Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-z4zkx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T03:29:55.546Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Behavioral effects of employer-sponsored retirement plans

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  29 October 2007

STEVEN A. NYCE
Affiliation:
Watson Wyatt Worldwide (e-mail: Steven.Nyce@watsonwyatt.com)
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Many organizations have either already terminated their defined benefit (DB) plans or are thinking about it, in order to offload the financial and regulatory risks these programs pose. But plan sponsors should think carefully about how their decision might affect their workers' commitment and productivity – and ultimately their organization's success.

To answer those and other retirement questions, Watson Wyatt set out to learn how DB and defined contribution (DC) plans affect employees' workforce behavior and decisions. Watson Wyatt's Retirement Attitude Survey (WWRAS) found that, while most workers value both types of plans very highly, workers with DB plans generally appreciate their retirement programs significantly more than those with only a DC plan. This was particularly the case for those with a hybrid pension plan. This analysis found that retirement plan generosity and effective communication strongly affect a plan's perceived value to employees. This has important implications for plan sponsors, since greater plan appreciation is strongly linked to employee commitment. In fact, we found that workers covered by a defined benefit plan express a very strong commitment to their current employer, while DC plan coverage has no effect on employee commitment. This is partly owing to a selection effect, whereby firms with DB plans tend to attract more committed workers. However, even after controlling for the selection effect, DB plans exert an independent effect on the likelihood that employees will stay with their employer.

Information

Type
Research Article
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 2007
Figure 0

Figure 1.Creating value from your retirement programSource: Watson Wyatt Worldwide.

Figure 1

Table 1.Importance of the retirement plan to employees and impact on retention

Figure 2

Table 2.Employee satisfaction with DB plan and impact on retention

Figure 3

Table 3.Number of employees per employer-sponsor

Figure 4

Table 4.Descriptive statistics of respondents in the WWRAS

Figure 5

Table 5.Percentage of respondents who correctly identify their retirement plan

Figure 6

Table 6.Comparison of demographic characteristics between respondents who identify their retirement program correctly/incorrectly

Figure 7

Table 7.Importance of the retirement plan in attracting and retaining employees

Figure 8

Table 8.Importance of retirement plan in attracting and retaining employees by plan type

Figure 9

Table 9.DB plan satisfaction by plan design feature

Figure 10

Table 10.DC plan satisfaction by plan design feature

Figure 11

Figure 2.The impact of plan design on plan importance and employee satisfactionNotes: Estimates are based on a non-union, 40-year-old male high school graduate who earns $45 K annually. He has worked for his current employer for 10 years and saves outside the plan.Source: Watson Wyatt's Retirement Attitude Survey.

Figure 12

Figure 3.The Impact of communication and generosity on retirement plan importance and employee satisfactionNotes: Estimates are based on a non-union, 40-year old male high-school graduate who earns $45 K annually. His tenure is ten years with a company that sponsors both a traditional DB and a DC plan. He saves outside the plan. Differences in each level of communication and generosity represent a one-standard-deviation improvement.Source: Watson Wyatt's Retirement Attitude Survey.

Figure 13

Table 11.The impact of enhanced generosity and communication on retirement plan appreciation

Figure 14

Table 12.Retention effects of retirement plans

Figure 15

Figure 4.Employees' propensity to stay with current employer at various levels of plan importance and satisfaction by ageNotes: Estimates are based on a non-union high school graduate who earns $45 K annually, has worked for the employer for five years and saves outside the plan. Differences in predicted values of employees' propensity to stay represent a one-standard-deviation improvement in importsat. For the regression analysis, we included workers aged 21 to 60.Source: Watson Wyatt's Retirement Attitude Survey.

Figure 16

Figure 5.Employees' propensity to stay with current employer at various levels of plan importance and satisfaction by tenureNotes: Estimates are based on a 40-year-old male high school graduate who earns $45 K annually in a non-union job. His company sponsors both a traditional DB and a DC plan, and he saves outside the plan. Differences in predicted values of employees' propensity to stay represent a one-standard-deviation improvement in importsat.Source: Watson Wyatt's Retirement Attitude Survey.

Figure 17

Table 13.Projected impact of plan design, importance and satisfaction on young, middle-aged and older employees' likelihood of staying with current employer

Figure 18

Table A.1.Description of regression variables

Figure 19

Table A.2.1.Ordinary least squares estimates of factors that affect plan importance and plan satisfaction

Figure 20

Table A.2.2.Ordinary least squares estimates of factors that affect plan importance and plan satisfaction

Figure 21

Table A.3.1.Logit estimates of factors that affect employees' likelihood of staying with their current employer

Figure 22

Table A.3.1(continued). Logit estimates of factors that affect employees' likelihood of staying with their current employers

Figure 23

Table A.3.2.Logit estimates of factors that affect employees' likelihood of staying with their current employers

Figure 24

Table A.3.2(continued). Logit estimates of factors that affect employees' likelihood of staying with their current employers