid; Zamil al-Rashid's Suʿūdī Relations with Eastern Arabia and ʿUmān, 1800–1870 (London: Luzac and Company, 1981); and Edward Henderson's This Strange Eventful History (London: Quartet Books, 1988), on events of the 1950s.
Finally, Ghubash's editors and translator do not serve him well. There are many inconsistencies in transliterations. Mirdas bin ʿUdayya al-Tamiimi (p. 19) becomes Mirdas ibn ʿAdayat al-Tamimi (p. 27); “ibn” is transliterated almost indiscriminately (see p. 21, where ibn, bin and b. are all used on the same page), with the Saudi chronicler ibn Bishr becoming Ben Becher (p. 83); ʿAmr b. al-ʿAs is ʿUmar throughout; and the much disputed election of Aḥmad b. Saʿīd Āl Bū Saʿīd becomes even more complicated when one of the electors, Ḥabib b. Sālim Al-ʾUm Bū Saʿīdī, becomes Āl Bū Saʿīdī (p. 69), a mistransliteration that would lead one to believe the elector and imam were from the same tribe. Translator Turton turns the “Muscat and Oman Field Force” into the “force of the ‘terrain of Muscat and Oman’” (p. 181). I do not mean to nitpick, and this is not an exhaustive list, but errors such as these do tend to confuse the reader, especially those not familiar with Arabic or Islamic/Omani history.
All in all, however, Hussein Ghubash has presented us with a useful general survey of Omani political history emphasizing the Ibadi tradition.
