Daniel Cavicchi's Listening and Longing: Music Lovers in the Age of Barnum is an ambitious, original book well worth careful reading for its integrated historical, historiographical, and methodological arguments. The bibliography alone will send readers to the library for scholarship not commonly pursued in American music history, even though it also reads like a who's who of members of the Society for American Music who write on nineteenth-century topics. The author's engagement with the subject is obvious as he grapples with complexities and chronological overlapping within nineteenth-century musical life in the United States. Reading the book, I experienced several “yes, but” moments, and I will have one important criticism to mention. Nevertheless, I see it as a significant and valuable study for anyone concerned with how and why humans of any era find expressive culture central to their lives.
Cavicchi centers his account on what he calls “audiencing”—“the reception of performances and works, the history of music consumption, the development of audience practices, and the uses of music in daily life” (4). He wants to foster a history of music in the United States from a listening perspective, one that would show today's listening practices as fully formed before the advent of twentieth-century technology. Although not a central theme of the book, this goal explains his choice of a topic freighted with conceptual and scholarly difficulties.
Rather than approach the topic in strictly chronological order, Cavicchi presents themes that return over the course of the book. In chapter 1, a ticket auction for an 1850 Jenny Lind concert in Boston frames the antebellum-era growth of entrepreneurially based musical performances. Drawing largely on secondary sources, this chapter describes how touring opera stars, singing families, and European virtuosos, among others, created a culture of performance and audience in urban areas. Chapter 2 explores a “crossover between cultures of hearing” (63) from church, theater, and oratory into music listening practices. Together, the first two chapters posit a new role for commercial presentations (occasionally “commercial music”) in enabling and shaping changes in audience practices, including responses to Barnumesque “ballyhoo” and increasingly controlled behavior in more sedate environments.
Chapter 3 uses the growing number of personal diaries that have survived from later in the century to show how young people integrated music into identity formation. (The bibliography lists twenty-six manuscript diaries along with letters, scrapbooks, and a few memoirs.) Chapter 4 draws on writing by Boston diarist Lucy Lowell in the early 1880s to describe a community of “music lovers” who sought serious and repeated involvement with music by Beethoven, Wagner, and others. The chapter is, in an important respect, conclusive: it points to the arrival of a developed concert culture (no longer labeled “commercialized”), through which listening had become a central form of musical experience. Chapter 5 examines criticism lobbed at musical connoisseurs, who were sometimes portrayed as monomaniacal or diseased, and at women, whose actions in furthering musical life were “proof” of their passivity and lack of creativity.
Finally, in an epilogue, Cavicchi nails down summary points about the individual agency he reads in the diaries:
To see participation in a concert as an audience member as merely an example of encroaching passivity egregiously reduces the significance of what was happening. … Shifts [such as urbanization and education] cultivated a younger generation of urban dwellers who were more willing than their parents or grandparents to try new behaviors. … This [development] can be seen in the changing language of the diarists, who, beginning at mid-century, talked about being able to choose to experience a particular performer or piece rather than simply “having music” (190).
The idea of individual choice is essential to Cavicchi's project; as he notes, Romanticism, psychology, and other approaches increasingly located music's power “in an individual's private emotional and intellectual responses” (164). Quotations from some of his concertgoing diarists support this understanding, which I see as the book's most important point.
Much of the material in the book will be familiar to readers knowledgeable about the period, as famous participants such as Barnum, Lind, Walt Whitman, George Templeton Strong, Margaret Fuller, and even Henry David Thoreau make their appearances. Other material is more original: The section on identity formation emphasizes the fascination and identification with specific performers that many of the diarists experienced. Given that they were all white, at least middle class, and before mid-century mostly male, the discussion of identity formation also calls attention to limitations on musical identity and aspiration imposed on African Americans and women.
The three later chapters, which connect new “audiencing” practices with public listening opportunities, offer extended summary statements—supported in detail—that highlight the most innovative and convincing aspects of the argument. Here, for example, Cavicchi comments on the musical experience of his star diarist, Lucy Lowell:
Lowell's diary offers not necessarily what we might like to know about her life but what she felt was important: a youthful expression of musical passion and a glimpse of a life profoundly shaped by the act of listening to music. … Her experience and her opinions in many ways represent the culmination of a developing culture after the Civil War in which auditory enthusiasm could organize one's daily activity, orient personal values, cultivate a sense of belonging, and shape new kinds of shared knowledge. This was a culture that deeply affected the lives of individuals who participated (118–19).
By putting an individual diarist at the center, such statements support Cavicchi's contention that the experience of listeners is valuable as a focus of historical inquiry.
The only aspect one might add to the account of Lowell's diary is the role particular musical works—she writes extensively about listening to Wagner—played in inspiring the time, thought, and engagement she invested. Readers primarily concerned with musical works will, in fact, be disappointed that Cavicchi has not explored the musical content the diarists are experiencing. However, his “music” is not a body of works, and the “work concept,” developed in Lydia Goehr's well-known book The Imaginary Museum of Musical Works: An Essay in the Philosophy of Music (Oxford University Press, 1992), is not in evidence. He explains, “I have purposefully refrained from any privileging of musical works or styles in order to move my thinking away from the analytical frame of ‘composer/text/performance’ so entrenched in academic music studies” (10). Listening and Longing, in fact, undermines Goehr's claim that by the nineteenth century Western musical life was regulated by a pervasive work-centeredness we recognize in today's formal musical culture.
I also think, however, that de-emphasizing musical styles undermines clarity on some of the broader social and intellectual issues Cavicchi considers. For example, it can be difficult to pin down a consistent argument about linkages among “music lovers,” various sorts of musical events and practices, and social class. He repeats an oft-stated contention that “yearning for a culture of refinement and European-style ‘gentility’” (7) encouraged the growth of “commodified listening” (6). Public listening opportunities (including those created for profit) were in fact essential to developing audience members’ listening skills and interest, and some of the diarists make it clear that they would rather listen to music than produce it. But he uses the term “music lovers” in at least three ways: to separate music-loving connoisseurs from ordinary concertgoers; to distinguish between professionals and inferior, music-loving amateurs; and to indicate members of a near-riotous audience at a Jenny Lind concert in 1850 (167). He also writes about “concert audiences’ mass hysteria over music and apparent ignorance of the manipulation involved in the marketing of music events” (156). In sum, Cavicchi is inconsistent and sometimes contradictory about the balance between music loving as a function of class aspiration and as a source of individual identity and engagement. Rather, the diarists seem to bounce between acting as agents using music for their own purposes and subsisting as victims of hegemonic forces.
Inconsistencies such as this one demand not only a careful reading, but also a strategic one. Confusion can arise between the author's report on a nineteenth-century attitude or thought and his own point. When I applied the nineteenth-century view, I usually found it more in keeping with the book's main theme. Further, at middle levels of interpretation, Cavicchi sometimes draws conclusions from secondary sources. He has an ear for pithy statements in the wide range of scholarship he uses. Although many of the statements ring true, they do ask readers to accept conclusions not fully supported within the book. Thus it is easy for readers to direct their closest attention to statements and arguments that appeal to their own prior understandings of the period or theories about musical life in general. Nevertheless, if one is aware of the intermittent Rorschach-like quality in the book and does not expect consistency at all levels of the argument, one will find insight, innovative use of primary sources, and an approach to music history worth the serious consideration the author has given it.
